4 ms·
Rule of thumb. If ever the government claims state secrets, they are playing their, "We did something wrong, and would like to get out of jail free" card. I k
by btilly 14y ago
Rule of thumb. If ever the government claims state secrets, they are playing their, "We did something wrong, and would like to get out of jail free" card.
I know of a number of cases where state secrets was claimed, then later it was proven that there was no actual state secret proven. (Including the very first case where state secrets were used as a defense in a court room.) I know of no cases where state secrets were claimed, and then there turned out to be an actual state secret at issue.
- mtgx 14y agoAnd then they will lobby to pass a law to make everything illegal they've done over the past 5-10 years legal, and of course retroactively.
- btilly 14y agoCase in point: FISA. :-(
- rhizome 14y agoCase in further point: FISAAA http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_Intelligence_Surveillance_Act_of_1978_Amendments_Act_of_2008 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_Intelligence_Surveillan...
- s_henry_paulson 14y agoThis is what happened. It was called the Protect America Act. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protect_America_Act_of_2007 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protect_America_Act_of_2007
- Animus7 14y agoThis is such a powerful and often-(ab)used argument that it genuinely horrifies me. It seems these days just about anything the U.S. government does can be justified under a binding legal ruling of "top secret, we can't hear this in our courts. But trust us, it's cool." Call me paranoid, but this is the reason I'm frightened of setting foot on U.S. soil.
- sneak 14y agoYou aren't paranoid. I packed up and left, leaving family, friends, job, and girlfriend all behind four years ago for this very reason. It sucks. A lot. (And I still visit, even.)
- wdewind 14y agoWhere do you live that's better?
- sneak 14y agoBerlin. Germany has a real economy, the Germans believe in good education (or at least skilled vocational training), there are tons of hackers, a great nightlife, and the rule of law. A big one for me was that the cops here ignore people who aren't criminals. Coming from the USA it's like a breath of fresh air.
- heretohelp 14y agoYou make it sound pretty good, but how does an American get a visa there?
- mixmax 14y agoI think that, paradoxically, Hitler and the nazis helped make Germans an honest and decent people that care greatly about the law and taking care of minorities. They've experienced what can happen if you don't.
- sneak 14y agoAlmost everything Hitler did was legal under German law. He just changed the laws first. There is a section on the Wikipedia page about the USA PATRIOT Act that illustrates the parallels with the Reichstagsbrandverordnung (Reichstag Fire Decree). The first section reads (translated): "Articles 114, 115, 117, 118, 123, 124 and 153 of the Constitution of the German Reich are suspended until further notice. It is therefore permissible to restrict the rights of personal freedom [habeas corpus], freedom of (opinion) expression, including the freedom of the press, the freedom to organize and assemble, the privacy of postal, telegraphic and telephonic communications. Warrants for House searches, orders for confiscations as well as restrictions on property, are also permissible beyond the legal limits otherwise prescribed." Sound familiar?
- rhizome 14y agoI know of no cases where state secrets were claimed, and then there turned out to be an actual state secret at issue. Part of the reason for this is that the US, unlike the UK, does not have state secrets law, so there is no actual legal definition of a state secret in the US. It's just a couple of words lawyers mumble in hopes that a judge will defer to their desires not to confront some fact.