4 ms·
> Most of them are happy to enable it once you describe what it is and how it works. This is going to depend very much on how you describe it. > The middle gr
by account42 2y ago
> Most of them are happy to enable it once you describe what it is and how it works.
This is going to depend very much on how you describe it.
> The middle ground is having a clear question where the telemetry option and the no-telemetry option is clearly shown and the telemetry is preselected. So you have to do a choice but the "I don't care" next > next > next choice is going to be to opt-in.
That's not a middle ground at all but very biased towards data collection. The middle ground is to play it safe and not collect any data where you are not sure you have informed consent, which includes users who do not understand the question or do not care to read it.
The better option would be to not add the data collection at all.
> Whether this is acceptable also depends on the nature of the program and the users. It's much easier to get acceptance for this if it's a piece of software that will make 100 requests to 10 different servers during normal operation (where all of those servers will likely know program version and even more client info anyway), but now makes 101 requests to 11 servers when you enabled the telemetry. A program that used no network requests at all without telemetry should probably be strictly opt-in since its such a major change in behavior.
It sould be strictly opt in for ALL software. Otherwise you are writing malware.
- alkonaut 2y agoIn what sense is anonymous usage stats “malware”? Because it does something you didn’t expect it to do? It did say on startup that it collects anonymous usage stats. It’s not “quietly enabled and opt-out has to be searched for”. It says front and center what is going on. You are free to exit at that point and not run it at all. Or just choose the no telemetry option. It’s basically more benign than 99% of web apps. It’s not a sneaky secret feature that does something behind your back. It’s not transmitting any information it wouldn’t transmit anyway. No information is stored that can identify a user either by fingerprinting or directly by some identifier.