6 ms·
US fertility rate dropped to lowest in a century as births dipped in 2023
- geenat 2y agoCost of housing
- hparadiz 2y agoI don't think this is accurate. I am far far far better off than either my grandparents or parents at this age and house ownership percentages in the United States are at the high end of what we had in the 60s and 70s. I think the real answer is that now people are faced with the choice and many are simply choosing not to.
- t-writescode 2y agoAre most people better off? Or just you? I know how a lot of people I know would answer.
- hparadiz 2y agoAmong my extended family, cousins, etc yes. Everyone has more square footage. Even double or triple. Even those that don't make six figures or live in Europe have much larger living spaces.
- t-writescode 2y agoWhen the only houses being built are monstrous, is that a useful metric? The majority of people I know don't own a house. They rent and they're in their 30s.
- ProfessorLayton 2y ago>I think the real answer is that now people are faced with the choice and many are simply choosing not to. It's not like they're choosing no in a vacuum. The price of housing bleeds into everything else being expensive too, especially in HCOL areas. Childcare is incredibly expensive, and in many cases it makes more sense for one of the parents to not work than to pay for it. That of course makes the calculus of having a child more complicated, let alone more than one.
- theendisney 2y agoSome 30-40 years ago there use to be stores here in the netherlands ran by old people who owned the building and the inventory. They live on the first floor. Almost no bills to pay. On a slow day they would sell 1 puzzle and 2 postcards. This was enough to buy food. I remember one that had motion detection lamps. If no one was in the store for 3 minutes the lights went off. In 2024 the new owner pays some 7-9000 per month and atleast 1000 worth of other bills. They also "own" a modest home that costs [say] 1500+600 and have some employees who also live in expensive houses. Shopping there is unsurprisingly expensive. Politics is artifically limiting construction and we all became the slaves of the owner class.
- michaelt 2y ago> I am far far far better off than either my grandparents or parents at this age Perhaps you have more disposable income and savings because you don't have the expense of supporting a stay-at-home wife and two kids?
- hparadiz 2y agoPeople have kids on the annual income I make in a month.
- anon291 2y ago> I think the real answer is that now people are faced with the choice and many are simply choosing not to. Moreover... many people are living very interesting engaging lives without kids that would have been impossible before due to the previous centrality of children to the social scene. In the past, not having kids was met with suspicion. Having children opened doors, economically, socially, and professionally, for better or worse. Today, you are probably going to have more opportunities without kids. Indeed having kids limits you, versus someone who does not.
- geenat 2y agoSmart people are not going to have kids in poverty or have a child with roommates.
- anon291 2y agoLiterally no one cares. This is not a major concern when deciding to have a child. Why don't we just ask the people that do have lots of kids. Not a single one, regardless of income (not everyone is rich), seems to really care. Truly we live in a rich country. No one who is not mentally challenged is going houseless. I recommend the book 'Hannah's children'.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoPrevious: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40164920 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40164920 - April 2024 (1 comment) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40157435 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40157435 - April 2024 (1 comment) Related: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40163251 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40163251 - April 2024 (79 comments)
- TheCoelacanth 2y ago[flagged]
- anon291 2y agoThis is a self-correcting problem. There are several subgroups in the United states with significantly above replacement rate. The basic statistics of stochastic processes and heritability of cultural practices regarding fertility and such dictate that those who have been able to resist the memetic pressure to have fewer children, will simply dominate. From an economic perspective, it doesn't really matter... A taxpayer is a taxpayer. From a political perspective, my guess is many people here won't like the simple results of natural selection.
- rconti 2y ago> memetic pressure to have fewer children What does this mean?
- kiba 2y agoPeople still want to have children, above replacement rate even. Problem is that we gate children behind careers and getting married which is atrocious because you will run out of years to start families if you wait too long. Until the cavalry for extending lifespan and fertility arrive, we need to fix our economic and cultural system right now.
- toomuchtodo 2y agohttps://www.axios.com/2024/07/25/adults-no-children-why-pew-data https://www.axios.com/2024/07/25/adults-no-children-why-pew-... > Stunning stat: 64% of young women say they just don't want children, compared to 50% of men.
- anon291 2y agoIt's simple memetic pressure. We've made out getting pregnant to be a bad thing. My wife and I married somewhat young, but hardly extraordinarily young -- age 22. When we conceived the first time, I remember going to the drug store with her to buy a pregnancy test and feeling ashamed at 23 to buy a pregnancy test -- ashamed that I got my wife pregnant! But it's simply due to the social conditioning that we're subjected to as teenagers. There's a weird American puritanism about sex, and it doesn't come solely from the religious right.
- maxsilver 2y agoIt's weird how wildly different this statistic is, compared to real life observation. At least in the midwest, we have had a record-high number of kids for the last 10 years or so (so many more kids that new schools keep being built to try to keep up with it because each new year the number of enrolled kindergarteners is higher than prior, daycare facilities have a minimum 1 year waiting list and many are closer to 2 years, summer camps sell out entirely in minutes, etc) I think people hear "low fertility rate" and just assume this means "adults aren't becoming parents" or "not enough kids being born". But if you spend 5 minutes on the ground, it becomes immediately apparent that we have the opposite problem -- there's so many more kids being born and raised than before, and most of our municipal/regional support systems for parents and children have not yet expanded to accommodate the slow-surge in births.
- infecto 2y agoThe US hit peak school age children a few years ago. Projections have it on a decline. While painted as midwest, I imagine these may be hyper-local issues. If you look at recent historical changes, there has not been some magic growth spurt and most states have been in a peak decline.
- genericone 2y agoSince the statistic applies to the whole US, it's biased towards urban population centers. E.g. the lack of K-12 kids in SF almost caused the shutdown of 11 schools due to the lack of funding that comes primarily from the number of enrolled students, they halted the closures in lieu of other cost saving approaches due to the political pressures of shutting down schools, but the truth remains that there are fewer kids in population centers.
- qwerpy 2y agoSame here in Seattle, both in the city proper and in the surrounding suburbs. Many public schools closing down due to lower enrollment. Partly because many parents are opting for private school, but also because there are fewer kids in the area. Many possible explanations: It's expensive to afford a big enough house for a family, people are having fewer or no kids, many people unable to find a partner, etc.
- settsu 2y agoNow someone do a chart with data that includes fertility rate, neonatal outcomes/infant mortality, healthcare availability/affordability, social safety net, cost of living, wealth equality/disparity, happiness, etc.
- throwaway1115 2y agoAn anecdote: Me and my wife live in Canada, with universal healthcare, and pay around 250k in taxes annually. We also have fertility problem. Our treatment costed over 100k so far and (yes, $100,000), all out of pocket. Worse that that, for some treatment (egg donation) we had to go abroad because laws in Canada prevent it! Somewhere I read 10% of families struggle with similar problem, and I'm sure many are not as lucky as me to have the means to spend this much. After spending so much, we finally could have our first child. But it's really hard to continue for the second one. The main problem is cost and traveling abroad. At the same time, I see govt spend so much effort for LGBTQ gender change and similar treatments. With such upside down policies, news like this is no surprise at all. Im liberal in most policies, but this in and of itself is enough to vote against liberals/dems.
- t-writescode 2y agoSo are you wanting to vote against transgender healthcare? Or against universal healthcare as a whole? Wouldn’t it be better to vote *for* additional rights rather than *against* someone being helped? Rising tide vs bucket of crabs, after all.
- longtimelistnr 2y agoThese kinds of people dont think rationally
- ineedaj0b 2y agorationally, budgets are constrained. any process that increases the number of potential tax payers is good. reassignment surgeries are elective, those receiving them do not pay more taxes, so priority should be given to fertility treatments.
- t-writescode 2y agoGender affirming care, including surgeries, increases the quality of life of transgender individuals, which can help make them more productive and even patriotic members of society and which can encourage other transgender individuals and those that believe in transgender rights into the country, potentially overall improving overall throughput and profit and taxes to pay for it all.
- mwcremer 2y agoInteresting paper exploring possible causes: https://pubs.aeaweb.org/doi/pdfplus/10.1257/jep.36.1.151 https://pubs.aeaweb.org/doi/pdfplus/10.1257/jep.36.1.151
- anon291 2y agoI think we should all be skeptical of any 'expert' views given the recent election being so disastrously misunderstood and unpredicted. In particular, I feel when it comes to these social issues, so much time is spent 'researching' that no one thinks to do the obvious and ask people who do have large families what made them do that. In particular, the book 'Hannah's children' comes to very different conclusions than the sorts of things you see here, and better matches my own understandings of those with large families, as well as my own motivations to have a larger family. https://www.independent.org/publications/tir/article.asp?id=2033 https://www.independent.org/publications/tir/article.asp?id=... https://www.c-span.org/video/?537667-16/hannahs-children https://www.c-span.org/video/?537667-16/hannahs-children To summarize: > While not all of the women she interviewed cited religious reasons or motivations for their choice to defy the birth dearth, most did. So faith, while not a prerequisite for the choice to have more children, is at least a catalyst. Greater religious liberty, especially with respect to educational choice, would allow for competing narratives of womanhood to re-enter the educational environment and allow women to choose narratives of self that more accurately account for the reciprocal opportunity cost of motherhood and career. I could not agree more. Every large family I know eschews the public school system FWIW.
- dqv 2y ago> > While not all of the women she interviewed cited religious reasons or motivations for their choice to defy the birth dearth, most did. So faith, while not a prerequisite for the choice to have more children, is at least a catalyst. Greater religious liberty, especially with respect to educational choice, would allow for competing narratives of womanhood to re-enter the educational environment and allow women to choose narratives of self that more accurately account for the reciprocal opportunity cost of motherhood and career. I could not agree more. lol, never miss an opportunity to make your pet political issue the solution I guess. Not going to miss mine either. Let's back up to the part about faith playing a role. It is actually not faith itself that plays the role, it is the organization surrounding that faith. Having a support system is incredibly important when raising a child, even if that just means getting moral support at the weekly social gathering for mothers. But people are turning their backs on these institutions. Why? Because they suck. No, it's not the people who suck, it's the institutions. https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2024/08/13/gen-z-women-less-religious/74673083007/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2024/08/13/gen-z-... It turns out that, in modern times, young women know LGBT people and actually like them! They also don't like organizations that espouse hateful messages about them (yes, saying someone will burn in hell for an eternity for being gay is an incredibly hateful message, no amount of twisting words will change that). The article goes into the other aspects of the conservatism turning people away from organized religion. Religious institutions are important and can play a role in giving mothers the community they need to flourish. Unfortunately, conservatives would rather destroy community than adapt to the times. As a local "true" Christian said in a review of a local affirming church: "one star, not biblical, they just talk about how to be a nice person". Damn... that affirming church rejecting the good news by *checks notes* telling people to be nice to one another. Maybe that review was an incredible act of compassion, because it really has me considering going to that church.
- ChrisArchitect 2y agoMisleading, article from April Some discussion then: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40163251 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40163251
- stego-tech 2y agoWildfires burning, oceans rising, glaciers melting, dual incomes can’t buy a home, can’t have a good quality of life without a college degree that’s ever-increasing in cost and decreasing in returns, food prices are rising, global conflict is on the rise, populism is boosting authoritarian regimes worldwide, widespread belief in younger generations that we’ll never be able to retire, cost of healthcare can bankrupt all but the richest of the rich… “Why aren’t people having children?” These articles were awful when it was “Millennials are killing X”, and they’re even worse now. The answers are obvious, and I’m tired of entertaining these clickbait narratives that refuse to acknowledge any of the very large elephants in the room.
- viraptor 2y agoThis is explicitly the opinion of some of my friends. One is the married couples broke up because only one of them felt really strongly about it. Many discuss this openly. It's weird to see this downvoted like some weird idea.
- stego-tech 2y agoI mean, your statement says it all plain as day. What used to be the norm - having kids freely and often - is now a discussion. While some people may try to blame that on civil rights, listening to stories from the extended older family as a kid paints a picture that we (as humans) will have as many kids as we feel we’re able to support, and as often as we feel safe doing so, when left to our own devices. And if that’s the case, then the question answers itself.
- anon291 2y agoSeriously... seeing how people discuss this is so strange. My wife and I literally just did the deed and made a baby. Didn't think a whole lot about it. But as I've said elsewhere in this thread. Part of this problem is that that 'let's-just-have-fun' attitude tends to dissipate by the time people are having kids these days. My wife and I married young for the 'well-educated' crowd (at 22), and I think my family size benefited from our collective on-going brain development. We did not even discuss this before getting pregnant the first time. It was just fun. I think as people age, hormones go down, etc, people start making this a bigger decision.
- alfiedotwtf 2y agoIdiocracy was a documentary
- mschuster91 2y agoWhat a surprise, given today's headline of women being asked to pre-pay the cost of births before delivery [1]. People can't afford housing decently sized for children, people can't afford birth itself (or medical complications), people have to work too much to care for children. [1] https://www.cbsnews.com/news/baby-birth-costs-women-asked-to-prepay-delivery/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/baby-birth-costs-women-asked-to...
- nineplay 2y agoI think that there's a greater societal problem that's causing ripples everywhere, including issues that came up in the recent election. Women are realizing that stay-at-home wife/motherhood is a really bad job. 24/7, room and board only, and are much like the company jobs of yore where if you leave or the company goes under, you may find yourself with nothing or worse, a pile of debt. So what's happening for the first time generationally is that women don't really _need_ men. They don't need the money, they don't need the children, they don't want the loss of independence. Men, particularly young men, are having trouble adjusting to this. They've been raised to believe that having a wife is part of the natural order of things, that being a breadwinner is part of the natural order of things. The whole 'trad wife' meme fed into this dream of coming home to a hot meal, a adoring wife, and obedient children. That's just not something that is going to happen anymore and only men are having a problem with it. I don't have any idea what to do about it. Sometimes the response to greater women's liberation is for men to take advantage of their greater strength and size and force women back into the homes. I'm hoping that's not inevitable.
- etrautmann 2y agoI've heard this over and over but don't see it anywhere around me (NYC, likely overeducated, doing fine but not wealthy). I know a lot of couples that have a kid but face major financial constraints. Up and down the socioeconomic spectrum, it's expensive as hell to have a family, house and educate them, and that's a major part of the calculus for even moderately well-off families.
- nineplay 2y agoYou don't see declining fertility rates?
- wakawaka28 2y agoPeople young enough to be having kids often don't have a sense of what was normal a few years ago, much less decades ago.
- 2y ago
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- imartin2k 2y agoMy hypothesis is that human progress (social, technological, moral, economic) is by definition at odds with having children. The more advanced we get as species, the less attractive it becomes (for most) to have children (many, or at all). And there’s nothing strange about it. You could even say: The individual’s need to have children - many or at all - was a bug in the human operative system, born out of circumstances that are being eradicated with human advancement. And I’m meaning this completely dispassionately, not in any way labeling this as good or bad. One could call it paradox of human progress. We are advancing to the point at which we eliminate the process that so far has sustained us as a species. The only ways out I see are that existing human lifespans are expanded significantly (with all the challenges this brings), or that childbirth is being entirely/partially offloaded from women to private/government-run incubating machines (sounds dystopian, I know).