3 ms·
The fact that every discipline uses the same test for admissions says more about the quality of academia than the scores.
by Alex3917 18y ago
The fact that every discipline uses the same test for admissions says more about the quality of academia than the scores.
- ojbyrne 18y agoThere are eight additional subject specific tests related to specific discliplines. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graduate_Record_Examination#GRE_Subject_Tests http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graduate_Record_Examination#GRE...
- dissenter 18y agoYes, and let's not forget that a generalized test is still useful at the graduate level, for a variety of reasons. The one that comes to mind when you mention subject tests is that people sometimes switch disciplines. I have several friends who went from math to physics and vice versa. They intended to research problems which are closely related to what they've done in their own department but that just happen to be worked on by professors in the other. Does it make sense to hold a math major up to the standard of a physics major taking the physics subject test? No way---he couldn't possibly compare, even though he may be more ably suited to tackling a problem that's being worked on in the physics department. So having a generalized quantitative/analytical section is helpful in at least this case. If the physics professor looking at your application knows nothing about what his colleague is doing (your intended advisor), at least he has a reasonable indication you aren't a dunce.
- Jebdm 18y agoWell, that's probably the leftover liberal arts philosophy that seems to be so common among college administrators.
- time_management 18y agoAt good schools, the GRE is just a formality, especially the general test. Research experience and recommendations are more important. Top math and CS departments don't really care about the GRE general at all.
- neilc 18y agoThis is absolutely true. Top CS programs don't even care about the CS GRE very much, at least in my experience (e.g. I didn't have time to write it before applying to grad school, and it wasn't a big deal).
- Alex3917 18y agoSo the "best" schools make you take a test they don't even care about? Yeah, they sure sound really good to me.
- eli 18y agoWell, no, it's not required everywhere. And the GRE isn't meaningless, it's merely one factor among many.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- davi 18y agoI don't think this is true in neuroscience -- GREs are more than a formality.
- tokenadult 18y ago"The fact that every discipline uses the same test for admissions says more about the quality of academia than the scores." What discipline is completely without use for reading skill, or for the kind of secondary school mathematics that appears on the GRE quantitative section?
- Alex3917 18y ago"What discipline is completely without use for reading skill, or for the kind of secondary school mathematics that appears on the GRE quantitative section?" The GRE doesn't measure reading skill, that's what the NALS is for. The GRE verbal is just a test of how many wank words you've memorized. Same goes for the math test.
- tokenadult 18y ago"The GRE verbal is just a test of how many wank words you've memorized." Evidence for this? (By which I mean, do you have any evidence that the GRE verbal section has failed validation studies to which it has been subjected by graduate schools?)
- physcab 18y ago"The fact that every discipline uses the same test for admissions says more about the quality of academia than the scores." That is not necessarily true. Its a testament to how education is treated as a commodity by College Board and ETS. Academic programs don't care what your scores are. They only use them to help you get fellowships so they don't have to pay for your salary. The real shame with the GRE is that it says nothing about the quality of the student. I knew someone who just failed their qualifying exam and is getting kicked out, even though he scored a PERFECT on the GRE and had external funding.
- ssharp 18y agoSo what is the answer to this problem? The GRE is a pretty generalized test. Most undergrad programs use either the generic SAT or ACT as their test factor - it's a efficient and useful way to measure a large group of people. The most important prerequisite for most graduate programs is an undergraduate degree in that field. How you performed (as well as the quality of the program you graduated from) is likely the most useful tool, so I can see how the GRE would be downplayed. In some graduate programs, specifically law and business, what field your undergraduate degree is in isn't that important. I'm guessing this is why the LSAT and GMAT tend to weigh more in admission decisions than the GRE does.