3 ms·
>HOAs often enacts rules that would be illegal for a city council to enact. (between the US constitution, US federal laws, State constitution, State laws, and c
by gruez 2y ago
>HOAs often enacts rules that would be illegal for a city council to enact. (between the US constitution, US federal laws, State constitution, State laws, and county laws there are often strict limits to what can be done that HOAs are not effected by). Courts have reigned in some of that, but there is still a lot that a HOA can do.
Can you give some examples that are applicable today?
>HOAs also tend to be too small - it is hard to find someone qualified who wants to be in charge and so they are often forced to accept some busybody nobody really likes because at least that person wants the job. As you get larger you get a choice of qualified people for the job (but of course also large enough for corruption to take effect).
This might vary on a state by state basis, but there are some pretty "cities" in some states. In Florida, there are plenty with population in the hundreds. In some cases it's due to it being rural, but there's plenty of cases where the city is simply small. For instance: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Briny_Breezes,_Florida https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Briny_Breezes,_Florida
more: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_municipalities_in_Florida https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_municipalities_in_Flor...
- dghlsakjg 2y ago> Can you give some examples that are applicable today? HOAs are pretty famously restrictive of free speech (house color restrictions, yard sign restrictions, political activism restrictions), and free association (visitor restrictions). Their are some speech restrictions that governments apply to historic structures, but you would have a hard time as a government trying to register the name of every visitor to a residence, or restricting hours that visitors can come, or how long they can stay, but those are all things that HOAs try to control.
- gruez 2y ago>house color restrictions And have courts ruled that cities (or other governments) can't impose color restrictions? >yard sign restrictions, political activism restrictions Not sure what's meant by "political activism restrictions", but cities most definitely have restrictions on signs. You can't put a brightly flashing LED sign next to a busy intersection, or plant a billboard to make some money on the side. >and free association (visitor restrictions). ??? I've literally never encountered this, unless you count having to register to use the visitor parking.
- supplied_demand 2y ago==Not sure what's meant by "political activism restrictions"== Rules that literally say, "You cannot put up election-related signs." ==I've literally never encountered this, unless you count having to register to use the visitor parking.== Rules that say how many people you can have at your house, how long they can stay, etc., etc.
- jdeibele 2y agoI moved to a home that's part of a small (47 homes) HOA. Here, the visitor restrictions are aimed at commercial visitors. You're not supposed to run a business like a massage parlor or barbershop out of your home.
- nickff 2y agoCities restrict where businesses are allowed to operate all the time; this doesn’t seem to be a counter-example.
- consteval 2y agoCities also have to adhere to cottage laws - it's perfectly legal and protected to run a small business out of your home. Unless the HOA says no. This isn't a power the city has.
- kelnos 2y ago