2 ms·
A Ponzi scheme is an investment system where the payout of current investors comes from the payin of future investors. That's the definition of ponzi. Does SS
by yummyfajitas 18y ago
A Ponzi scheme is an investment system where the payout of current investors comes from the payin of future investors. That's the definition of ponzi.
Does SS meet that definition or not? If so, it's a Ponzi scheme. The fact that it lasted longer than other historical Ponzi schemes does not change it's nature.
- Retric 18y agoA Ponzi scheme is a fraudulent investment operation that pays returns to investors out of the money paid by subsequent investors rather than from profit. SS does not hide the fact that it pays money from dead investors to the living so it's not fraudulent. It does use some money from new investors to payout money but so does life insurance. PS: While some people get far more out of SS than they pay in many people got zero benefits. With a SS their will would still "own" their money but with SS it diapers into the void. I don't mind calling SS a period scheme, but a lot of 22 year old's are going to die before their 60's so the math can work out just fine.
- gills 18y agoOne point that has not appeared in your dialog, in favor of identifying SS as a Ponzi scheme, is that the excess accumulation of Social Security taxes has been spent on other things and replaced with IOUs by Congress (this is how the Clinton administration produced a so-called budget 'surplus').
- tptacek 18y agoFirst, the Clinton administration did not synthesize a surplus out of the social security trust fund; they simply had the good fortune to take office during a period of historic productivity expansion. Second of all, the "IOUs" you're talking about are government bonds. For your argument to hold, you have to assert that the government is going to default on its own bonds.
- miked 18y agoGovernments default on their own bonds often enough. Cf. Argentina plus a whole slew of third-world countries. I'll skip the theory and offer a single data point: the employees of the Social Security Administration do not, themselves, use or pay into SS. Neither do any other US Government employees. That is, the people who know the most about the system think it's so good that they don't want any part of it. It's almost like they know something some of us don't.
- Retric 18y agoI would suggest that the general fund is a Ponzi scheme backed by selling IOU's. We are borrowing more money to pay the interest on money we already borrowed and adding more debt on top of that. Long term we need to start borrowing less than the interest on our debt - inflation. Which is not all that high a number vs GDP.
- tptacek 18y agoSocial Security isn't an investment system; it's a social insurance program. A Ponzi Scheme is an investment scam; victim investors are, for a short time, paid an unnaturally high rate of return based on the recruitment of an ever-broadening base of new victims.
- yummyfajitas 18y agoThe retirement component of social security is not insurance. It does not spread the cost of low probability, high cost events among the insured. Only the very small disability insurance part of SS does this. As I mentioned, that is a separate issue. Tell me; if Madoff called his hedge fund an "insurance program", and actually devoted 1% of it to providing disability insurance, would that make it not a Ponzi scheme? Incidentally, Madoff's returns were not unnaturally high, just unnaturally regular. As for the fraud, it's true that the nature of SS is quite clear. SS uses force instead; if you don't pay in, you get locked up. So maybe "Ponzi Protection Racket" would be more accurate than "Ponzi Scheme".
- tptacek 18y agoYou're arguing that Social Security isn't an insurance program. I'm arguing that it isn't an investment system. If we're both right, it's still not a Ponzi Scam. It doesn't blow up like a pyramid scheme, and it doesn't attract victims with returns on investment. What it does is allow a generation of entrepreneurs to start companies instead of working for Geico and Alcoa to keep their parents out of the cat food.
- yummyfajitas 18y agoI'm not sure how it isn't an investment system; you put money in because you are forced, but with the hope of getting money out later. That's closer to an investment than to insurance, though I guess the use of force confuses things. You could be right, I never thought of it this way. Take a scam, then use a gun to force people to participate without disguising your intentions. Is it still a scam? Maybe not, I'll have to think about it.