3 ms·

If you are interested in audio (or stem) separation have a look at RipX https://hitnmix.com/ripx-daw-pro/ https://hitnmix.com/ripx-daw-pro/ It can even export

by fxj 2y ago

If you are interested in audio (or stem) separation have a look at RipX https://hitnmix.com/ripx-daw-pro/ https://hitnmix.com/ripx-daw-pro/ It can even export the separated tracks as midi files. It still has some problems but works very well. Stem separation is now standard in the musical software and almost every DAW provides it.

makz 2y ago
Thanks for the information. I’m a long time Logic Pro user and I wasn’t aware of this feature.
- Sporktacular 2y ago
  On an M1/2/3/4 processor. Not Intel.
sbarre 2y ago
Stemroller[0] has been around for a while too, it's free and based on Meta's models: 0: https://www.stemroller.com/ https://www.stemroller.com/
- cloudking 2y ago
  I've heard Meta's Demucs is SOTA, has anything else better come out since?
  - adzm 2y ago
    It's still pretty much the best, though there are fine tunings and tweaks on top of that and the runner-up MDX that work well for specific scenarios.
oidar 2y ago
> almost every DAW provides it. It's an up and coming feature that nearly every DAW should have, but most don't yet. Ableton Live - No Bigwig - No Cubase - No FL - Yes Logic - Yes Pro Tools - No Reason - No Reaper - No Studio One - Yes
- fxj 2y ago
  MPC3 - Yes Mixcraft - Yes Maschine3 - Yes
tasty_freeze 2y ago
RipX can do stem separation and allows repitching notes in the mix. If that is what you want to do it is great. I find moises (https://moises.ai/ https://moises.ai/) to be easy to use for the tasks I need to do. It allows transposing or time scaling the entire song. It does stem separation and has a simple interface for muting and changing the volume on a per-track basis. It auto-detects the beat and chords. I'm not affiliated, just a happy nearly-daily user for learning and practicing songs. I boost the original bass part and put everything else at < 10% volume to hear the bass part clearly clearly (which often shows how bad online transcriptions are, even paid ones). Once once I know the part, I mute the bass part and play along with the original song as if I was the bass player.
- alok-g 2y ago
  Moises looks promising. I wonder why pricing information is so hard to find these days. Would like to get an idea of the same.
antback 2y ago
It appears to be related to Polymath. https://github.com/samim23/polymath https://github.com/samim23/polymath Polymath is effective at isolating and extracting individual instrument tracks from MP3s. It works very well.

by fxj 2y ago

makz 2y ago

Thanks for the information. I’m a long time Logic Pro user and I wasn’t aware of this feature.

Sporktacular 2y ago
On an M1/2/3/4 processor. Not Intel.

sbarre 2y ago

Stemroller[0] has been around for a while too, it's free and based on Meta's models: 0: https://www.stemroller.com/ https://www.stemroller.com/

cloudking 2y ago
I've heard Meta's Demucs is SOTA, has anything else better come out since?
- adzm 2y ago
  It's still pretty much the best, though there are fine tunings and tweaks on top of that and the runner-up MDX that work well for specific scenarios.

oidar 2y ago

> almost every DAW provides it. It's an up and coming feature that nearly every DAW should have, but most don't yet. Ableton Live - No Bigwig - No Cubase - No FL - Yes Logic - Yes Pro Tools - No Reason - No Reaper - No Studio One - Yes

fxj 2y ago
MPC3 - Yes Mixcraft - Yes Maschine3 - Yes

tasty_freeze 2y ago

RipX can do stem separation and allows repitching notes in the mix. If that is what you want to do it is great. I find moises (https://moises.ai/ https://moises.ai/) to be easy to use for the tasks I need to do. It allows transposing or time scaling the entire song. It does stem separation and has a simple interface for muting and changing the volume on a per-track basis. It auto-detects the beat and chords. I'm not affiliated, just a happy nearly-daily user for learning and practicing songs. I boost the original bass part and put everything else at < 10% volume to hear the bass part clearly clearly (which often shows how bad online transcriptions are, even paid ones). Once once I know the part, I mute the bass part and play along with the original song as if I was the bass player.

alok-g 2y ago
Moises looks promising. I wonder why pricing information is so hard to find these days. Would like to get an idea of the same.

antback 2y ago

It appears to be related to Polymath. https://github.com/samim23/polymath https://github.com/samim23/polymath Polymath is effective at isolating and extracting individual instrument tracks from MP3s. It works very well.