4 ms·
>Is it really an agreement if you must agree to it for basic necessities? The article says the article says the location data was "harvested from ordinary apps
by gruez 2y ago
>Is it really an agreement if you must agree to it for basic necessities?
The article says the article says the location data was "harvested from ordinary apps installed on phones". What type of "basic necessities" are you getting from apps on your phone that have location access? I'm guessing it's from random weather apps, rather than something "basic necessities".
- exe34 2y agowho needs to check the weather before going outside or making plans, right? that's just a luxury.
- RiverCrochet 2y agoMy boomer cousin just said, "Yeah, they invented this really cool thing for that called a window." I just updated my will to remove his name from it.
- recursive 2y agoBut you probably still look out the window though.
- Jerrrrrrry 2y agoI don't think your money means as much to someone less dependent on macro-complexity. He based-ness and your bias-ness are on display.
- exe34 2y agoyep, a properly configured window will tell you about flood risks and lighting strikes several hours ahead of time!
- bigstrat2003 2y agoYou in fact do not need to check the weather forecast to do those things. People went outside and made plans just fine before we had the weather on TV, much less on a computer.
- fallingsquirrel 2y agoIt sounds like you're advocating for a world where ordinary people need to choose between: - not knowing the weather this weekend - knowing the weather and signing away their firstborn child in the T&C - becoming an amateur lawyer and spending dozens of hours reading and comparing T&Cs between apps to choose which one to use (until they change the T&Cs again of course, which they'll do without notifying you)
- gruez 2y agoHow about not granting location permissions and typing in your location manually? Weather forecasts worked fine before phones with geolocation built in.
- fallingsquirrel 2y agoWe're talking T&Cs here. How would typing in your location invalidate you agreeing to (what a company would like to believe is legally binding) clickwrap T&Cs? Even if you deny individual permissions, apps will still slurp up your app list/hardware specs/any metadata they can get their grimy hands on, directly and indirectly through side channels. You're saying to give them 999 data points instead of 1000 and you think that's a solution?
- gruez 2y ago>Even if you deny individual permissions, apps will still slurp up your app list/hardware specs/any metadata they can get their grimy hands on Is this a purely academic thought experiment or something that's happening in practice? I'm not exactly sure what the "999 data points" consists of. Given basically nobody assembles their own phone, the most that hardware fingerprinting will reveal is "you have an iPhone 13", impossible to differentiate from all the other iPhone 13s floating around because they're all identical. Both android and ios have cracked down on software fingerprinting as well, so you can't for instance grab a list of all installed apps.
- fallingsquirrel 2y ago
- teeray 2y ago> What type of "basic necessities" are you getting from apps on your phone that have location access? I already mentioned one: parking apps granted a monopoly over a region by a municipality. Before you ask, no, there are often no meters to feed cash or a card to anymore (the apps don’t want those cutting into their fees). Your options are to accept the T&C in the app so you can go buy groceries or get parking tickets, and eventually a boot or tow.
- gruez 2y agoAnd those apps require location access? As per app store guidelines, they're supposed to provide fallback if you deny location permissions. Not to mention both iOS and Android have cracked down on background location permissions years ago, so at best those parking apps is getting a list of places you parked at, not minute by minute location updates. Tracking you by where you swiped your credit card is probably more reliable than this.
- prmoustache 2y ago- just use a different mode of transport. - elect beeter officials