3 ms·
This still devalues the creation of software that is genuine innovation. ... Before artificially segregating software into a ghetto I'm not sure if it comes th
by josteink 14y ago
This still devalues the creation of software that is genuine innovation. ... Before artificially segregating software into a ghetto
I'm not sure if it comes through in my post, but what I wrote I intended for all patents, not just software patents. If your product or category of product (software or not) only has a lifespan of 2 years, patents for that product or product-category cannot be made to last more than those 2 years.
In that sense I'm not devaluing software (or any other products for that matter) any more than the people producing them already do.
That may not fully satisfy you and your point of view, but it seems to me it would address some of your concerns. If you still find it objectionable, I guess that's fine by me. We are all entitled to our opinion.
Sometimes, even reasonable people cannot be made to agree ;)
- runako 14y agoFair enough, and your position makes sense to me. (A lot more sense than those who would specifically curtail software protections.) I think there's something to this approach, but I can't help wondering how anyone would define the lifespan of a product. Also, I think reasonable definitions would be much longer than you'd like and closer to the existing 20 years. I kept my last mobile phone for 6 years, for instance, so I'd probably say 10+ years is reasonable for technology in a mobile phone. WinXP is 15 years into its invention cycle, etc.