2 ms·
> Remember we're talking about a very different world from the one we actually live in, a world where banks aren't allowed to lend at longer terms than they bor
by philwelch 14y ago
> Remember we're talking about a very different world from the one we actually live in, a world where banks aren't allowed to lend at longer terms than they borrow. In such a world health insurance would presumably also be very different....
So that's your solution, throw away the world and start over again? This kind of thinking gets very unappealing when you realize that for all its flaws, the world seems to work fairly well as it is--and that empirically-based, stepwise improvement on the status quo is a safer and more reliable way to go than hoping some ideology is going to work better.
- pdonis 14y agoIt's not my "solution", it's my description of what a hypothetical world might be like in which we didn't expect the difficulties of things like finance and health care to be hidden from us by schemes like banks borrowing short and lending long, and governments hiding from us the real costs of the health care we receive. I agree completely that the actual world we live in is nowhere near that hypothetical world, and that we aren't going to get to that hypothetical world in one giant transition. However, I would also observe that what we are doing now is not a "stepwise improvement" towards that hypothetical world or anything like it. Instead we move in the other direction--more of the real costs of financial tricks and health care are hidden from us.
- philwelch 14y agoI said empirically based stepwise improvement, not stepwise transition towards some ideologically driven fantasy world.
- pdonis 14y agoThen how do you define "improvement"?
- philwelch 14y agoEmpirically. Certainly not by comparison to some ideological ideal, but by analyzing the net results. If something "shouldn't" work, but appears to produce the correct result, I change my theory to match the new evidence. For instance, empirically, lots of governments "hide the cost of health care" by setting up universal health care programs, and in every country that's economically, technologically, and culturally similar to the US, the result is improved health care metrics and lower costs per capita. I could wave my hands around and say that's the wrong way to go, based on some crackpot ideology cooked up by a Russian novelist on speed. Believe me, I've tried that. But it's easier and saner to just use normal empiricism instead. The problem with monetary policy is that it's nigh-impossible to do proper empiricism on it. What we can say is that we certainly aren't experiencing any major catastrophes that we didn't encounter with the gold standard, and in fact a lot of the problems we faced then are no longer possible.
- pdonis 14y agoI actually agree with your general methodology. I'm not sure I agree with all your factual claims.
- einhverfr 14y agoDoesn't insurance hide the costs of health care?
- pdonis 14y agoWhat we currently call "health insurance" does, because it's actually more than just insurance; as I commented before, it's more like insurance plus an extended maintenance contract. Normal "insurance", like auto insurance or homeowner's insurance, only covers large, unforeseen expenses; it doesn't cover regular maintenance, and it doesn't cover things like buying new appliances when the old ones wear out.