4 ms·
James Randi's explanation of homeopathy is incredibly intellectually dishonest. In the video Randi says that homeopathy involves extreme dilution to the point w
by Alex3917 14y ago
James Randi's explanation of homeopathy is incredibly intellectually dishonest. In the video Randi says that homeopathy involves extreme dilution to the point where virtually none of the original substance is left. But this isn't true. There were two schools of homeopathy, high dilutionists and low dilutionists. Only one school of homeopathy believed in dilution like this.
It was homeopathy that pioneered evidence-based medicine, which is why mainstream medicine eventually merged with low dilution homeopathy and began to use its methods. But Randi doesn't mention that either.
- MartinCron 14y agoNote: I don't want to be the [citation needed] asshole here, but this is the first time I've heard of the distinct schools of homeopathy and I'm skeptical (of course). Can you point me to an article about this history?
- Alex3917 14y agoFrom JAMA: http://jama.jamanetwork.com/article.aspx?articleid=202602 http://jama.jamanetwork.com/article.aspx?articleid=202602 "19th-century homeopaths pioneered systematic drug-testing research, challenged the dangerously depleting procedures of mainstream physicians at that time, established rigorous professional standards, and valued advanced education at least as highly as their mainstream counterparts did. It was not without reason that homeopaths considered the bases of their approach to medical problems to be more logical and more promising than the inherited tradition of the ancients, upon which mainstream physicians still based their practices. [...] This book will be useful primarily to scholars looking for specific information about particular people, events, and developments within the homeopathic movement during the period covered. Among other things, readers will find the names—and often the opinions—of hundreds of previously invisible homeopathic practitioners, publicists, and professors; they will follow fierce debates between the so-called high-dilutionists (whose therapeutic commitment to infinitesimally small doses of supposedly energized substances verged on spiritualism) and the low-dilutionists (who ultimately merged with mainstream physicians in the early decades of the 20th century); they will explore the founding and fate of homeopathic medical schools; they will listen to well-intentioned homeopaths defend themselves against attacks from the American Medical Association; and they will learn about regional variations in the character, reception, and legal standing of homeopathy around the country." Anyway not to defend homeopathy, but I just find it sad that so many people view James Randi as a credible source despite the fact that he can rarely go five minutes without lying about something.
- MartinCron 14y agoThank you! It seems a stretch to say that James Randi is lying when he doesn't include a disclaimer that the same word happened to also be used for something more scientific around 80 years ago. Everything Randi talks about is perfectly true if you use the contemporary understanding of the word "homeopathy"
- Alex3917 14y ago"Everything Randi talks about is perfectly true if you use the contemporary understanding of the word 'homeopathy'. Which he wasn't. He was specifically talking about homeopathy in the period when it was invented and when it came to the US in the mid 19th century. In fact he even talks about 'the proving', which as a far as I know isn't even actively done anymore in modern homeopathy. (I'm pretty sure the modern manufacturers are just reusing old formulas and not actually doing new 'research'.)
- zargon 14y agoHe gave some historical background but also brought it around to how homeopathic preparations are presently made, with the examples of actual products using 30x and 1500x dilutions. There are lots of specifics we could be pedantic about, but I agree with the grandparent that for a 15 minute summary of homeopathy it's on target.
- freshhawk 14y agoLet's pull another part of that quote: "John S. Haller, Jr, reminds us that homeopathy in the 19th century rested upon highly specific principles—all of which flowed from Samuel Hahnemann's fundamental axiom that “like cures like”" Taking a magical axiom as a given and then using scientific principles is not science. You can make the exact same arguments about alchemists and some schools of occult study. They used careful and meticulous methods, and even made some discoveries in the areas of lab work or procedure that were useful to many areas. These things don't mean the beliefs are any more true. So you're mad at Randi for not providing a small piece of historical context in a presentation about protecting people from modern con artists? That just seems like you are looking for something to object to.
- ippisl 14y agocitation needed.