3 ms·
The original intent of patents, long forgotten, was to limit the use of trade secrets. Trade secrets have the unfortunate property that the public state-of-the-
by jandrewrogers 14y ago
The original intent of patents, long forgotten, was to limit the use of trade secrets. Trade secrets have the unfortunate property that the public state-of-the-art can be decades behind the private R&D. This was endemic during the times of guilds.
The reversion to a use of trade secrets, at least in software (because patents are largely unenforceable), is recreating some of the issues that patents were intended to avoid. In my own area of computer science, the private state-of-the-art is at least half a decade ahead of academia. This was the situation that patents were intended to avoid.
- ZeroGravitas 14y agoIf academia is only 5 years behind then it doesn't seem a good deal for the public to give 20 years monopoly on ideas, particularly so if those ideas build on top of each other and lead to patent gridlock. (Of course in reality, academia is part of this patent gridlock, but the general point remains)
- jandrewrogers 14y agoThe point is more that academic research is reinventing the wheel rather than doing genuinely productive research. Instead of researchers researching stuff that needs to be researched, a significant number of them are researching things that other researchers have known the answer to for years. It is not an effective use of human capital.