3 ms·
Mass Deportation: Devastating Costs to America, Its Budget and Economy
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- toomuchtodo 2y agoIf you don’t experience consequences for poor governance decisions, you don’t learn.
- tdeck 2y agoThe problem is that the people who experience the worst consequences are often those who had the least power over the decision to begin with.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoIt is unfortunate democracy and an unsophisticated electorate has led us here. All you can do now is attempt to protect the vulnerable while allowing the culpable to experience what they've voted for.
- quickthrowman 2y agoPeople with incomes under 50k/year overwhelmingly voted for the winner in the recent election, perhaps they’ll reconsider when chicken is $15/lb and strawberries are $10/pint, roof replacement costs doubling, etc. They likely do not understand the impact that illegal immigrant labor has on food affordability, but they might find that out now. Hopefully congress will increase SNAP benefits if food prices start spiraling upwards.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- TeaBrain 2y agoPeople making 30k to 100k on average voted for the winner. People making less than 30k or more than 100k did not.
- quickthrowman 2y agoThanks for the clarification
- AnimalMuppet 2y agoWould it be a net win for them, or a net loss? Prices will go up, but shouldn't wages go up as well (because there are fewer people to work, and we still want the work to get done, so supply and demand dictates a higher price for work)?
- toomuchtodo 2y agoThere is robust evidence Americans are not going to do the jobs migrants are doing, and businesses will not be willing to pay a living wage for those remaining authorized to work in the US. Prices will go up. Supply and demand. Farm fields, dairy farms, construction, slaughterhouses, seasonal work, hospitality, etc [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7]. So, assume you're going to deport the people who do these jobs (~8M unauthorized people are in the US labor force, total unauthorized is ~11M-15M). Also consider that Boomer retirement is ramping, and is roughly 11,200 per day or 4.1M per year [8]. Unemployment is still historically low. Who is going to do this work? [1] https://www.pewresearch.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/20/2020/06/ft_2020.06.10_unauthorized_02.png https://www.pewresearch.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/20/2020... ("Unauthorized immigrants account for nearly a tenth of all US workers in food industries") [2] https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2020/06/10/a-majority-of-americans-say-immigrants-mostly-fill-jobs-u-s-citizens-do-not-want/ https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2020/06/10/a-majorit... ("A majority of Americans say immigrants mostly fill jobs U.S. citizens do not want") [3] https://www.pbs.org/newshour/economy/how-migrant-workers-have-contributed-to-strong-u-s-job-growth https://www.pbs.org/newshour/economy/how-migrant-workers-hav... ("How migrant workers have contributed to strong U.S. job growth") [4] https://www.npr.org/2024/04/26/1242236604/florida-economy-immigration-businesses-workers-undocumented https://www.npr.org/2024/04/26/1242236604/florida-economy-im... ("A year later, Florida businesses say the state's immigration law dealt a huge blow") [5] https://civicmedia.us/news/2024/11/14/wisconsin-farmer-calls-election-results-a-disaster-for-agriculture https://civicmedia.us/news/2024/11/14/wisconsin-farmer-calls... (“The election outcome is an unmitigated disaster for the state’s agriculture-related businesses,” Breitenmoser explains. “Trump criticized immigration policies that overall target essential farm workers, many of whom come from outside the U.S. Our dairy and meat industries rely heavily on these workers and sending them home or restricting immigration threatens to collapse Wisconsin’s agricultural economy.”) [6] https://eyeonhousing.org/2024/03/states-and-construction-trades-most-reliant-on-immigrant-workers-2022/ https://eyeonhousing.org/2024/03/states-and-construction-tra... ("States and Construction Trades Most Reliant on Immigrant Workers, 2022") [7] https://limos.engin.umich.edu/deitabase/2024/05/28/undocumented-construction-workers-us/ https://limos.engin.umich.edu/deitabase/2024/05/28/undocumen... ("The perils of Undocumented Construction Workers in the United States") [8] https://www.cnbc.com/2024/02/08/baby-boomers-hit-peak-65-in-2024-why-retirement-age-is-in-question.html https://www.cnbc.com/2024/02/08/baby-boomers-hit-peak-65-in-... ("As baby boomers hit ‘peak 65’ this year, what the retirement age should be is up for debate")
- sschueller 2y agoI can guarantee one thing and that is that they will not learn. These kinds of people do not learn from their mistakes. They find scape goats to blame and will try the same thing the over and over again like the fools they are.
- nostrademons 2y agoI don't think that's true: "Americans can always be trusted to do the right thing, once all other possibilities have been exhausted." -- Winston Churchill I think that once the chips are down and their are real consequences for failure, Americans learn pretty quickly. There just have to be real consequences for failure, personally experienced.
- consteval 2y agoThe game of fascism is you always blame some group for all your problems, typically a minority. If the particular target of a fascist ideology is removed and issues still persist, you just pivot to another minority.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- rectang 2y agoThe presidential government system has the flaw of the citizenry ascribing blame or credit to the president for effects that they had no hand in. It impedes learning from mistakes, compared with the parliamentary system where the accountability is somewhat more direct.
- dzhiurgis 2y agoAre you saying Trump didn’t set draconian sanctions on Cuba and Venezuela causing mass migration and essentially cooking elections?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- borroka 2y agoWhile I understand the logic behind deportations, and may or may not appreciate the policy itself, I do not understand the logic behind maintaining the status quo. What is the policy and vision of those who oppose any deportation of illegal immigrants (we use "undocumented" now, which gives the impression that they left their papers in the washing machine, not that they can't have them because they shouldn't be in the U.S.)? Full disclosure: I am an immigrant myself, and I have spent money and time following a cumbersome process that I have complied with anyway. Some, and surprisingly most of them are very left-wing, say that without illegal immigrants everything would cost a lot more, which seems to me to be an invitation to exploitation that is somewhere between funny and absurd. Some suggest legalizing everyone, thinking that people like me who follow laws and procedures are nothing but fools, and that making millions of people "legal" would have no impact on government and public finances. Moreover, making everyone "legal" would give the unpleasant impression that domestic policy is dictated by foreign people and countries, that laws are not really relevant, and that everyone is welcome and will receive goods and services. The same reasoning applies to Europe, whose domestic policies are dictated by North African and Sub-Saharan countries. And reciprocity, what is this strange word? Moroccans apply for Spanish or Italian citizenship, "simple procedures", they ask. But try to get Moroccan citizenship as a foreigner. It is impossible.
- GauntletWizard 2y agoThe logic is very easy: Certain groups objectives are not "Everyone lives well" or even "I live well", they are "I live well in comparison to those I see around me". They do not say it aloud and they are not very bright, but by their actions and what compromises they are willing and unwilling to accept you can eke out their true utility function. They thrive in chaos because they receive relative pleasure from seeing others fall, and even more from importing the miserable and keeping them miserable. To be perfectly honest, everyone does this. Schadenfreude is an inherently human trait. The relative weight is different by person, though.
- quickthrowman 2y agoPresident Lyndon B. Johnson once said > If you can convince the lowest white man he's better than the best colored man, he won't notice you're picking his pocket. Hell, give him somebody to look down on, and he'll empty his pockets for you.
- atemerev 2y agoI wonder how nobody talks about moral considerations of this atrocity. Just like 80 years ago. “Do we have enough livestock cars to move them _all_ to Poland?” I am scared for the future of our civilization.
- rmah 2y agoThere is no need to be hyperbolic. The US has regularly deported up to 1/2 a million people per year for over a decade until 2020 or so. Some years, the number of deportations exceeded 2 mil. This policy is just a return to the status quo. https://ohss.dhs.gov/topics/immigration/yearbook/2019/table39 https://ohss.dhs.gov/topics/immigration/yearbook/2019/table3...
- atemerev 2y agoAnd you actually think this is good?
- rmah 2y agoI purposefully did not state my feelings on the matter.
- sabarn01 2y agoThere is a large democratic majority that supports border enforcement including deportation. Shouldn't the policy conform to the majority.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- atemerev 2y agoNo, total majority rule without safeguards is no better than tyranny. Even ancient Greeks knew that. So did founding fathers.
- t-writescode 2y ago
- tim333 2y agoThe article seems to assume the government will behave in a rather dumb way costing link $150k to remove each immigrant but I'm sure there are more efficient ways things could be sorted out? I'm not American so I'm not that up on the details.