4 ms·
My dad was reprimanded for not following orders ejecting when the engine on his F-86 failed. He did the calculations and figured he could make the field, which
by WalterBright 2y ago
My dad was reprimanded for not following orders ejecting when the engine on his F-86 failed. He did the calculations and figured he could make the field, which he did.
They said the pilot was far more valuable than the airplane.
- tzs 2y agoPlanes were cheaper then. I wonder if the higher costs of today's planes results in any pressure to try to save planes that in your dad's day would have been considered not worth the risk? An F-86 ranged from $180-$580k in 1950 dollars, depending on the model. That's around $2.4-7.8 million now. That's quite a bit lower than the statistical value of human life that is currently used by the government for regulatory analysis, which is $13.1 million. An F-35 is something like $80-$110 million. Even if we add the cost of training for the pilot, which Google tells me is $10.1 million for an F-35, to the statistical life value we only get $23.2 million which is only 21-29% of the cost of the plane.
- qingcharles 2y agoI look at, say, the war in Ukraine, where they have a fresh supply of planes from allies, but their roster of pilots is diminishing. In this situation the pilot is far more valuable than the plane. And probably always the case during war when aircraft production is at a maximum.
- lenkite 2y agoOut of curiosity, is there a source for the "statistical value of human life" at $13.1 million ?
- coolspot 2y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_of_life https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_of_life
- tzs 2y ago“HHS Standard Values for Regulatory Analysis, 2024” [1] [1] https://aspe.hhs.gov/sites/default/files/documents/cd2a1348ea0777b1aa918089e4965b8c/standard-ria-values.pdf https://aspe.hhs.gov/sites/default/files/documents/cd2a1348e...
- sirspacey 2y agoAn airman I know shared that it cost $10M + to train a pilot by the time they can run missions, which matches the sources Perplexity found on the question. (1) The number of years the military gets to keep a trained pilot is limited, so that’s also a factor. The more significant one is that so few people prove to be capable and willing to be fighter pilots. Replacement is not a given. 1 https://www.perplexity.ai/search/how-much-does-it-cost-the-air-D8ToGqfyTOiFz6Z2uqESKA https://www.perplexity.ai/search/how-much-does-it-cost-the-a...
- WalterBright 2y agoThe procedure was to: 1. know the optimal glide speed. Since the jet was traveling much faster than that, he pulled up the nose to trade excess speed for altitude. 2. trim the airplane for optimal gliding 3. push the nose down to maintain optimal glide speed 4. work the math on altitude, air pressure and sink rate to get distance traveled This was long before calculators (1950s) so he had to know the formulae and the figures. I read one of his certification tests for flying jets, and you had to know an awful lot. When I was at Boeing I was told that one of the engineering marvels on a jet was the mechanical computer that managed the engine, reducing it to a single lever for the pilot. P.S. ejection seats were new in those days, with bugs that could injure or kill the pilot. He figured it was safer to glide the bird in.
- ChicagoBoy11 2y agoWhen I did my flight training on a CAPS-enabled airplane, they showed us footage and stats from the military to say that there was a clear bias towards "saving" planes, especially in training, and that it led to more fatalities than if folks stuck by the book. Thought it was super interesting, and definitely helped to cement the attitude of using the resources of the plane by the book, which, (I think sadly), this guy is being punished for.