5 ms·

I'd be curious to see if _anyone_ has actually been hired through HN Who's Hiring over the past two years here. I can only offer anecdotal experience, but...

I'd be curious to see if _anyone_ has actually been hired through HN Who's Hiring over the past two years here. I can only offer anecdotal experience, but... Despite 1) being a US-based dev, 2) Applying only to US-based jobs, 3) With 10+ years work experience, and 4) Having skills in commonly asked for technologies such as JS, React, and Python... I've only gotten to the interview stage with an HN Who's Hiring listing only once. Only a single instance over the past two years.

mdaniel 2y ago
The Who's Hiring, I kind of have lukewarm feelings toward those outcomes, because assholes are everywhere - but I've had the same experience as you on https://www.workatastartup.com/ https://www.workatastartup.com/ which is just what the actual fucking hell. From reading the sibling comments, it seems that my problem is that I enjoy reading more than talking on the phone so I much prefer browsing through listings and being selective, but what apparently needs to happen is that I call previous recruiters and badger them about "got anything?" rather that believing anything written online is true
theideaofcoffee 2y ago
I am also US based applying to exclusively US-based jobs. I've had the most success with Who's Hiring over all of the other ways (cold applications, network referrals, headhunters and whatnot), success rate being way higher than the others: for just a handful of positions I've been interested in I've had three offers, two for FTEs and another for a contract. My skills and background have been pretty well-matched to postings, almost exactly what they were looking for, but extremely deep in specific (increasingly hard to hire-for) areas. I'll admit I've been super lucky here. It's almost like a cheat code because you're almost always connected with the person(s) actually doing the hiring and with the power to make the decision so things move fast.
93po 2y ago
I had an interview last month from a post there. Dude sounded like he was half asleep and hated talking to me even from the very beginning. He carried it on for almost an hour for reasons I don't understand if he was so disinterested. No rejection email follow up, posted again in November. The rule just says "you have to respond" and he did by interviewing me, it doesn't explicitly say you have to provide direct yes or no answers to going forward.
- dennis_jeeves2 2y ago
  >He carried it on for almost an hour for reasons I don't understand if he was so disinterested. He is just going the the motions that he's been prescribed. Either that or an idiot.
  - 93po 2y ago
    it's more, why did anyone tell him he has to interview people that are clearly not a fit? is this just some sort of thing to hire an H1-B person instead? and if so why carry it on for an hour?
    - dennis_jeeves2 2y ago
      Most likely an H1B, or nepotism. he's been probably been tasked with doing the dirty work of a superior. If he goes on for an hour, because he is most likely tracked for the hrs he puts in. If you feel repeatedly in a situation like this, you should end the interview prematurely to save your time. I have had to do this a few times in the past.
      - 93po 2y ago
        unfortunately im a little desperate for a job and getting an interview right now is super rare and difficult despite 15 years experience in software
        93po 2y ago
        update: got a job offer :)

mdaniel 2y ago

The Who's Hiring, I kind of have lukewarm feelings toward those outcomes, because assholes are everywhere - but I've had the same experience as you on https://www.workatastartup.com/ https://www.workatastartup.com/ which is just what the actual fucking hell. From reading the sibling comments, it seems that my problem is that I enjoy reading more than talking on the phone so I much prefer browsing through listings and being selective, but what apparently needs to happen is that I call previous recruiters and badger them about "got anything?" rather that believing anything written online is true

theideaofcoffee 2y ago

I am also US based applying to exclusively US-based jobs. I've had the most success with Who's Hiring over all of the other ways (cold applications, network referrals, headhunters and whatnot), success rate being way higher than the others: for just a handful of positions I've been interested in I've had three offers, two for FTEs and another for a contract. My skills and background have been pretty well-matched to postings, almost exactly what they were looking for, but extremely deep in specific (increasingly hard to hire-for) areas. I'll admit I've been super lucky here. It's almost like a cheat code because you're almost always connected with the person(s) actually doing the hiring and with the power to make the decision so things move fast.

93po 2y ago

I had an interview last month from a post there. Dude sounded like he was half asleep and hated talking to me even from the very beginning. He carried it on for almost an hour for reasons I don't understand if he was so disinterested. No rejection email follow up, posted again in November. The rule just says "you have to respond" and he did by interviewing me, it doesn't explicitly say you have to provide direct yes or no answers to going forward.

dennis_jeeves2 2y ago
>He carried it on for almost an hour for reasons I don't understand if he was so disinterested. He is just going the the motions that he's been prescribed. Either that or an idiot.
- 93po 2y ago
  it's more, why did anyone tell him he has to interview people that are clearly not a fit? is this just some sort of thing to hire an H1-B person instead? and if so why carry it on for an hour?
  - dennis_jeeves2 2y ago
    Most likely an H1B, or nepotism. he's been probably been tasked with doing the dirty work of a superior. If he goes on for an hour, because he is most likely tracked for the hrs he puts in. If you feel repeatedly in a situation like this, you should end the interview prematurely to save your time. I have had to do this a few times in the past.
    - 93po 2y ago
      unfortunately im a little desperate for a job and getting an interview right now is super rare and difficult despite 15 years experience in software
      - 93po 2y ago
        update: got a job offer :)