3 ms·
The point is meat/chicken consumption isn't required for population growth.
by ceejayoz 2y ago
The point is meat/chicken consumption isn't required for population growth.
- JumpCrisscross 2y agoIsn’t required but in practice occurs. With both population and wealth. We aren’t getting rid of chicken or beef any time soon.
- ceejayoz 2y ago> We aren’t getting rid of chicken or beef any time soon. This is a very different argument. We won't be. We could, in short order, if we all wanted to, without having to "ctrl-z the last ~60 years of population growth around the world" as asserted upthread.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> We could, in short order, if we all wanted to, without having to "ctrl-z the last ~60 years of population growth around the world" as asserted upthread This is akin to we could wish war away. Like sure. We could. If you want to reduce chicken consumption, the practical route is reducing population or wealth.
- fsflover 2y agoYou could also promote nature-friendly lifestyle and support vegetarians somehow.
- nomel 2y ago73% of the Indian population is protein deficient [1]. [1] https://www.orfonline.org/expert-speak/indias-protein-deficiency-and-the-need-to-address-the-problem https://www.orfonline.org/expert-speak/indias-protein-defici...
- ceejayoz 2y agoYou've argued elsewhere in the thread that "60 to 75% of the population eats meat". Now you're arguing 73% are protein deficient. These are hard stats to combine into a "it's the not-meat-eating that's the problem"; either one stat is wrong/misleading (I suspect "meat" includes fish, for example), or there are other factors than "not enough chicken".
- nomel 2y agoI can't follow what you're saying. Someone mentioned that India would be surprised that removing animal protein would undo population growth. I see these "hard stats" as being in complete opposition to that idea. The data says that most of the population eats meat, and nearly of the population consumes animal proteins, but and in spite of that, most of the population is not eating enough protein. Since they're not eating enough protein, as is, removing animal protein seems like a bad idea. Suggesting that they would be ok even if animal protein were removed, when all evidence says they're having trouble even with animal protein, doesn't seem realistic. The more realistic approach would be to add more protein to India. One way to do this would be more animals (I don't know how this maths would work).
- Jedd 2y agoThere are clearly overlaps in those cohorts. Doubtless plenty of the 60-75% demographic that eats some amount of meat, are getting insufficient protein. I speculate that's because meat is not readily available to them - though it's likely also true that the non-meat foods they're eating are not filling the protein gap either.