3 ms·
"Failure is not an option!" is a phrase that automatically annoys me when I hear it, because almost nobody who uses it actually understands what it means. It's
by smacktoward 14y ago
"Failure is not an option!" is a phrase that automatically annoys me when I hear it, because almost nobody who uses it actually understands what it means.
It's usually used in the sense of "we have decided to rule out the possibility of failure." But that's not really what the phrase means. What it means is that you have exhausted every possibility other than succeeding. It means that, to borrow a poker term, you're "all in" -- you have gotten yourself into a position from which there are only two ways out: success, and utter ruin.
This is what the screenwriters of the movie Apollo 13 were getting at when they coined the phrase (it's usually credited to NASA flight director Gene Kranz, but that's incorrect: see http://www.spaceacts.com/notanoption.htm http://www.spaceacts.com/notanoption.htm). When the Apollo 13 mission went awry, the NASA teams on the ground didn't have the option to accept failure, because failure meant the death of the three astronauts and probably the end of the moon landing program. There was literally nowhere else for the people involved to go. They were "all in" -- the astronauts especially, but even to some degree the men on the ground. (If you're a mission control specialist in 1970, and you get drummed out of NASA with the loss of three astronauts on your record, whaddaya gonna do, go work for the other space program down the street? Start your own? Your career is done.)
What most of the people who use this phrase miss is that rarely are they actually in that deep. If your social video sharing startup fails, you've lost a couple years of your life, and maybe some money. But you're not ruined. You're still alive; you still have your skills and talents; you can still go get a job somewhere. If you're smart, people will probably even lend you money to try again someday. You're down, but not out.
A true "failure is not an option" startup scenario would be one where, if the startup didn't take flight, you would lose every dollar and piece of property you own, all your academic and professional credentials would be revoked, and you'd be barred from ever working in technology again.
That's what "all in" looks like. It's fucking terrifying.
It's also much, much higher stakes than all but a few of us will every play for. Which is a good thing! But unless you're one of those few, if you go around talking about "failure is not an option," it makes you sound kind of stupid.
- kstenerud 14y agoFurthermore, if you do take entrepreneurship to that level, you are doing it wrong. Economic ruin is one thing, but gambling your ability to ever try again against such steep odds is fucking stupid. Entrepreneurs who succeed on their first try are extremely rare. Risk your entire fortune and the clothes on your back and the respect of your peers, but nothing more. Once you've hit rock bottom a few times, getting up again becomes second nature.
- dredmorbius 14y agoIt wasn't until I read Neal Stephenson's Anatham that I could finally pin a name on this logical fallacy: Diax's Rake. "Never believe a thing simply because you want it to be true" http://anathem.wikia.com/wiki/Diaxs_Rake http://anathem.wikia.com/wiki/Diaxs_Rake As "failure is not an option" is typically used, it's an "abandon all logic and evidence and punt on faith" mode of operation I see far too often, in which the meaning isn't "we find it acceptable to fail", but "because of our blind faith in some belief, we set the possibility of failure as zero. Particularly in various business inspirational literature and Republican Party military, foreign, economic, energy, and environmental policies. Articles such as this one make me wish for an option to downvote, rather than simply flag, submissions.