3 ms·
It would make more sense to have insurance against the less likely risk, like a bank run.
by philwelch 14y ago
It would make more sense to have insurance against the less likely risk, like a bank run.
- pdonis 14y agoWhat you're calling "insurance" against a bank run is a central bank printing money. For examples of how well that works out in practice, see the Great Depression and the economy right now.
- philwelch 14y agoA fair appraisal of fiat money would be the entire history of economic development since the 20th century, and on that standard it looks quite different. The world is far richer today than it was when the gold standard was abandoned.
- pdonis 14y ago> The world is far richer today Agreed, but the relevant comparison is the way the world is now, compared to the way it would have been if the gold standard had not been abandoned. Unfortunately there is no way to re-run the experiment to see. However, there is at least one interesting indication: the worst depression in history, the Great Depression, happened after we went off the gold standard and after we established the Fed to supposedly control the money supply so boom and bust cycles would be controlled.
- philwelch 14y agoThe Fed's major mistake in the Depression was not printing enough money--the money supply contracted and started a deflationary spiral. Solution: go ahead and print more money when a big recession hits. Which is exactly the solution you people criticize.
- pdonis 14y agoThe money supply has gone up considerably since 2008, hasn't it? Shouldn't that have led to an actual recovery, instead of the stagnant economy we've actually observed?
- philwelch 14y agoWe didn't have another catastrophic depression, which is what not increasing the money supply might have done if we take the Great Depression as an example. If we had a reliable way of triggering an actual recovery whenever we wanted, it wouldn't be worth arguing about; we'd just do it. Unfortunately, if such a thing exists, it's a mystery to everyone.