5 ms·
From BSP to ESP – How S3ctor Abused Quake Editors to Redefine the Morrowind Mod
- knome 2y agohey, in case the author is the submitter, your title covers 2/3rds of the top line when viewing this from my phone.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- slowmotiony 2y agoI have a hard time believing an eight year old child was watching Doom 3 developer talks and telling his kindergarden friends about buffer shadows and Carmack's Reverse.
- sorbusherra 2y agoI don't know...When I was kid we used to talk poking memory addresses for cheats while playing c64 games and we were all 9-11 years old. Kids do darnest things.
- amatecha 2y agotrue, that reminds me of my friend hex-editing his savegame files for WarCraft 1 in DOS - he would have been 10 or 11 at the time.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- badsectoracula 2y agoI started programming at 7, i was certainly telling my friends about all the random stuff i barely had a smidge of understanding while trying to program simple games myself - i could barely move a smiley face (DOS ASCII character 2) on screen to collect hearts (DOS ASCII character 3) and yet i was certain i could make a game like Prince of Persia once i figured out how to draw lines on screen with Turbo Pascal's BGI.
- jufjfau 2y ago[flagged]
- pjmlp 2y agoBack in the 80's having 10 year olds show off Z80 Assembly on their Speccy and C64 wasn't that extraordinary, what was impressive is the ideas many would think of without nothing else besides a couple of books and nothing else. I am sure what I am telling here, because I was one of those kids, with whatever we could get from the local library, coupled with Input magazines, and some Portuguese newspapers with computing stuff on fridays (A Capital). By 14 I was already into Demoscene stuff. EDIT: Naturally it was 6502 on the C64.
- warpspin 2y agoDito. Started c64 scene at 12. You had to not talk about your age back then, though.
- Y_Y 2y agoIs there any modern equivalent? If you could control a child's computer access and didn't care about them missing out on tiktok etc what would you do? Of course a refurbed ZX Spectrum is an option, as is Scratch or some other hand-holding environment. I'd be interested to know if anyone is raising tough, rugged, Mel-type hackers[0] these days, and how they're going about it. [0] http://www.catb.org/jargon/html/story-of-mel.html http://www.catb.org/jargon/html/story-of-mel.html
- warpspin 2y agoI am skeptical that this can be repeated at all nowadays the way we had it in the 80ies and 90ies (or even earlier, but I'm an 80ies child, haha). At best with some kind of limited hardware or in some narrow area like writing games. Also, surely not with Scratch. Scratch is, what you give a 5 year old to learn some concepts in my opinion. My children were appalled by it when they became 10 cause it's "baby stuff". At least those kids interested in programming. The thing in the 80ies and early 90ies was, that you could actually, as a kid, compete with something professional and have total control over the outcome, if you had a bit of talent in any area. This was unbelievably motivating. Where can one person or two people nowadays seriously compete with professionals and have serious control over the outcome? If at all in the area, where you will actually find kids today: Roblox games, Unity games, anything with a finished engine, where they can focus on the content itself because anything else will simply be unrealistically large effort. Also, limited retro hardware things might work, I do not know. For me, if I was a child again, they would not work because these are things that are too limited - I would always know there are really powerful PCs with all 3d stuff around. As said above, the fantasy of being able to do anything some software company could do was what motivated me in the 80ies/early 90ies, so I'd rather probably teach myself some game engine, too, because that allows me to live the state-of-the-art fantasy. At least I assume that. Another thing old hardware did, by the way, which modern hardware does not, is that it launched people on a programming learning path immediately, if they desired to successfully use it. You could not use a C64 without learning at least a tiny little bit of basic.
- bogwog 2y agoI started when I was around 10, and made my first "game engine" in C++ at around 12 or 13. If anything, doing this type of thing when you're that young is easier (unlimited free time, and young brains probably learn things more easily). The only real barrier is interest/motivation.
- colechristensen 2y ago>The only real barrier is interest/motivation. My barrier at that age was just information. Obviously things have become much easier now. Having windows 95 as your first OS made this particularly difficult and the Internet was what it was at that time. It took me years to find the right questions to ask and the right information. What took me several years to figure out I have tought someone in an afternoon. (getting from 0 to a short roadmap to something functional).
- amatecha 2y agoYeah, I always wished so badly I knew an adult who was a skilled programmer. I borrowed books from the library but I would always hit a wall so early on, not being able to make sense of the concepts (and being on a Mac, which none of the books provided a compiler for). Looking back I know for a fact I could have grasped the concepts if they were explained a little more "gradually" for me, which a mentor-type person absolutely could have done easily.
- ShroudedNight 2y agoWithout mentorship / guidance, how are you supposed to know that K&R and / or Petzold (and maybe A. S. Tanenbaum?) are where it's at, and everything else is arguably a waste of your time? Almost every programming book I encountered seemed intent on making the computer appear mysterious and esoteric which did not help me feel empowered to explore.
- colechristensen 2y agoI even got to K&R. Types, variables, input and output made sense to young me. Pointers made sense but I couldn't wrap my head around why, and then I was stuck with "what next". For years everything next I could find (like writing a windows application) was way over my head and any "step 2" was completely elusive.
- wrsh07 2y agoEven today a friend's kid has been programming since younger than eight - watching YouTube videos about game development etc I think you'd be surprised at what kids are able to do at what ages if they're allowed to work productively towards useful goals Watch a video of some Montessori 3 year olds.
- bobim 2y agoMontessori has nothing to do with this, my triple experience is that kids figure out the method allows them to derp around, and they will derp around. The school tells nothing as keeping the cash coming in is more important than kids education. A passionate kid is passionate, the method is not making him passionate.
- wrsh07 2y agoThe friend's kid isn't a Montessori kid He just likes programming. He likes building stuff. One of his best friends is a kid his age who lives across the country. They just like being productive. At the end of my previous post, I was trying to dispel this idea that kids under ten are incapable of doing things independently. That they're incapable of engaging in things like an adult. If a 3 year old can grocery shop and make a cake, an 8 year old can watch a game dev talk. Can be obsessed with game engines. Can learn to juggle. My niece wrote a blog post years ago when she was under ten, and the comments she got were "your parents must have written this for you, you aren't capable of having done this" which is absurd. Don't act like kids are incapable just because the ones you see are incapable.
- bobim 2y agoI agree, sorry, I just have a grief against scammers jeopardizing kids education.
- amatecha 2y agohmmm, I don't feel too skeptical about it - I think it just sounds more impressive in hindsight where it can be described in full clarity (and probably underestimating how much was picked up in the months/years afterward). I was writing HyperTalk around the age of 9, after learning the "secret" command of "set userlevel to 5" [0], although it was kinda difficult without any documentation (I just opened other existing Stacks to see how stuff was done). If you grew up around computers and had a knack for it, well, a youthful brain just soaks up everything it's exposed to, really. This actually reminds me of how valuable it can be to expose kids to complex/depthful things from an early age -- some will dive right in and embrace it, and potentially enjoy a rewarding experience with the particular subject.. For me it was computers, and at the time I really couldn't get enough. [0] https://hypercard.center/HyperTalkReference/Set-the-user-level-to-scripting https://hypercard.center/HyperTalkReference/Set-the-user-lev...
- pzduniak 2y agoEh, you're overestimating OP's statement. I think they're roughly my age and at eight I was busy figuring out Win32 APIs and DLL imports in Object Pascal to make _rad utility programs_. I probably would've immediately gone into game modding if not for the fact that I was using a late 90s Dell notebook that had like 8MB of VRAM :) Two years later I had a bunch of game servers running entire custom gamemodes implemented in LUA with other kids _loving it_.
- pdntspa 2y agoI was pulling similar shit around that age, armed with those old illustrated "How Computers Work" books. This kid just got into something nerdier
- foldor 2y ago8 years old is well past kindergarten aged. It's the second grade around here. It's still young, but the maturity difference is huge.
- shpongled 2y agoI booted a hobby OS I had written in C on the family PC (off of a floppy disk!) by the time I was 13. Kids can have a lot of free time to mess around with this stuff - I would love to see what I could do now with a whole summer off.
- craftkiller 2y agoI started programming when I was 8. Certainly not to the point where I would understand Carmack's reverse and buffer shadows but there are people much smarter than me and information has never been more available than it is today so I don't think its completely implausible.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- jheriko 2y agoi don't. although the magic of carmack's reverse to me is how it was a passing thought for me in a gamedev book written by an over privileged silly valley asshat in my teens... and turned out to be gold.
- brcmthrowaway 2y agoIt's called having wealthy parents
- deterministic 2y agoI was programming the ZX-Spectrum in machine code when I was eleven. And discussing what I was doing with other (geeky) kids my age.
- ahoka 2y agoYou can do much more in Blender and it takes around a month to get to a decent level with it. BSP is just outdated and limiting. If you want to add small details and variance, then just make smaller models and combine them in creative ways, together with decals, texture atlases, etc.
- cheeseomlit 2y agoBlender certainly has many more features, but I've been bouncing off of it for years- every time I try to learn it I get overwhelmed by all the minutia. Trenchbroom just feels more natural, and for lower fidelity quake-style maps its all you really need
- bogwog 2y agoThey're creative tools. The "better" one is the one that the artist is most comfortable with. I've seen working professional artists who still rely on ancient abandoned software from dead companies.
- amatecha 2y agoYears ago I learned about the tools that one of my favorite bands used. At the time where Intel Macs were taking the world by storm, these guys were still using G4 towers in their studio and had no interest in using anything new. I'm sure they moved onto something newer, but who knows how long that took. Indeed, an artist's relationship with their tools takes some time to develop and isn't easily cast aside!
- 9point6 2y agoThere's a good chance this might be down to Apple's constantly changing foundations and the fact that a studio's worth of music software can (especially back then) cost a lot of money to upgrade on top of the new hardware requiring the upgrade in the first place. And that's not going into the case where the company that wrote the software has gone bust. Given you mentioned G4, there's a good chance they had recent memory of having to upgrade a load of stuff to jump from OS9 to OSX. The Intel architecture change required another upgrade for a lot of software, so it probably made a lot of sense to try and eek more value out of the previous round of purchasing before going again. Hopefully they delayed enough to not get hit rapidly by the changes in Yosemite, Mojave or Catalina which all necessitated upgrades (IIRC, one might have only been some edge cases) or finally the most recent jump to ARM—which still isn't natively supported by a surprising number of DAW or VST vendors. On Windows I can run any DAW or VST that's been written since about 2006 natively and can even load up a 32-bit DAW if I want to dust off some ancient project with ancient VSTs that never made the jump to 64-bits.
- asdga 2y ago[flagged]
- somat 2y agoI love the quake .map format. It is like this glimpse into an weird alternate history. A sort steampunk ascetic to graphics. The article touches on this, but for them unfamiliar, the quake .map format is the editable text based format. but it does not use the common method of vertices into edges into faces as the base building block. it uses planes, the graphics primitive is is the three points that define a plane, where these planes intersect are the edges. I never dove into the subject enough to figure out if this plane representation was also internal to the compiled bsp format, but I suspect it is. My guess is that it is the natural conclusion when you need a map interchange format for your highly optimized space partitioned engine.
- rasz 2y agoPowerVR supported in hardware something called "infinite planes", wonder if its connected. Afaik no game, program or API ever used it.
- cmovq 2y ago> I never dove into the subject enough to figure out if this plane representation was also internal to the compiled bsp format, but I suspect it is. Not exactly. The BSP format stores planes as a normal (3 floats) + distance to the origin + an int that flags axis aligned planes. Which is the representation the engine uses. I believe “3 points on the plane” was chosen for the map file so the coordinates could be exact integers in the text file, to avoid precision loss from storing the normal+distance representation. The latter representation uses less space and is easier to work with.
- jheriko 2y agobeautiful to see a decent programmer understanding the tech that people at e.g. unity and unreal have just fucked up badly.
- Llamamoe 2y agoIMO, an even better tool was the Cube 2 Sauerbraten ingame editor - a combination of octree(e.g. variable-size) voxels spliced with per-vertex heightmaps that let you treat parts of it as terrain, others as cubes, and sculpt others into arches, rocks, spheres or vases. It had that same intuitive sculpting feel, but even more powerful and quick to work with.
- HexDecOctBin 2y ago> per-vertex heightmaps Do you mean per-face heightmap? Like a displacement map?
- Doxin 2y agoI assume he means you can move any vertex an arbitrary amount along its normal.
- Llamamoe 2y agoAlmost, but not quite - you can move each vertex of a cube inwards on all 3 axes, e.g. treating each face as a 4-point heightmap. This would automatically extrude new cubes upwards, destroy ones you flatten to nothing, etc. which means it could absolutely work as an almost-typical heightmap, if you wanted it to.