4 ms·
"The idea is to block viruses from tampering with the boot process and injecting themselves into a system before they can be detected." Does anybody serious be
by bediger4000 14y ago
"The idea is to block viruses from tampering with the boot process and injecting themselves into a system before they can be detected."
Does anybody serious believe that UEFI will "block viruses" from meddling with any boot process? Are boot-sector viruses even a problem any more, because it was pretty obvious that boot-time viruses (like "Brain") were only widely spread by MS-DOS and early Windows, that required a lot of boots. Boot-time viruses never made inroads in other populations of computers, just like Macro viruses never made inroads except in "Word" dominated environments.
UEFI is a power play, pure and simple, just like Digital Rights Management (a.k.a. "copy protection").
- fein 14y agoEven worse, it opens up a whole new attack vector: "UEFI reimplements a full networking stack, unlike many BIOSes, and therefore is a target for remote security exploits" [http://catless.ncl.ac.uk/Risks/26.18.html#subj13 http://catless.ncl.ac.uk/Risks/26.18.html#subj13]
- keithpeter 14y agoSO as soon as someone cracks/leaks the Microsoft key, they can compromise all the Arm tablets? Disclaimer: Not a programmer and not into details of hardware, just interested
- gvb 14y agoYes, they would have the ability to compromise all PCs (ARM, x86). Notes, though: * All BIOS-based PCs and many ARM-based PCs (as well as other CPU-based units) are currently vulnerable. As others have noted, this is not a very active threat vector compared to, say, Flash bugs and infected software ("...to view this p0rn, you have to install this codec" - bam! you are pwned). * Ability to bypass the key signing via a stolen key is necessary but not sufficient for an attack. You also have to get (trick) the user into installed infected boot-type code. The advantage is that you can then install rootkit-class software, which is very very hard to detect and eradicate. * People with "powerful" keys take extensive measures to protect them. Having said that, people with "powerful" keys have slipped up, which causes a lot of problems. Examples: Microsoft's key (an old one) was hacked and used to sign the "Flame" virus, Mozilla's private key revealed, the RSA key token hack. References: http://news.cnet.com/8301-10805_3-57446466-75/flame-virus-spread-through-rogue-microsoft-security-certificates/ http://news.cnet.com/8301-10805_3-57446466-75/flame-virus-sp... http://www.itnews.com.au/News/252766,comodo-hacker-reveals-mozilla-private-key.aspx http://www.itnews.com.au/News/252766,comodo-hacker-reveals-m... http://blogs.computerworld.com/17995/rsa_securid_hacked_2fa_fob_and_software_compromise http://blogs.computerworld.com/17995/rsa_securid_hacked_2fa_...
- yuhong 14y agoYes they are reappearing. Look up "bootkits".
- bediger4000 14y agoExcellent! How do they spread? People no longer leave MS-DOS or Windows 1.0 "boot floppies" in A: to get infected on the next reboot. The implementation of UEFI needs to be flawless for the keys and the signing to make any difference, leaked or not, except for control of the consumer marketplace. Look at "rooting" Android smartphones, or putting alternate OSes on the Wii. Imperfect implementations spoil the security. Even if "bootkits" are making a boot sector virus comeback, UEFI will not make much more than a temporary difference.
- yuhong 14y agoThey don't spread by themselves, they are installed by rootkits to help hide them. I recently had to clean up such a rootkit.
- gcb 14y agoAll this only serve to make ms strong again on consumer market. It's the good old bait and switch. And Ubuntu suckers are going right into "ohh i have money. I can buy into the game and finally have more installs than Debian" Let's see how that plays out later, since we all know this boot shenanigans do nothing it advertised (virus, security) and only serve to harden the installation of non windows os
- geofft 14y agoIf by "money" you mean $99 to buy a certificate from Verisign. Debian also has $99 to throw at Verisign, it's just making up its mind as to whether it wants to. I'm not saying I'm happy about any of this, but complaining about the money makes you sound exactly as credible as someone calling Ubuntu suckers because they pay for SSL certificates. (Especially because SSL has all the same issues of root keys owned by rapacious trusted third parties, and a security benefit that isn't obviously that big, these days...)
- gcb 14y agothe sucker part is about the big picture. SSL for all it's problems still is the closest to provide http securely. This safeboot thing helps with nothing. at all. now back to the sucker part. thanks to ubuntu, everyone now instead of complaining or not buying hardware because free drivers aren't provided, will just and gladly use binary ones. and then complain that linux is unstable. i know it's a fine line to walk since otherwise they will just complain linux is not compatible with anything... but i think the later is fixable.
- recoiledsnake 14y ago>Does anybody serious believe that UEFI will "block viruses" from meddling with any boot process? Are boot-sector viruses even a problem any more, because it was pretty obvious that boot-time viruses (like "Brain") were only widely spread by MS-DOS and early Windows, that required a lot of boots. Boot-time viruses never made inroads in other populations of computers, just like Macro viruses never made inroads except in "Word" dominated environments. I have addressed this in a previous comment here. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4190483 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4190483
- burntwater 14y agoBoot-sector or similar viruses are absolutely a problem, thanks to the prevalence of spyware. Just ask anyone who routinely deals with end-user desktop maintenance. You generally have to alter your cleaning techniques every few weeks to deal with the latest and greatest.
- freehunter 14y agoAt my workplace, I get alerts whenever our security event monitor notices a pattern consistent with malware. We've had ~10 boot sector malware infections since May, most of them being ZeroAccess. Our policy is to reimage the computer rather than try to remove it, in order to keep maintenance times low. As you mentioned, ZeroAccess is spyware that installs itself to the master boot record to avoid detection or removal. Boot sector viruses are indeed still an unfortunately common issue.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- ladzoppelin 14y agoPower play for what? Boot time root kits are a serious problem for Linux, OSX and Windows. http://www.stoned-vienna.com/ http://www.stoned-vienna.com/ IOS already signs their UEFI and blocks Linux from installing so it looks bad when Apple is not even mentioned in any UEFI discussions. The Ipad is the most used ARM tablet and any competitors need to at least do what Apple does if they want to compete. If Apple did not lock the boot-loader it would then be susceptible to known root-kits that are incredibly hard to detect once loaded. Linux and Android are also vulnerable to this attack.