3 ms·
Releasing software as open source does not invalidate patents. What happens is that if the software infringes, then you cannot use it even though it is open sou
by hollerith 14y ago
Releasing software as open source does not invalidate patents. What happens is that if the software infringes, then you cannot use it even though it is open source.
- rbanffy 14y agoajross' reasoning didn't lead to full invalidation, but a patent Nokia cannot use against Android or Linux is useless for Microsoft.
- hollerith 14y agoYou seem to believe that Nokia's having open-sourced some software confers on users and re-distributors of that software some sort of protection against Nokia's patents -- that certain behaviors that would have been infringement in the absence of the open-source license are somehow no longer infringement. If that is what you believe, I disagree. Sometimes a corporation will grant a license of any patents need to run a piece of open-source software -- IBM did that in the 1990s in regard to Linux -- but I do not know of any open-source licenses that incorporates such a patent licensing. Certainly GPL 2 does not. In other words, sometimes a patent holder will make a legally-binding promise not to sue any user or re-distributor of an open-source software for patent infringement, but all the open-source licenses I know restrict themselves to copyright and, to the first order, are silent on patents. (The qualification "to the first order" is necessary because IIRC GPL 2 includes language to the effect that if you try to use patents (or any other means -- but the language was added to address software patents) to discriminate among the recipients of your GPLed "changes", you lose the right to re-distribute the changes at all -- but note well that this language does not prevent a contributor of some changes from using its patents to stop the re-distribution of the changes altogether.)
- rbanffy 14y agoThe GPLv2 provides an implicit patent license. Imagine you hold a patent and publish some code that implements your patent under the GPLv2. Everyone who gets the program from you is granted, by the GPL, the right to use it. In order to use it, they'll need a license to your patent, which you can't deny because of the GPL. The GPL also stipulates they can give this program to other people, provided it is under the same terms. This grants downstream users the same rights to use your patents your direct clients have. I'd love to see this tested in court.
- hollerith 14y ago>Imagine you hold a patent and publish some code that implements your patent under the GPLv2. Everyone who gets the program from you is granted, by the GPL, the right to use . . . your patent, which you can't deny because of the GPL. It is rare that one can say with certainty how a court will find, so let me just point out that neither Eben Moglen nor the FSF agree with your position as quoted above. To be exact, their position as of the late 1990s (when I studied the GPL) is the opposite of your position, and they are very unlikely to have changed their position since then. This will probably be my last reply to you.
- ajross 14y agoIt depends on the license. Apache and L/GPLv3 both have explicit patent grants (GPLv2 does not). Most of what Nokia released was LGPLv2 I think. But regardless, I think there's a clear good faith argument to be made there. Telling the world "use this great stuff for free" and then suing them when they do it certainly seems counter to the spirit of good faith patent licensing.