5 ms·
Microcontrollers and stepper motors were already controlling 2-D printers in the 01970s and early 01980s at higher speeds and similar powers to currently popula
by kragen 2y ago
Microcontrollers and stepper motors were already controlling 2-D printers in the 01970s and early 01980s at higher speeds and similar powers to currently popular 3-D printers. The first RepRaps did not "use a full-power PC as their host machine"; they were controlled by AVRs, just like Arduino (which didn't exist yet). Generating motor control waveforms on a full-power PC is a nightmare nowadays, and was already a nightmare in 02005. The LinuxCNC people would do it by running Linux under a real-time hypervisor. The first CNC machining was done in the 01950s with IBM 704s, comparable in power to an Intel 8008. The 6502 used by the Commodore 64 to drive its floppy drive would have worked fine, though it is much slower than the AVR and doesn't have built-in PWM generation hardware.
I agree that the pieces did not exist in the 01970s, but the missing pieces weren't the computation.
- actionfromafar 2y agoNow I'm very tempted to build a 3D printer with an 8-bit home computer and vintage parts.
- dcminter 2y agoThat sounds like a delightful project! This contemporary book from Usborne demonstrates the point that basic stepper controls from an 8-bit computer were well within hobbyist reach: https://drive.google.com/file/d/0Bxv0SsvibDMTZ2tQMmpyOWtsRFk/view?resourcekey=0-zt3ZcOMMA30T_LJlUEzoDQ https://drive.google.com/file/d/0Bxv0SsvibDMTZ2tQMmpyOWtsRFk... I do think that the limitations of memory (and disk) will require some ingenuity in 3D printing more than the most trivial procedurally defined objects!
- Suppafly 2y agoThat's a great book, it looks so simplistic and then the next thing you know it's teaching you about resistors and soldering and programming, all in like 50 pages of mostly graphics.
- aforwardslash 2y agoJust buy an old ender 3, they came with stock 8bit cpus :)
- wilg 2y agoid watch a youtube of this
- TuringTourist 2y agoMake your own 8-bit computer on breadboard a la Ben Eater for bonus points
- Suppafly 2y agoMy son is into vintage computers and I'm pretty sure I could make a 3d printer from the old c64s, disk drives, and printers in my basement. The hot end would be the only issue and I'm pretty sure you could rig one up from a glue gun or soldering iron.
- stevekemp 2y agoFloating point maths would be hard, and fitting the model in 64k would be a challenge - but paging could resolve that, or streaming/paging from disk if you assume something like CP/M. Logically it's a simple project, though the devil is always in the details!
- kragen 2y agoFloating-point was ubiquitous in the BASIC interpreters on early home computers. It was just slow. CP/M didn't really do paging, although you could read and write 128-byte records to disk. But CP/M disks were typically only 90 kibibytes, or maybe up to a mebibyte for 8-inch floppies. And a lot of hobbyist home computers omitted disk drives because they were too expensive.
- stevekemp 2y agoSure floating point is possible, but if you're thinking of something like a 6502 or Z80 you'd have to implement it yourself - no maths co-processor, or dedicated instructions for it. In terms of paging I was thinking of paging in later layers of data from disk, perhaps from a large file, perhaps from a series of files. But CP/M certainly did have support for paging RAM, in 3.x, if your hardware supported it. (My own emulator, and the hardware I have running genuine CP/M are all running 2.x so no paged RAM there. Shame!)
- kragen 2y agoYeah, people did do overlays a lot on CP/M. If you were using a 6502 or Z80 in the late 70s you wouldn't have to write the floating-point routines; you could just call the ones in the BASIC interpreter you probably had in ROM. They'd still be slow. As for paging RAM, do you mean bank switching? The 8085 and Z80 didn't have MMUs, so you couldn't do "paging" in the sense people normally understand it today.
- kragen 2y agoI'm very interested to hear about the results if you do. If I'm wrong, you'll be able to show me how!
- inglor_cz 2y agoAn offtopic question: how do you manage to write all the years consistently with 0 at the start (I know why, but how), when everyone around you uses a different standard. If I decided, IDK, to write "cnow" instead of "know", or "J" instead of "I", I wouldn't be able to do so consistently. Not in a world that massively uses the other word. Or it would take me twice as much time to double-check everything that I have typed.
- kqr 2y agoYou get into the habit fairly quickly. I type organise rather than organize despite everyone around me not doing that, but it is legitimately difficult for me to do it the popular way.
- mongol 2y agoI don't even know the why. Why?
- ForHackernews 2y agoI assume they're a fan of https://longnow.org/ https://longnow.org/
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- smeej 2y agoWait, I can guess at why (somebody's probably still going to be alive in 8k more years), but is that really the reason? In case somebody's gonna care enough to read this comment on HN that long from now? And not realize that of course we didn't bother adding leading zeros? Why not 0001970s in that case? (I'm sincerely hoping I'm missing something here and am going to look really silly asking this question.)
- tdeck 2y ago> The first RepRaps did not "use a full-power PC as their host machine"; they were controlled by AVRs, just like Arduino It's possible that they were referring to the RepRap Host Software, which was RepRap's original slicer. https://reprap.org/wiki/DriverSoftware https://reprap.org/wiki/DriverSoftware
- kragen 2y agoOh, I'm sure you're right! Thank you. I didn't realize Skeinforge wasn't the first.