28 ms·
As a cybersecurity practitioner and owner of a mid 7 figures budget to defend an enterprise, I am not unfamiliar with the costs (controls, staff, implementation
by toomuchtodo 2y ago
As a cybersecurity practitioner and owner of a mid 7 figures budget to defend an enterprise, I am not unfamiliar with the costs (controls, staff, implementation). But, the evidence is clear that the response was “no” to this effort, and no further action or negotiation to improve the security posture of these entities. I know what it looks like when someone says “we don’t have the funds for this, what can we do with what we have?” but also what it looks like when lack of funding is an excuse to take no further action. Republicans have made no effort to appropriate funding for this work at either the federal or state level, for example. If this matters to them, when can we expect this to happen? And how many people will have to be harmed first for it to happen?
> Republicans aren't a comic book villain;
Agreed, they’re much worse. “We’re going to spend nothing, and when something happens to you, too bad, so sad” under the guise of fiscal responsibility. But if that’s what you vote for as a voter, who am I to get in your way? This isn’t a problem to be fixed, this is an indicator of electorate intent.
> What if we took a good chunk of the EPA's budget and distributed it to the local water utilities directly (in other words: Your federal taxes go down, your county taxes go up).
This sounds like a recipe for fraud and waste due to the sophistication of those responsible at the local level, with no accountability.
- roenxi 2y ago> Agreed, they’re much worse. “We’re going to spend nothing, and when something happens to you, too bad, so sad” under the guise of fiscal responsibility. 1) What, Republicans don't need to drink water now? 2) I find it amazing. For decades the small government people have been arguing that centralising power to the national level is a bad idea because it creates a single point of failure. It is a real tell that people are play-acting with their concerns about the Republicans that they currently control all the major organs of the US government AND are led by Trump, but this is not enough to provoke a "gee, maybe centralising all these critical functions is a bad idea" response. The answer is still to concentrate power towards Trump and the Republican party, just to demonise them more vociferously. I mean gee. If there are a group of people who are so terrible at securing clean water, don't give them control over the water systems ~50% of the time. Let it all happen at the local or state level. Is this such a radical position?
- AlotOfReading 2y agoDo you think water systems are managed at the federal level? They're not. Municipal water supplies are primarily managed by local and state agencies. The feds get involved when there are environmental issues (EPA) or something directly under the federal prerogative comes up like federal lands, standardisation, the army, or interstate cooperation.
- roenxi 2y agoSo from your comment it seems you see a body that is basically advisory. Would I be correct in assuming you see no issue with getting rid of the parts of the EPA that deal in water? They don't sound like they do anything particularly important. They were probably overstepping their mandate with the cybersecurity stuff if your view is accurate; nobody needs to sue them if they don't exercise any control. Those functions could be wholly coordinated by the states or direct communication between relevant bodies by the way.
- forgetfreeman 2y agoWhen presented with an issue that poses a real and present danger to the drinking water supply of citizens of this country your contribution is pearl clutching over notional mandates? To be clear, in your opinion "overstepping their mandate" is the bigger threat here? Here's a wild idea, how about we return to the concept of actual governance for the first time in a few decades and actually empower the EPA with both budget and enforcement rights to ensure that local and state run systems that our fellow citizens rely on aren't falling through the cracks?
- roenxi 2y ago> ...your contribution is pearl clutching over notional mandates... > Here's a wild idea, how about we return to the concept of actual governance for the first time in a few decades... These two ideas are actually somewhat contradictory, I recommend picking one. You can't return to good governance by ignoring governance every time you think something needs to be done. And you don't need the EPA to be involved to defend against these sort of risks. In fact, standardising the IT approach through the EPA will might increase the risk since any vulnerabilities will be more likely to be standardised. Highly heterogeneous systems are expensive and difficult to cripple. If an adversary wants to attack there is a single point of failure they can target - the EPA process.
- 015a 2y ago> Republicans have made no effort to appropriate funding for this work at either the federal or state level, for example. The article states that drinking water systems for 26 million Americans are vulnerable to significant cybersecurity risks. What that obviously implies is that the drinking water systems for... 308 million Americans face an at least mitigated and acceptable level of cyber-risk. Are you stating that 308 million Americans live in counties led by Democrats, as they're the only ones capable of securing their water systems? Clearly that isn't the case. Are you crediting all of the good things about the good water systems to Democrats, and all the bad things about the bad water systems to Republicans, somehow? That feels unlikely; though I'm sure the federal government funds a significant amount of our local water systems' budgets, and currently the Republican party is the party of anti-federal government, obviously past and current Republicans also had a hand in creating some of that federal infrastructure and no one is saying it should entirely disappear. > This sounds like a recipe for fraud and waste due to the sophistication of those responsible at the local level, with no accountability. Its actually fascinating how Republicans would say the same thing of some of our federal institutions: That they've become so big that they're impossible to hold accountable. There's some truth in both extremes: but the Republican view is that the voting populace can more-easily hold their local government and utilities accountable than we're able to hold the federal bureaucracy accountable. Given the measurable performance and efficiency of some of these federal institutions; I do believe that Republicans are, at least, operating in good faith, even if I tend to side with Democrats directionally. Of course, we've become a culture of extremes: you're either in the party of "don't touch it, touching it is anti-federal and anti-democrat" or "tear it down and salt the earth it stood on", there's no in-between take that maybe these institutions just need an overhaul (well, there was [1], but it never panned out). [1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/climate-environment/2022/05/31/epa-biden-climate-chemical-safety/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/climate-environment/2022/05/3...