5 ms·

HN is also social media…

by mepian 2y ago

alexjplant 2y ago
Only by the loosest possible definition that would also encompass forums, IRC, game lobby chatrooms, etc. There's a clear and practical distinction between communities driven by a specific interest like this one and platforms like Xitter. Saying that HN is social media is like saying that a taco is a sandwich.
- Karrot_Kream 2y ago
  Disagree. That's what HN and IRC fans tell themselves to draw an artificial distinction between networks they like and networks they don't. I don't see a huge meaningful difference except in scale and content breadth.
  - alexjplant 2y ago
    There are _huge_ differences. Compare HN to Xitter et al: - Barrier to entry is higher and participation is tiered by karma - Moderation and community participation guidelines are heavier-handed and more defined - You can't embed media or have a profile picture - There's virtually no advertising anywhere - You can't delete posts after a few hours which means no way to nuke your presence after the fact - No hashtags - Far less algorithmic manipulation of user attention (infinite scrolling, per-user algorithmic feed, etc) - Encouragement of longer-form discussion because of a lack of (at this point historical, from what I understand) character limits on posts - Likes/upvote counts aren't visible to other users - No official app with telemetry and push notifications; in fact, no notifications _period_ for things like replies - No friend or follow mechanism My taco comment stands. Both a sandwich and a taco comprise flat, oblong starches with ingredients in the middle. One or two people have called them the same. In practice virtually nobody would confuse the two or substitute one for the other. People are migrating from Xitter to Bluesky but almost none are migrating to HN.
    - deleted 2y ago
      [deleted]
  - pseudalopex 2y ago
    Social media was coined to distinguish between platforms based on social graphs and older platforms like forums and IRC.
- samatman 2y ago
  I agree with you for what that's worth. I think there are two central criteria for some interaction-based online system to be called 'social media': follows, and DMs. Hacker News has neither of these things, so it isn't social media. YMMV.

HN is also social media…

by mepian 2y ago

HN is also social media…

Only by the loosest possible definition that would also encompass forums, IRC, game lobby chatrooms, etc. There's a clear and practical distinction between communities driven by a specific interest like this one and platforms like Xitter. Saying that HN is social media is like saying that a taco is a sandwich.

Karrot_Kream 2y ago
Disagree. That's what HN and IRC fans tell themselves to draw an artificial distinction between networks they like and networks they don't. I don't see a huge meaningful difference except in scale and content breadth.
- alexjplant 2y ago
  There are _huge_ differences. Compare HN to Xitter et al: - Barrier to entry is higher and participation is tiered by karma - Moderation and community participation guidelines are heavier-handed and more defined - You can't embed media or have a profile picture - There's virtually no advertising anywhere - You can't delete posts after a few hours which means no way to nuke your presence after the fact - No hashtags - Far less algorithmic manipulation of user attention (infinite scrolling, per-user algorithmic feed, etc) - Encouragement of longer-form discussion because of a lack of (at this point historical, from what I understand) character limits on posts - Likes/upvote counts aren't visible to other users - No official app with telemetry and push notifications; in fact, no notifications _period_ for things like replies - No friend or follow mechanism My taco comment stands. Both a sandwich and a taco comprise flat, oblong starches with ingredients in the middle. One or two people have called them the same. In practice virtually nobody would confuse the two or substitute one for the other. People are migrating from Xitter to Bluesky but almost none are migrating to HN.
  - deleted 2y ago
    [deleted]
- pseudalopex 2y ago
  Social media was coined to distinguish between platforms based on social graphs and older platforms like forums and IRC.
samatman 2y ago
I agree with you for what that's worth. I think there are two central criteria for some interaction-based online system to be called 'social media': follows, and DMs. Hacker News has neither of these things, so it isn't social media. YMMV.