4 ms·
>The consensus is that gravity - outside of extreme mass/energy environments - works just as Newton described it to many many decimal places. It absolutely doe
by nimish 2y ago
>The consensus is that gravity - outside of extreme mass/energy environments - works just as Newton described it to many many decimal places.
It absolutely does not. Newtonian gravity occurs instantly. It has no notion of information taking time to propagate. But we know gravitational waves happen, so Newtonian gravity is wrong _at even very large scales_. If the sun disappeared Newton tells us we'd know immediately. In GR we'd know about 8 min later.
The bigger problem is not that the quantitative effect is large, but that the _qualitative_ difference of going from the instantaneous effect to one that needs to propagate is enormous. It's the whole point of relativity as a concept.
Even going to GEM as a true, non-singular linear approximation of GR would be a step up from Newton's laws, at least there we can have gravitational waves and causal flow of information.
- the__alchemist 2y agoThanks for bringing this up; this is the central reason why I'm skeptical of Newtonian models that predict dark matter, and why I don't think the term MOND makes sense as the simplest alternative.