3 ms·
The heist that made the Mona Lisa famous
- LeoPanthera 2y agoOK, this is a horrific tangent, but if you haven't seen the classic Doctor Who story "City of Death", go check it out. Written by Douglas Adams and filmed on-location in Paris, it involves the Mona Lisa being stolen, and is probably the finest Doctor Who story ever written. In fact it's so good that I'm always a little disappointed by other classic stories in comparison.
- jhdias 2y agohttps://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/p00vh9yb/doctor-who-19631996-season-17-city-of-death-part-1 https://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/p00vh9yb/doctor-who-19...
- kQq9oHeAz6wLLS 2y agoWhile we're on this tangent, I found Audrey Hepburn's "How To Steal A Million" rather entertaining.
- devindotcom 2y agoI've always loved this quote: "What audacious criminal, what mystifier, what maniac collector, what insane lover, has committed this abduction?" Though Peruggia claims he did it out of patriotism, I've always nursed the theory that, during its absence, the original was used as reference to create several extremely good fake versions. These could be sold as the original, since everyone knew it had been stolen, and each would think they had the real one. Then the original is returned, and the buyers are without recourse. What are you going to do, tell the police? And of course Peruggia et al would say nothing. I suspect this isn't true, but the fun part is that it could be and no one would ever know. So I'm choosing to believe it is so.
- ricksunny 2y agoI like this approach to epistemology :) Imagine how many what-ifs it could turn up if automated & applied across the corpus of knowledge (scientific & otherwise) :) We'd have Pepe Silvio on steroids, and that I'd like to see =)
- david927 2y agoThe details of the crime seem to point to something like this. Remember that Picasso was questioned and probably involved. One theory is that what we think is the original is, in fact, a master-copy by Picasso. The original is held privately in Florence.
- pgalvin 2y agoUnfortunately (for a fun theory), carbon dating and x-rays of the Mona Lisa have disproved that.
- david927 2y agoThere's a reason why you have connoisseurs. You can fool carbon dating by using materials from that time. I'll have to look into the x-rays and what they show, but it can be quite hard to prove art authentic with scientific methods alone.
- PittleyDunkin 2y agoIt'd make a lot more sense to fake the black market copies you actually make money off of.
- tough 2y agoUnless you wanna keep the original for yourself too
- PittleyDunkin 2y agoThat doesn't seem very smart.
- starlite-5008 2y ago[dead]
- 2y ago
- RandomThoughts3 2y agoYour post reminds me of the very underrated latest film from Orson Well, F for Fake, which is about forgery. It contains an excellent quote from Elmyr de Hory, a notorious art forger, who at some point exclaims: "Guilty? Of what? Making masterpieces?".
- devindotcom 2y agoI watched it recently, interesting film for sure. In his Cape Era.
- daviddavid11 2y ago[flagged]
- jampa 2y agoArchive link for non-US users: https://web.archive.org/web/20241109154132/https://www.history.com/news/the-heist-that-made-the-mona-lisa-famous#expand https://web.archive.org/web/20241109154132/https://www.histo...
- mkl 2y agoThe original worked fine from NZ, so there must be some tighter criterion.
- alsetmusic 2y ago> Peruggia, meanwhile, was charged with theft and put on trial in Italy. During his testimony, he claimed that national pride had inspired him to steal the painting, which he believed had been looted from his native Italy during the Napoleonic era. Peruggia was mistaken—Da Vinci had brought the Mona Lisa to France in 1516, and King Francois I had later purchased it legally—but the patriotic defense won him legions of admirers. Even after the prosecution presented evidence that he planned to shop the painting around to art dealers and sell it for profit, many Italians still considered him a national hero. Just the sort of nationalism that would lead Europe (and other nations) into the Great War only a few years later. The guy only served seven months. Nationalism begets poor outcomes.
- rlue 2y agoThis is the subject of a fun little ditty on Vulfpeck’s upcoming live album: https://youtube.com/watch?v=T7ahw2jhpdE https://youtube.com/watch?v=T7ahw2jhpdE
- cafard 2y agoWhy does this notion persist? Water Pater wrote a famous essay on the painting in 1869. My impression is that it made a pretty big splash in the English-speaking world, at least: much later, W.B. Yeats used a sentence from the essay in his Oxford Book of Modern Verse.
- tomcam 2y agoI... I don't see what's special about the Mona Lisa. daVinci's drawings, on the other hand, teem with life.
- dudisubekti 2y agoIt is way over-rated, but it’s still among Leonardo’s best works IMO Personally I like “Virgin on the Rocks” more
- kombookcha 2y agoIt's a good painting, but with such an unreasonable amount of hype, the real deal can only disappoint. You can't even really engage with it as a painting, it's become some kind of inescapable weird hyper symbol of Great Art (tm). St John the Baptist gets me far better than Mona Lisa. And as you say, the drawings are kinda where he really shines. I like to think that for a guy with so many different talents and pursuits, doing all these repetitive, careful passes over what was ultimately commission work to pay his bills was less engaging than the rapid, iterative nature of drawing. Technical and precise, yet ferociously vivid.
- tomcam 2y agoBeautifully put. Of course I have to agree.
- Avalaxy 2y agoReally? This is why the Mona Lisa is famous? Not because of any intrinsic properties of the painting itself?
- ramonverse 2y agoIt's funny that most of people think the Mona Lisa is a masterpiece when in truth there is nothing particularly interesting about this painting. Just the heist that made it famous