9 ms·
So why can Goldman take positions where they stand to profit enormously if their clients lose money? Because Goldman's clients are grown-ups and allowed to hav
by twoodfin 14y ago
So why can Goldman take positions where they stand to profit enormously if their clients lose money?
Because Goldman's clients are grown-ups and allowed to have their own beliefs about the future of the market, as well as their own risk tolerance.
Goldman wasn't obligated to put up a shingle reading "We are losing our appetite for CDOs, and so can't take your money if you think they're still a great investment."
- forensic 14y ago>Goldman wasn't obligated to put up a shingle reading "We are losing our appetite for CDOs, and so can't take your money if you think they're still a great investment." This is the problem. They should be obligated. Being a professional carries ethical constraints. If your clients aren't getting your best advice you aren't a professional, you are a salesman. It's not okay for salesmen to pose as professionals.
- lsc 14y ago>This is the problem. They should be obligated. Being a professional carries ethical constraints. If your clients aren't getting your best advice you aren't a professional, you are a salesman. It's not okay for salesmen to pose as professionals. Now, modern usage of 'professional' aside,(I killed a long screed about how the only people putting effort into being seen as professionals anymore are salespeople, thus the word is losing it's previously positive connotations.) This idea that "professionals are trustworthy" comes from the outmoded idea that the upper classes are somehow more honest and trustworthy than the 'working man' - that because the lawyer has more education than the plumber, and probably comes from a higher-class background, he has a feeling of "Noblesse oblige" - and you can therefore trust the lawyer while you can not trust the plumber.
- msabalau 14y agoProfessional ethics are based on the obligations that come with specialized knowledge and responsibility. Even professions that are solidly middle class are seen as having duties and obligations. Librarians are expected, for example, to resist censorship, and to protect the privacy of their patrons. If professionalism seems less meaningful in modern society, it is because a distressingly large number of professionals in occupations like finance are acting dishonorably and unethically.
- lsc 14y agoFine, fine, I'll post the screed. My point is that the word "professional" is now all but synonymous with "slick salesman" Personally, I doubt that "professionals" were any more trustworthy before I was old enough to notice, too... thus me poking fun at the very ideas underpinning it. (as an aside, I don't know all that much about finance... but as far as I can tell, it's nothing but sales, so there really isn't any room for professionalism in the way you mean the word. They aren't doing anything but selling.) My experience with people that claim to be 'professional' or who attempt to dress professionally - nearly all of those people I know are salespeople. If you want someone to show up on time and look good? sure, go with one of them. If you want the correct answers to your questions? if you want someone to give you truthful answers even when those truthful answers mean you go with a competitor? find someone who is actually into what you are trying to do. That's the thing, at least in the part of Engineering where I work? sure, some good Engineers claim to be professionals, but almost none of them put any effort into the appearances of professionalism. Few put any effort into dressing or grooming, and many are habitually late. The only people I know that put a lot of effort into appearing professional are the sales people. I mean, sure, you and I can argue back and forth all day... "Words have meaning!" and, of course, a 'professional' is someone that does a job that requires a lot of training, and probably comes from an upper middle class background. But the thing is, that meaning changes over time, as how the word is used. Personally, I associate the word 'professional' along with the western style business suit, with fraud, mostly because the Engineers I know don't put much effort into claiming to be professional, while most sales people do. I think that more and more people have that opinion of the suit; even salespeople I meet rarely wear suits, (though, of course, they still loudly declare they are 'professionals' even though they have little knowledge of the product and are more than happy to make up ridiculous lies about their own product and the competition.)
- rayiner 14y agoNo, it's based on the very real fact that a lawyer can get in serious trouble for violating a raft of nit-picky self-regulatory provisions. Law firms have entire departments dedicated to avoiding conflicts of interest, and lawyers can get in trouble even for failing to disclose unethical activity they know about. Not to mention the constant threat of malpractice suits, in which violation of the ethical rules are strongly probative of malpractice liability.
- lsc 14y agowell, if the line between 'professional' and not is a legally defined one, you have a good point. I don't know how deep it goes, but I do believe that you need some kind of government-issued licence to be a stockbroker, in which case, sure, maybe then you should be able to expect that they follow a certain set of rules. (I do note that even with tightly defined rules, it's /very hard/ for people that are essentially salespeople to act in someone else's best interest. Hell, it's hard for a honest person to at in another person's best interest.)
- wootie 14y agoFinancial licenses are issued by FINRA (Financial Regulatory Authority). A main focus of the general exam and the supervisory exam (the Series 7 and 24) is 'dealing with the public.' The industry relies on the idea that you can trust your financial advisor. You still can't regulate ethics. Some people are just slimy; they will be slimy no matter what industry they are in.
- rayiner 14y ago> You still can't regulate ethics. Some people are just slimy; they will be slimy no matter what industry they are in. I think this is a bit defeatist. Professions can and do regulate their own culture. It's a question of having the will to do so. I'm going through the process of being admitted to the bar right now, and I have to say it's instilled in me at least a healthy fear. It's incredibly invasive. The character & fitness committee not only digs into your public data (speeding tickets, etc), but reaches back into things like expunged juvenile convictions. And it starts from Day 1. I had professors who were on the C&F committee who told me horror stories of people with $200k of debt failing to be admitted. There is a honor code culture. If there was cheating going on at my law school, it was below my radar, while it was fairly common at my engineering school. I feel medicine is the same way. I have family members who are surgeons who feel incredibly uncomfortable just when drug reps bring in lunch. Even in engineering, at least in the traditional disciplines like mechanicals, etc, (I was an aerospace major), there is a strong understanding that when you go into work, peoples' lives are on the line. I'm sure there are a lot of slimly people in these professions, but the difference is that the strong cultural condemnation forces such behavior under the radar. Meanwhile, the financial sector seems to reject the idea of professional codes of conduct as outmoded.
- ubernostrum 14y agoPart of the problem is persistent allegations that firms were advertising certain investments as great, safe, wonderful money-making vehicles, while simultaneously knowing and privately acting on the knowledge that they were anything but. That sure sounds like fraud to me.
- sambe 14y agoSales is sales. They were not doing this any more than than they would for any other product, and no financial investment is safe. Blaming the banks who sold these seems totally crazy to me. The prospectus is available, and the contents are pretty well known in the industry anyway - it's in the name. Note that other banks were quite often counterparty, not the man on the street who feels overburdened by small print. More likely the fraud & negligence for this specific part of the problem is committed by ratings agencies.
- rayiner 14y agoIf a car dealer sells you a car he thinks will break down in six months, you definitely have a case against him. Answering "caveat emptor" to everything is what's crazy. We're civilized people, we should abide by reasonable standards of business conduct. Especially when you're in a profession that holds itself out as representing the interests of its clients. You wouldn't have a problem with your lawyer taking bets against your case? Or your accountant using the information he learns from auditing you to profit on the side? I think these things fall below the standard of reasonable business conduct. I think the excessive reliance on caveat emptor is the product of a failed economic ideology.
- sambe 14y agoThose are terrible analogies. They did not hide bad loans in there and claim they were good. The products specifically consiste of a subprime tranch. In the financial world you are always buying products with risk attached. The amount and nature of the risk varies with the product; remember lots of people made money on CDOs as they will continue to do, as they did and do on junk bonds, and every other product that has bankrupted someone in the past. Attempting to put some arbitrary limit on what can and cannot be sold seems rigid and counterproductive. You realise that you can still buy Greek government bonds, right? Further, there is a reason caveat emptor is heavily restricted in the consumer domain: the overhead of people trying to assess and manage the risk of every single purchase they make far outweighs the cost of legislation and the onus on the company to deal with it instead. Note also that the strongest protections apply to new products. If you buy a used car without guarantee something can go wrong without any liability for the seller, so you are not even factually correct. I cannot see a legitimate reason to downbote my parent unless considered to be factually incorrect. Probably better to state the inaccuracies, you know, kind of friendlier where they are non-trivial. Spent today upvoting similarly against-the-consensus comments; exceptionally disappointing that such discussion must be one-sided on HN.
- rayiner 14y agoFirst, there is the information asymmetry. Second, there is the incentive structure created by that conflict of interest, even in a situation where the clients had perfect information.
- pdonis 14y ago> Goldman wasn't obligated to put up a shingle reading "We are losing our appetite for CDOs, and so can't take your money if you think they're still a great investment." They are obligated if they are fiduciaries.