2 ms·
> Solar/wind is great if you have practically unlimited, life- and disaster-free deserts to capitalize. Sucks otherwise. Bit more complex than that: the UK is
by ben_w 2y ago
> Solar/wind is great if you have practically unlimited, life- and disaster-free deserts to capitalize. Sucks otherwise.
Bit more complex than that: the UK is north of the Canadian-US border and has parts at the same latitude as southern Alaska, has fantastic wind resources, and somehow is managing to do not too badly with PV either.
> stripping vegetations off mountainsides and farmlands to install mega-solars is just man-made disaster, not a positive decarbonization effort.
Human imagination doesn't handle the huge numbers involved very well, maths is necessary.
If we did what you're describing (which we don't need to because PV doesn't have to be in a contiguous sheet and rooftop PV can supply a non-trivial percentage of demand, and also a poor choice geographically, and you wouldn't want to because geographical diversity is good), then the EU could get 133% of its needs from Slovenia, which is one of the smaller countries in the union (only three are smaller), and that's already accounting pessimistically for capacity factor: https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=area+Slovenia+*+1kW%2Fm%5E2+*+20%25+*+10%25 https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=area+Slovenia+*+1kW%2Fm...
(Likewise with the US, while Massachusetts would be a really poor choice of location to tile with PV, if you did it would supply 117% of US demand all by itself: https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=area++Massachusetts+*+1kW%2Fm%5E2+*+20%25+*+10%25 https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=area++Massachusetts+*+1...).
If you put a 3m wide strip of PV on or by the side of the EU road network (not rail, not airports, not car parks), that would also meet 96% of current demand by itself. And for the US, that same number with the same assumptions about capacity factor and width would be 87%.
Where PV doesn't work is dense city-states like the Vatican, because rooftop PV is only a "non-trivial percentage of demand" not "all of demand".