4 ms·
Did anyone read the actual manifesto? [0] The wording sounds a bit confused, because I can't often tell if they're using precise technical definitions for terms
by baddox 14y ago
Did anyone read the actual manifesto? [0] The wording sounds a bit confused, because I can't often tell if they're using precise technical definitions for terms or not, but I'm not seeing what this article's author claims to be seeing. The manifesto appears to denounce government-enforced IP law [1], and the only mention of "public domain" seems to be referring not to creative works without any license or copyright, but rather to the idea that websites run on privately-owned hardware should be considered "public" in some way (and therefore the government's business) [2].
From what I can tell, the main point of this manifesto is that governments are trying to establish control over privately-owned Internet resources, that the language they use is intentionally deceptive, and that governments enjoy a double standard whereby data collection is prohibited for private endeavors but allowed and even encouraged by governments [3].
Perhaps the boingboing author would also consider my views about the Internet and legislation radical and "pretty terrible," but while I consider this manifesto confusing and poorly written, I'm not seeing any evidence of many of his points, and I can't help but agree with many of the manifesto's points. One particular line from this article says "They also ... argue that government monopolies over knowledge should be extended, and that tax-dollars should be used to enforce them." Where is that in the manifesto? Is the author missing something, or am I missing something?
[0] http://www.campaignforliberty.org/profile/14524/blog/2012/07/05/c4l-introduces-technology-revolution http://www.campaignforliberty.org/profile/14524/blog/2012/07...
[1] "Among the most insidious are government attempts to control and regulate competition, infrastructure, privacy, and intellectual property."
[2] "According to them [the Internet collectivists]: ... Private property rights on the Internet should exist in limited fashion or not at all, and what is considered to be in the public domain should be greatly expanded."
[3] "Internet collectivists are clever. They are masters at hijacking the language of freedom and liberty to disingenuously push for more centralized control. 'Openness' means government control of privately owned infrastructure. 'Net neutrality' means government acting as arbiter and enforcer of what it deems to be 'neutral.' 'Internet freedom' means the destruction of property rights. 'Competition' means managed competition, with the government acting as judge and jury on what constitutes competition and what does not. Our 'right to privacy' only applies to the data collection activities of the private sector, rarely to government.
- ojbyrne 14y agoI read the manifesto and found it hard to get past the obvious distortions about the role of government in technology. For starters, not even acknowledging that that wondrous thing called the internet was originally funded by the government.
- baddox 14y agoI don't think the Pauls would intentionally deny or conceal that government funds were used to create the beginnings of the Internet. Just like NASA, I suspect they would take their usual stance: that even when governments use tax revenue to do worthwhile things, it would be preferable (certainly morally and perhaps economically) for private enterprise to accomplish the same things.
- prodigal_erik 14y agoWe've already seen private enterprise solutions to the long-haul network problem: CompuServe and AOL, each of which was a heavily-censored and ludicrously expensive walled garden, soundly rejected by anyone with access to the Internet. Well-run private enterprises avoid creating public goods because they don't pay off, so they aren't going to happen unless you solve the free rider problem (i.e., taxation) or you have so many selfless donors who don't object to free riders that you can ignore the problem.
- saraid216 14y ago> The manifesto appears to denounce government-enforced IP law Out of curiosity, what do you imagine is non-government-enforced IP law?
- baddox 14y agoI didn't have anything specifically in mind, but from what I know about the Pauls I suspect they might approve of IP through non-governmental means, like through voluntary contracts between content producers and consumers.