> But what you describe is basically done by any human on Earth You don't simply learn on training data, you are taught by other humans who were in turn taught

> But what you describe is basically done by any human on Earth You don't simply learn on training data, you are taught by other humans who were in turn taught by more humans still. When you do learn genuinely new information, you know exactly how it makes sense to you, and you can share it with others in a way optimized for them to incorporate it as well. LLMs aren't just learning to speak and read, they are developing from scratch a framework for comprehending the training data thrown at them. An LLM has no concept of phonetics because it has no ears with which to hear nor a mouth with which to speak. It derived english from pulses of electricity. Leave a child in a box with no human contact and a library of books and perhaps it will ascribe meaning to the symbols written on the pages, but it will never know what they actually mean. Even if they lived a million lifetimes, and were able to recognize that the symbols appear with certain regularity and could infer some rules of the language, they would never know what concept the string "comprehension" refers to.