3 ms·
> Part of the problem is that the law didn't seek to distinguish between tame first-party tokens and the really naughty third-party tokens Maybe I'm an outlier
by ryandrake 2y ago
> Part of the problem is that the law didn't seek to distinguish between tame first-party tokens and the really naughty third-party tokens
Maybe I'm an outlier, but ideally I don't want them collecting any "tokens" without my consent. I don't care if they're first party or third party or birthday party. I should be able to browse web sites in peace without some company collecting anything. If the web site doesn't work exactly the way I'd expect because I did not provide that consent, then that's on me.
- self_awareness 2y agoWell that's a thought everyone can identify with, but objectively speaking, they're paying with their energy to build the website, and paying their money to host it. Yet you would want to browse it for no cost at all. How to resolve this?
- hnbad 2y agoYou're framing website use as transactional but for financial transactions we literally require informed consent. Also you seem to be operating under the assumption that your personal data is something that can be used as payment. The GDPR literally does not allow that just as human rights don't allow committing yourself to indentured servitude. You can't sign away your rights. If you share personal data you continue to have rights to that data and can revoke your consent. It doesn't stop being your data just because you handed it over, even if you did so willingly. If your business model can't work without exploiting your users' personal data, your business model no longer works and it's your job to find a new business model that does. There are plenty of business models that only worked when indentured servitude was legal (let's not have the debate about prison labor in the US) and I'm sure you would agree that it's fine for those business models to no longer work. It's part of the risk of doing business. Innovate. Disrupt. Or perish.
- smolder 2y agoThere is basic non-identifying logging that is almost entirely necessary to operate a website. I assume you're okay with that much?