2 ms·
#1 devalues genuine software innovation. If a software innovation is genuine, why is it worth less protection? While a good general argument, you have to ask w
by josteink 14y ago
#1 devalues genuine software innovation. If a software innovation is genuine, why is it worth less protection?
While a good general argument, you have to ask what software which was developed 20 years ago is still relevant today. Most software 20 years old is not even available today, and even if you had stored a copy, it would probably not be possible to find hardware which would run it correctly or at all.
Basically, 20 years of computing-time represents several generations of products and innovations. 20 years for a patent may have been a relevant timeframe when products had a lifespan that long.
I think it would be hard to argue that this is still the case.
The solution is not to extend software patents to 20 years. The solution is to reduce patent-time to fit the lifespan of products within the category which for the patent is valid.
Which for software would mean an absolute maximum of 10 years, with 3 years much more reasonable.
- runako 14y ago>> Which for software would mean an absolute maximum of 10 years, with 3 years much more reasonable. This still devalues the creation of software that is genuine innovation. Think about mainframe software that controls factories, for instance, which can be bought over 10 years after creation. Also consider the prevalence today of Windows XP, which shipped in 2001 (and where any relevant patents would date to the 1990s when it was developed). Microsoft has reluctantly stopped selling it, but I'd argue that we still don't know how long the useful lifespan of WinXP will be. And we're probably ~15 years in from when patents in XP would have been filed. Before artificially segregating software into a ghetto, ask this: would this innovation be worthy of protection if there were a purpose-built device that performs the same function? If the device would be worthy of protection, then it's going to be hard to argue that the software embodiment is somehow worth less protection. (At least it will be hard to argue this with me, but I'm a chauvinist for programmers.) Finally, the argument that the old software becomes irrelevant is congruent with equal protection for software. If old software loses relevance, then so do the patents (and correspondingly their utility to patent trolls). I think you mean precisely the opposite: old innovations in software actually become more relevant, so that everyone wants to use them in their own wares. Nobody rushed to shorten the lifespan of vacuum tube patents because they became irrelevant. I don't think it's reasonable to reduce software patent lifespans to shorter durations than that of the hardware the software runs on, or the cables used to transmit it.
- josteink 14y agoThis still devalues the creation of software that is genuine innovation. ... Before artificially segregating software into a ghetto I'm not sure if it comes through in my post, but what I wrote I intended for all patents, not just software patents. If your product or category of product (software or not) only has a lifespan of 2 years, patents for that product or product-category cannot be made to last more than those 2 years. In that sense I'm not devaluing software (or any other products for that matter) any more than the people producing them already do. That may not fully satisfy you and your point of view, but it seems to me it would address some of your concerns. If you still find it objectionable, I guess that's fine by me. We are all entitled to our opinion. Sometimes, even reasonable people cannot be made to agree ;)
- runako 14y agoFair enough, and your position makes sense to me. (A lot more sense than those who would specifically curtail software protections.) I think there's something to this approach, but I can't help wondering how anyone would define the lifespan of a product. Also, I think reasonable definitions would be much longer than you'd like and closer to the existing 20 years. I kept my last mobile phone for 6 years, for instance, so I'd probably say 10+ years is reasonable for technology in a mobile phone. WinXP is 15 years into its invention cycle, etc.
- robotresearcher 14y agoTeX was first released in 1978. BSD UNIX in 1977. I don't know how much of that code is running today, but I'd be very surprised if the methods embodied in that code (the patentable parts) have changed very much in 20 years. There may well be chunks of code more than 20 years old in both those widely-used and absolutely relevant systems. Lots of decades-old C, Fortran and Lisp code compiles and runs just fine today. Code has been quite well decoupled from architecture since the 1970s, if you choose to write it that way.