2 ms·
The main time period in classical byoyomi has always seemed strange to me: if it's expected that you'd reach byoyomi at all in a game of a typical length, then
by zahlman 2y ago
The main time period in classical byoyomi has always seemed strange to me: if it's expected that you'd reach byoyomi at all in a game of a typical length, then the main time isn't making much difference. It lets you allocate extra time to a certain critical move, but only if it's early enough in the game. If say you have 10 minutes of main time with a single 30 second byoyomi, and you're disciplined enough to use 30 seconds per move generally, then the main time is irrelevant past the opening - you'll have used it by your 20th move or so even if nothing gave you a reason to take extra time.
Yes, I'm aware that traditionally instead of main time you'd have a large (for important slow games) number of one-minute periods. Using multiple byoyomi periods is even stranger - more complex for questionable effect on time management strategy.
One idea I've had that I'd like to see implemented is "reverse single byoyomi": you have a certain amount of time per move (which resets for each move), and when exceeded on a given move you start using your "main time" (and lose when that runs out). I think that fixes the above problems: you can spend a little time on each move (but you and your opponent can expect reasonably brisk play from each other most of the time), and if you prefer you can use your reserve in late game to count the score, double-check for teire and semedori, etc. And, of course, you don't encounter extra time pressure just because the game went to an unusually high number of moves (and your opponent doesn't get to waste huge amounts of time during dame-filling just because the game went to an unusually low number of moves).
Fischer is close to accomplishing this, but it makes you "bank" and manage your thinking time for the longer moves.
- sdwr 2y agoByoyomi creates severe relative advantages based on banked time. One player having 3 minutes left, with the other in byoyomi is an "on the ropes" moment. Like the article says, with Fischer you always have the opportunity to claw back extra time, so it's not as severe a deficit.