3 ms·
My question is why they need to prove the dude was on the bridge? Didn't they arrest him there? Regardless, assuming privacy rights when using a public social n
by briandear 14y ago
My question is why they need to prove the dude was on the bridge? Didn't they arrest him there? Regardless, assuming privacy rights when using a public social network is a bit of a stretch. Even phone records are subject to release with a warrant. If one is worried about privacy, then don't tweet or Facebook your damned location.
The Twitter TOS might be illuminating for this case. If Twitter guarantees privacy then the defendant might have a civil case against Twitter if records are released. Though they do have indemnification clauses..
I'm not too sympathetic to this dude's plight, a reasonable person would expect arrest for blocking the Brooklyn Bridge. How many people were financially harmed by this guy's actions? Protest is one thing, but when his expression of his rights interferes with my right to get to work and earn a living, then he has very little moral ground upon which to stand.
- panarky 14y agoMaybe the district attorney isn't really interested in proving the defendant was on the bridge, but is using this trivial case as a pretext to get at his social network. The DA requested not only his location, but IP addresses used to access Twitter plus all email addresses linked to his account. Source: https://www.eff.org/cases/new-york-v-harris https://www.eff.org/cases/new-york-v-harris
- greenyoda 14y agoDefinitely a pretext. NYC would not expend all those resources just to convict someone of disorderly conduct (which is only a misdemeanor offense). And believe it or not, there are real crimes happening in NYC which the DA might want to spend a bit more time on, instead of going after protesters. As a taxpayer, I'd be very curious to know why my money is being spent on this.