4 ms·
The life insurance aspect of SS is always overlooked in discussions on its impending collapse. I would guess that it's just not a significant factor. The yearly
by mattmaroon 18y ago
The life insurance aspect of SS is always overlooked in discussions on its impending collapse. I would guess that it's just not a significant factor. The yearly Social Security/Medicare payments for the average American is something like $7,500. Term Life would be what, $600?
I'm not sure what you meant after that. Actuarial tables take life spans into account. And people are not living longer, see my original comment. That's a myth, and not the problem at all.
- Retric 18y agoThe average lifespan is not increasing but the percent of people living into old age is. Someone dieing at 55 vs 60 does not save SS the money of someone dieing at 85 vs 80. The baby boom also distorted the number of young people supporting old people, but over the next 40 years far more people will reach 95 than did 40 years ago. The other main support of SS was the long term increase in income, but middle class wage stagnation has also impacted SS. Most of the economic growth over the last 20 years has occurred well above the SS cap so it's not capturing that growth. PS: (technology) Cars kill the young, medicine and sanitation keeps the old alive. Few young people need much in the way of medicine and few old people drive.
- mattmaroon 18y agoYou have it backward. The percentage of people living into old age has not changed significantly. The average lifespan from birth has, but that's not relevant to SS. The average lifespan of someone who enters the system (an adult, at let's say age 18) is the same. The percentage of people who live from the age of 18 to the age of 95 will not be higher than 40 years ago, in fact, it may be lower.
- Retric 18y agoThe average lifespan has not changed much once you hit 18, but your chances of dieing between 30 and 40 have gone up where your chances of dieing between 60 and 70 have gone down. I need to find and old actuarial table from the 50's to show compare with today. Edit: http://www.ssa.gov/OACT/STATS/table4c6.html http://www.ssa.gov/OACT/STATS/table4c6.html I should say the odds of hitting 100 from 1 are about the same but the odds of hitting 100 from 65 have increased. Male death probability with some comments by me: 01) 0.000513 06) 0.000182 11) 0.000104 12) 0.000156 13) 0.000273 (wow big jump suicide?) 14) 0.000435 (some car) 18) 0.001061 (more car) 21) 0.001361 (full car) 23) 0.001438 (peak of early death risk) 31) 0.001367 (still car) 41) 0.002629 (start of heath issues?) 51) 0.005657 61) 0.012966 71) 0.030131 81) 0.075724 91) 0.199019 101) 0.388563 PS: Old age is bad for your heath but 21 vs 31 is about the same because it's mostly accidental death aka car accidents. Just watch the increase from 14 till 23.
- mattmaroon 18y agoThat's not worth much in and of itself. It has to be compared with past data to be relevant to the argument. Also, it would have to be that 18-65 has gone down while 66+ has gone up. Seems highly unlikely to have done so significantly.
- Retric 18y agoStill looking, but I found one for japan: http://www.mhlw.go.jp/english/database/db-hw/lifetb04/2.html http://www.mhlw.go.jp/english/database/db-hw/lifetb04/2.html 1955: 40 and live to 60 = 71%; 2004: 40 and live to 60 = 88%; 1955: 60 and live to 80 = 32%; 2004: 60 and live to 80 = 64%; Edit US: http://www.infoplease.com/ipa/A0005124.html http://www.infoplease.com/ipa/A0005124.html (Looks like deaths are down per 100,000 people but I can't find the right tables.) Edit: Got it: Even more old people in the US: 1990 vs 2000: http://www.infoplease.com/ipa/A0905042.html http://www.infoplease.com/ipa/A0905042.html look at Percent change in the over 75 age range. The US population was not growing anywhere near that fast.
- mattmaroon 18y agoThat's not showing anything about life spans, just the baby boomers getting older. It's the retiree to worker ratio shifting as they age.
- Retric 18y agoBaby boomers are not that old yet. These are the number of people over 75 in 2000 vs 1990. 1990 - 75 = 1915 and before vs 1925 and before. 95 years and over + 34%. Are you suggesting that there was a 34% population boom between around 1885 and 1905?
- justindz 18y agoThis is an important point you've raised. In particular, lowered infant mortality combined with a poor grasp of statistics makes it look like you and I are living longer, even when those infants that might have died before could end up keeling over at 30 from health problems and we might die a few years earlier than we were likely to a few decades ago. Also, people who are living longer as a result of advances in life-saving surgery are doing so in poor health as a result of the reasons for the increased necessity of these surgeries such as coronary heart disease and type 2 diabetes. Increasing the retirement age in this context could mean attempting to employ a bunch of people not fit to be productive, in a worst case scenario.
- mattmaroon 18y agoI blame it on the government for citing the worthless stat in the first place. They rarely express it as anything other than from birth expectancy. They should mention it from some stable age like 5, then simply show infant mortality stats separately. Though I guess they don't want to do that because we have one of the worst rates in the developed world.
- justindz 18y agoCongress is good at fund raising, not math.