3 ms·
ERP rollout at Europe's largest local council slammed
- bearjaws 2y agoWhat an embarrassing situation. $163,000,000 spent and nothing to show for it. Of course, Oracle / SAP have absurdly powerful contracts that basically bail them out of any accountability. This is despite both of them being notorious for overruns on their projects, especially government deployments. From a survey, 47% of ERP projects have budget overruns. https://www.statista.com/statistics/526423/worldwide-erp-implementation-projects-cost-overrun/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/526423/worldwide-erp-imp... When you have this many problems in government deployments, it goes from "oopsie doopsie" to "government budget milking machine - working as intended"
- NearAP 2y agoPeople love to blame Oracle or SAP for every botched rollout without actually looking at who is responsible. If you used consultants for the implementation, how is a botched rollout the ERP vendors fault? This article says …… The council initially customized Oracle but now plans to reimplement the software out-of-the-box, adopting standardized processes..…. The above tells you the issue isn’t from Oracle the ERP vendor.
- bearjaws 2y agoSales team and contracting sure have no issue offering those solutions and how "easy they are to implement". Literally every ERP sales process includes an "oh you can customize the edge cases to your needs!", but rarely is that a good idea.
- NearAP 2y ago….every ERP sales process includes an you can customize the edge cases… This isn’t what you think. First, large ERP vendors will repeat the mantra that you shouldn’t customize and that they don’t advise it. At best, implementation consultants will be the one talking about customizing. Secondly, ERP sales process isn’t as simple as you think. Buying firm have a detailed and documented list of requirements and these are checked off as they’re being demoed. If customization is needed, that specific customization needs to be shown before that item requirement is checked off.
- BrandoElFollito 2y agoThey have the contracts someone agreed to sign.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ydlr 2y agoIt seems to me that the whole concept of an off-the-shelf ERP is misguided. These systems have to be heavily customized to fit the needs of the any particular organization. Why not just hire a couple programmers, build what you need from the ground up, using open source components where appropriate? It might take longer than 18 months to finish, but it sounds like that wasn't a realistic estimate for configuring an ERP, either.
- friendzis 2y agoIn any ERP deployment there will be at least two major cost sinks that have absolutely nothing to do with software: enumerating actual business processes and training employees. Before you can even think of "hiring a couple programmers, build what you need from the ground up" you need a very detailed and thorough spec of what the business actually does and hopefully transform said spec into something better served by electronic processes. How much resources do you reckon would it entail to arrive at such spec? The thing is, you can't agile this. ERP is notoriously hard to deploy. You have warehousing in ERP, but purchasing in paper? Accounting will love you.
- rawgabbit 2y agoI believe this is key. Agile is the exact opposite of what should do when writing software for a mature organization like government.
- friendzis 2y agoThere's nothing wrong with applying agile on mature orgs per se. With all due respect, technical software people usually fail miserably at understanding what deploying ERP is. It's by no means software project. The "ERP" could be a huge physical book with all required templates even if very inefficient one, nevertheless deploying such "ERP" would still face *exactly* the same problems. Deploying ERP is first and foremost business transformation. All ERP deployment horror stories that I have some inside info on always revolve around reluctance of business to transform and instead attempting to contort ERP to fit some undefined shape. Deploying ERP painfully highlights all the spots where business processes are undefined, overlapping or flat out useless. Those processes need to be cleaned up, there's no way around that. Every information system follows SiSo/GiGo (Garbage in - Garbage out) principle. Humans can apply common sense heuristics and do reasonable things given garbage data. Information systems cannot. That's the beauty and horror of deploying an ERP. If management is actually willing, it's a perfect opportunity to streamline business processes, but if it is managed as some software deployment over existing business - you get horror stories, reduced efficiency and maintenance hell on top.
- librasteve 2y agoFrom Computer Weekly… https://www.computerweekly.com/news/366572935/Birmingham-City-Councils-Oracle-implementation-explained-What-went-wrong https://www.computerweekly.com/news/366572935/Birmingham-Cit... By 2018, Birmingham decided to review its future requirements of finance, procurement, human resources and payroll systems. It hired Socitm Advisory as part of the process to help it procure a new cloud-based ERP system. The contract was awarded to Insight Direct (UK) Ltd, in partnership with Evosys, on the basis that the pair would deliver what Birmingham City Council’s Report to Cabinet in 2021 described as “a new solution” based on the Oracle Cloud ERP.
- NoZZz 2y agoYour tax dollars at work :/