7 ms·
The True Story of the Amazon Door-Desk
- darushimo 14y agoI just don't care any more. this site is not for old startup people to wax anything. I want to start something. I know or know about these stories already. I'm not excited for this culture to get all pseudo-nostalgic.
- SoftwareMaven 14y agoI thought about this comment for a while before I decided to vote up. On the negative is an unwillingness to learn from the previous generation. They've made a lot of mistakes we shouldn't. On the positive is a willingness to say "screw the establishment". We are going down a path that leads to a better place. In the end, I think we need less establishment and more better places. We should recognize where we came from, but not get stuck idolizing it.
- sanswork 14y agoIt was already light grey when I got here so I neither downvoted or upvoted but my opinion differs from yours. I don't see this post as being about the old establishment but more about how a marketer sold a tech business to the public before it was quite ready for one. There is a lot to be said about ignoring certain old business practises but I'm not sure ignoring very recent(the 90s weren't so long ago!) marketing techniques is one of those areas we should so quickly ignore. The world in relation to the internet is quite different from now but I think this story still holds true in that finding something quirky and original about your business is a great way to sell it to the mainstream.
- jessedhillon 14y agoThe comment deserves a downvote, if for no other reason than because the last thing HN needs is another person whining about how they want to start a company. A thousand graybeard reminiscences filling the front page never would be as harmful to OP's chances as the fact that he thinks the top story on HN is in any way connected with him starting a company.
- blhack 14y agoYour submissions: http://news.ycombinator.com/submitted?id=darushimo http://news.ycombinator.com/submitted?id=darushimo Sorry everybody else isn't doing a better job of building a website custom-tailored to exactly your desire.
- daeken 14y agoThe proper solution when you see something you dislike on HN: move on. If you think it simply doesn't belong on HN: flag it. If you want to improve HN: submit something better.
- wooster 14y agosigh I was an intern at Tellme, which used door-desks early employees had to build themselves. I built a desk in pretty much the same style as the Tellme desks (although structurally more sound… I can jump up and down on mine thanks to an extra 2x4), which were based on the Amazon desks. My desk, which I have used since 2003, is a 30" x 80" x 1-3/8" hollow core white door, on four cut to order 27.5" 4x4's from Home Depot. It cost less than $50 to make and is a very nice desk. It took me less than two hours to build, from leaving my house to driving to Home Depot to building the final product. My next desk will be a built-to-order sit-stand adjustable desk, but that's because I'm currently able to earn enough money (and am concerned enough about my health) to justify the cost. If I were still 23 and concerned about costs, I'd build a desk identical to my current one in a heartbeat.
- jjcm 14y agoAs someone who got a year out of those Tellme desks before we moved, thanks for building them. Goddamn they were sturdy.
- jonhendry 14y agoThe Amazon desks appear to be a particularly expensive implementation of a potentially cheap desk.
- nirvana 14y agoThe door desk is a lie. They claim it is cheap, its one of the company mantras like "its day one!" that are part of the ideology/cult that exists at amazon. It is part of their fraud (like leaking that kindle fire is a success via a PR firm, if they told lies in their annual reports it would be actionable, but they can commit the same fraud using a PR firm and get away with it.) Basically everything Amazon says is exactly the kind of lie that the door desk is-- it sounds plausible and in other contexts it could be true, but in reality, it is a lie.
- spudlyo 14y agoI started in the catalog department at Amazon in 1997, right as Glennf left. It took me an embarrassingly long time to realize that the desks were made out of doors. It just seemed like giant clunky desk to me. One thing I do remember distinctly about Glenn's time in the catalog department was this terrifying 60k Perl script I inherited from him called sitecounts.pl. This script examined all the various catalogs (books, reviews, etc) and attempted to generate some interesting stats about them. One day it just broke, and since it was used in the catalog build process to verify that things were sane, it needed to get fixed pronto. The code was plenty confusing, but what was the worst part was the extent of the right margin creep, I'm talking 150+ character lines -- not exactly easy reading on my crappy 15" X-terminal. I felt like a character in a HP Lovecraft story, slowly descending into madness as I learned more about the horrors of this script. I ended up maintaining and adding to this script my entire first stint at Amazon. Eventually as I added features and changed things, it slowly got made sane over time, save for a little bit of madness that I kept in there just so I'd have a reminder of what it was like. Ah the 90s. Good times.
- nhashem 14y agoUnfortunately I don't have much to add to the OP, but I wanted to comment on this. Everyone I know that hates Perl had some sort of experience where they inherited some legacy Perl script that broke all the time and yet performed business critical functions. I started my first full-time job in 2004, and whenever I get together with my old co-workers we'll STILL talk about the battle scars we had trying to bubble gum and tape together a particular script called cc_processing.pl (yep, just as critical as the name implies), that seemingly broke every other day and went so far down the rabbit hole you had no idea how it ever ran successfully. $a{$a} = $a->{$a}? Sure, why not. I wonder how much of Perl's reputation is based on these kinds of formative experiences. I love Perl, but I'm realizing that everyone had their nemesis in sitecounts.pl, or traffic_reports.pl, or partnerpayments.pl, or wtf-how-did-this-ever-work.pl, and unfortunately didn't draw the same conclusions about Perl that I did.
- taligent 14y agoFor me the problem with Perl isn't the language but the mindset the goes with it. It's like it triggers some primitive release of testosterone which results in developers competing to fit the most functionality in one regex filled line of craziness. Hilarious to watch. Hell to debug.
- kevinburke 14y agoI worked at Google for a brief period of time and put in a work order for a door desk, as it was part of the culture I read about in 'In the Plex' and more. Sadly I was told that only senior VP's and up could have door desks. Maybe in 20 years :)
- jrockway 14y agoWhy did you want a door desk when you can get an electronically-controlled height-adjustable desk? Much more ergonomic...
- praptak 14y agoIt is not always that ergonomy is the same as satisfaction.
- jrockway 14y agoWhat makes a door better than a normal desk?
- thematt 14y agoThey're larger and typically deeper than the height adjustable ones.
- jrockway 14y agoWhat do you do with a deep desk? My IKEA table at home is already too deep, all I do with the extra space is store a monitor that I don't use. At work, the extra space hosts a marble track. And this is with a standard desk; a door would just be a massive dust collector. Space that you can't easily reach is essentially useless. My desk mostly exists to take up space between the wall and my monitor so my legs have somewhere to stretch out to.
- emmelaich 14y agoYeah, I have a 'nice' desk with a good finish and slide out keyboard tray, which I got from my family for my birthday. Haven't had the heart to tell them I'd prefer a door.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoOne down side of those door desks, sometimes they leak sap on you because the legs are made of just plain old unfinished lumber.
- pasbesoin 14y agoI'll add: If the posts are pressure treated lumber, you don't want to breathe the dust if/when you saw them. Better to avoid pressure-treated -- but depending upon where you shop, you might end up with it if you don't know better.
- adestefan 14y agoIf your lumber is leaking sap, then you've got problems.
- scrame 14y agoI worked there for about 3 years in the mid 00's. Everyone still had door desks, and all-hands frequently mentioned the fact that they were less cost-effective than actual desks, but they still used them as a reminder of frugality.
- brown9-2 14y agoHow is it frugal to buy something less cost effective than another product that would work equally as well?
- mcguire 14y agoIt reminds visitors that you're frugal, even if you aren't.
- rdl 14y agoI think I would pretty much quit working for a place which required the cognitive dissonance of overpaying for a symbol of frugality.
- japhyr 14y agoCan anyone find a link to pictures of the original desks? Google shows a bunch of desks built by people who were inspired by this story.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- nhebb 14y agoI had a door desk in college. It was solid core with a flat surface. You could buy them at a deep discount if you found one with surface defects. I used cinder blocks to support the corners, making it cheap and portable. Simply put, it was the best desk I have ever had.
- aneth4 14y agoThere is something symbolic about something impractical and expensive becoming a symbol for practicality and frugality. There was a recent post on HN about a startup in Seattle spending loads of time to build door desks, an apparent attempt to emulate Amazon. Perhaps purchasing ergonomic desks for a reasonable price and no time sink would be a better strategy than these clunkers.
- vonmoltke 14y agoMaybe I'm looking in the wrong places, but I have never been able to find heavy-duty desks at a reasonable price, except for the old-fashioned sit in the middle, drawers on the side design. I've built my variants of the door desk at home specifically because they were cheaper than the alternatives, even the cheap particle board desks fro the big box stores. My variant is to lay two 2x4s across either two filing cabinets or sawhorses, then put two 2'x4' sheets of 5/8" or 3/4" MDF on top of the studs. Cheap[1], toolless[2], and portable[2]. My current variant is a little more elaborate, since I wanted a corner desk, but fundamentally the same architecture. [1] The sawhorse version costs less than $50 [2] Nothing is attached
- codeonfire 14y agoYou can get a laminated 8' folding table nicely finished with a steel frame for $80 new that will hold at least 1000 lbs and doesn't have to be taken apart. i actually got one for $50 new a few years ago. I tried lots of lumber yard solutions, too until I realized there is a superior engineered solution.
- moron 14y agoSounds penny-wise and pound-foolish. Works as lore, though.
- blu3jack 14y agoThe opposite is true: it was penny-foolish and pound-wise. As Glenn pointed out -- the door desks were an expensive and ergonomicaly unsound symbol that told a true story about frugality and the relationship between the company and the employee. Because of the omnipresent symbol of frugality, many cost saving decisions were made that undoubtedly paid for the cost of the door desks many times over. The less happy side of the symbol: that amazon really didn't care about employees was reinforced in other ways as well. A common refrain from Jeff: if you're not happy here, leave. Life is too short to be unhappy. In some senses that's a bold answer, and an honest one. But note that the answer was very, very rarely: what can we do to make life better here? The door desks were also a symbol to us all that if you wanted to work at a place that cared about your health, well-being, and happiness, you might very well want to move on. But, to be fair, three counterbalancing factors held people there: hard engineering problems, the very real prospect of wealth, and working on a product that was very, very successful. I never heard Bezos give anyone the sugar water speech: he didn't have to. It was obvious that Amazon was changing the world.
- kghose 14y agoI'm sorry, I read the whole article and could not understand it. perhaps I need more sleep. Are doors cheaper than desks? Why is this a cost saving measure? Did the desks double as doors? I guess there is some industry insider stuff that I am just not getting.
- brown9-2 14y agoThe doors were expensive, built to an arbitrary height, heavy, difficult to move, and horrible for body health because of the bad ergonomics. That's when I started having to see an acupuncturist for carpal tunnel and related problems. And also note that these were exterior doors: moving a exterior door through an interior door frame with legs permanently attached is a tricky task. At the time, a slightly smaller desk (or even a study banquet table) would have cost 1/3 to 1/2 the amount and worked far better.
- jrockway 14y agoIndeed. The door desks were one reason I turned down an offer from Amazon. If they want their employees to get carpal tunnel, what other landmines lie lurking?
- ams6110 14y agoThe tl;dr is that the doors were not less expensive than desks, at least not enough to really matter. The value was in the perception of frugality that they created.
- amcintyre 14y agoMy true story of the door-desk is that it made me think, "Wow, they're making everybody use desks that look like they were built from things they swiped from a dumpster behind Home Depot...how much are they going to nickel and dime me when it comes to compensation?" Sure, the work sounded interesting and the people seemed competent and friendly, but the view of an open floor plan filled with those desks really dampened any excitement I had about working there.
- hrktb 14y agoImagine the employees at some instances of Yahoo when they removed the water coolers for cost efficiency reasons...
- kragen 14y agoWhen I was at AirWave, which was an IdeaLab company, we had door desks made of hollow-core doors set on top of two cheap steel filing cabinets. Maybe other IdeaLab companies did the same thing. These worked fine as long as you didn't poke holes in them, but at first they were a little unstable, since the doors would slide around no top of the filing cabinets. At some point, somebody had the idea of putting some of the Thinking Putty we had sitting around the office on top of the filing cabinets, and that kept the doors from sliding. This is considerably more frugal, in my view, than the solid-core doors with metal brackets to attach the legs. Lightweight, easy to move, easy to disassemble (the Thinking Putty stained the wood with its oil but didn't get stuck itself), lots of storage space in the drawers, etc.
- pasbesoin 14y agoI picked up the tip from an IKEA employee of using (industrial) Velcro. That's what they use at the store to keep things from flopping about. Works a trick.
- Stratoscope 14y agoI've never used a door desk, but in addition to the other negatives already mentioned, I have to imagine that they must be rather wobbly, like the Ikea desks we had at a startup I was at several years ago. If anyone wants a great cheap desk (around $250 delivered), I recommend the Hon AM3060: https://www.google.com/search?q=hon+am3060 https://www.google.com/search?q=hon+am3060 These things are extremely sturdy with no sideways wobble at all. They are adjustable height and have adjustable feet for uneven floors. I've had a couple of them for years and think they're great. Unfortunately, Hon seems to have discontinued them. The only model I see in stock anywhere is the AM3060ZZP with a mahogany colored top. I have the AM3060ML with a light oak color top, and there was also one with a gray top. (All the tops are a laminate.) There also used to be an AM3048 and an AM3072, but I don't see those anywhere. (The model numbers indicate the top size: 30x48, 30x60, 30x72.)
- dionidium 14y agoMy current desk is a solid wood door with these legs: http://hairpinlegs.com/products.php?id=5 http://hairpinlegs.com/products.php?id=5 It's the most sturdy desk I've ever used. There is no wobble and I'm sure you could easily stand a few people up on it. Those legs aren't super-cheap, so it's not the least expensive desk you could build, but it's very strong and looks pretty nice.
- jsolson 14y ago> I've never used a door desk, but in addition to the other negatives already mentioned, I have to imagine that they must be rather wobbly, like the Ikea desks we had at a startup I was at several years ago. They're not. Actually, neither is my Ikea desk at home, for that matter. A well-built door desk has the legs braces on two axes (note: not all of them are correctly built) and the legs are really quite substantial. I'm a fan of the "giant table as desk" school of office furniture selection, so I actually rather like my door desk. It's one of the only things supplied by Amazon that I didn't feel the need to eliminate or replace out of pocket.
- rdl 14y agoWhat tools does Amazon provide to a software engineer?
- brianstorms 14y agoI own a door desk, bought from the Saltaire company in Seattle, the one that made Amazon's desks. I had interviewed at Amazon in 1997 and saw the door-desks everywhere and asked one of the people there where they got them and found out the company info. (Meanwhile, the interview didn't go well: they didn't seem to like me and I really thought the company was creepy -- every interview was unpleasant, every person I met was arrogant and the whole vibe of the place felt wrong.) Anyway, I went to Saltaire and special-ordered one of their door-desks. Cost around $200 plus tax. I still have it 15 years later, it's in use every day.
- fooooobar 14y agoIt should be obvious the desks aren't actually made from real doors. When's the last time you saw a door that was only 4 or 6 feet high? Unless they're imported from the land of midgets...
- unabridged 14y agoI am a fan of large surface desks with nothing underneath. My favorite desk I've ever had is just a 6ft banquet table like http://www.lifetime.com/tableschairs/rectangular/6-foot-adjustable-height http://www.lifetime.com/tableschairs/rectangular/6-foot-adju.... It can be packed in the back of an SUV/minivan, relatively light, and very sturdy.
- ryporter 14y agoI worked at Amazon in '05/'06, and the perception of frugality was still important then. For example, someone from another group complained to me that they were being forced by higher-ups to remove a set of plastic plants they had recently bought. When it was pointed out that the plants were actually quite cheap (not to mention a sunk cost), the reply was that they "looked expensive."