2 ms·
In any organization, military or otherwise, there is a hierarchy of authority. The paint operator reports to their forperson who reports to shop floor manager w
by mmooss 2y ago
In any organization, military or otherwise, there is a hierarchy of authority. The paint operator reports to their forperson who reports to shop floor manager who reports to the ... etc. who reports to the CEO who reports to the board of directors.
It's generally not a good idea for the CEO or board member to directly manage the painter, because there is so much they don't know about the person, situation, paint, etc; that's why they delegate. Also it undermines all the managers in the chain. On the other hand, sometimes those costs are worth it, and it's better than the alternative - sometimes the bureaucratic rules get in the way, or the structure is malfunctioning, and you need to get things moving.
But none of that is not special to militaries.
> civilians should stay out of it
While it may be true practically in many cases, I think that phrase is antithetical to democracies and freedom. A big threat to democracy is a military that is above civilians in status, power, etc. And one big advantage of a democracy is an open society, where citizens can see and respond to issues; sunlight disinfects corruption.
- devilbunny 2y agoYou left out my leading phrase: if they are operating within their orders and military regulation. And civilians are quite entitled to question those. If the captain is within both of them and still commits a war crime somehow, you don't hang the captain, you hang the admiral.
- mmooss 2y ago> civilians are quite entitled to question those It might seem like a technicality, but my point is that civilians are entitled to question anything they want about the military - that's necessary for democracy. I would agree that it's usually not wise. > If the captain is within both of them and still commits a war crime somehow, you don't hang the captain, you hang the admiral. You hang both. Captains are officers, not automatons; they are responsible for their actions. But I agree that the admiral is the biggest issue, or maybe the secretary / minister of defense.