4 ms·
How are HOAs any different than a city council, except on a smaller scale? In both cases they're democratically elected, and they enact restrictions that can't
by gruez 2y ago
How are HOAs any different than a city council, except on a smaller scale? In both cases they're democratically elected, and they enact restrictions that can't be opted out of.
- bluGill 2y agoHOAs often enacts rules that would be illegal for a city council to enact. (between the US constitution, US federal laws, State constitution, State laws, and county laws there are often strict limits to what can be done that HOAs are not effected by). Courts have reigned in some of that, but there is still a lot that a HOA can do. HOAs also tend to be too small - it is hard to find someone qualified who wants to be in charge and so they are often forced to accept some busybody nobody really likes because at least that person wants the job. As you get larger you get a choice of qualified people for the job (but of course also large enough for corruption to take effect).
- Loughla 2y agoMy sister just moved into a place that has an HOA. She's actively trying to get it suspended permanently. They live on a lake that attracts very aggressive Canadian geese. The geese do geese things like eat and poop lots of poop. The HOA fined them before they moved into the house for having goose poop in their back yard. For me, it's hilarious. I take handfuls of corn and stuff to throw around their backyard when I go visit. She has started a genuine campaign to have the HOA removed. She's so salty all the time now. It is top 10 things that has happened in my life.
- searealist 2y agoI don't want to live in a neighborhood where my neighbor's yards are full of poop. This is true even if the unit is unoccupied.
- AlexandrB 2y agoGoose poop is not very smelly since it's mostly fibre from their all-grass diet. It's not like a backyard full of dog poop. It's no worse than applying manure to fertilize the soil. Source: I've stepped in goose poop many, many times up here in Canada and it's the least bad poop to step in.
- AngryData 2y agoIf a deer walks through your yard and poops in it do you go out there and pick it up? Like these are wild animals, they aren't talking about a someone raising geese or something. Wild animals poop, it will quickly disintegrate into the soil. At worst you might run a lawn mower over it to spread it out better.
- searealist 2y agoYes. It's your responsibility to maintain your property if you choose to live in an HOA.
- kelnos 2y agoThe HOAification of America has gone too far. There are some places where it's hard to find a home not subject to a HOA. I don't think "well live somewhere else" is a reasonable answer to that complaint. That's definitely a "I got mine, so eff off" sort of response.
- searealist 2y agoWho wants to invest in a neighborhood that can be ruined by a few bad apples not maintaining their properties?
- iamevn 2y agoWhy would people need to invest in a neighborhood? Houses are for living in.
- gosub100 2y ago> The HOA fined them before they moved into the house for having goose poop in their back yard. It's not as dramatic as it sounds. the house was owned by _someone_ before they moved in. at _some_ point the guano was left and the HOA found it (whether that alleged violation cited done in a good-faith effort is irrelevant). The HOA applied their process, and at _some point_ ownership changed. Leaving your sister with the bill, which she is probably able to recover from the previous owners. HOA's are agreed to by the owners and they preserve the value of everyone's property and enforce common decency. (no trash, overgrown yards, RVs parked). I own a house under HOA and I get a letter or two per year about leaving the garage door open or the trash cans out too late. It's not a big deal and the neighborhood stays beautiful and desirable.
- sokoloff 2y agoHOAs’ most redeeming feature is they serve to coarsely segregate people who like to live under HOAs from people who don’t.
- kelnos 2y ago> Leaving your sister with the bill, which she is probably able to recover from the previous owners. That depends, really. If the unpaid HOA fine was disclosed during the buying process, and the buyer didn't make it a condition of sale that the seller had to cover it, then the buyer is responsible. If the seller didn't disclose it, then the buyer can of course sue the seller, but depending on the magnitude of the fine, it might be easier and less stressful to just pay it. > HOA's are agreed to by the owners and they preserve the value of everyone's property and enforce common decency. In theory, yes. In practice, many HOAs are full of busybodies who enjoy the power trip and love to meddle in how other people live their lives. Even in the absence of that, like any institution, the people who are a part of them and subject to them often disagree on the fine details. For example, I'm not convinced it's fair that an elected board of homeowners gets to decide things like what color the curtains on the inside of your windows facing the street are allowed to be. But many HOAs have restrictions on that. I suspect you might think that such a restriction is fine, but that's exactly the point I'm trying to make: people don't always agree, but everyone ends up being subject to whatever the board/majority decides. I don't think we should allow these mini-governments to be able to enact property restrictions that actual governments wouldn't be allowed to do. My latest fun letter from our HOA was that the paint on some air vents on our roof had faded and no longer matched the color of the roof, and we'd be fined if I didn't have them repainted. What a huge waste of time and money, both for me and for whatever busybody was paid (yes, paid) to drive around the neighborhood looking for these things. As an amusing aside: not long ago I read of a case where a homeowner had been parking his boat in his driveway for some very long time (like more than a decade), but suddenly the HOA decided to enforce a provision about that not being allowed. Boats had to be put behind some sort of opaque fence or partition, so they're not visible from the street. So he built the fence, parked his boat behind it, and had an artistic neighbor friend paint a mural... of his boat... on the outside of the fence. Loved that.
- mywittyname 2y agoMy HOA is worded such that it must exist for at least 30 years and there are no facilities to dissolving it before that time (after that time, a simple majority can vote to dissolve it, so long as the city agrees to incorporate the land and infrastructure). In this case, it's because the HOA is responsible for the loans taken out and long term leases to manage the sub division's infrastructure. And yes, geese love to poop everywhere.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> My HOA is worded such that it must exist for at least 30 years and there are no facilities to dissolving it before that time Technically, there are. Lack of an explicit termination clause doesn't mean an agreement can't be terminated. But the party that would object to that termination is the lender. If you had their sign off, you could dissolve the HOA today.
- kelnos 2y agoI was assuming that too. At the very least, the CC&Rs/by-laws could be amended to remove that clause. But, right, presumably the lender is a party to the agreements with enough power to vote down that change.
- kelnos 2y ago> I take handfuls of corn and stuff to throw around their backyard when I go visit. Wow, it's a wonder your sister hasn't stopped inviting you over.
- Loughla 2y agoI'm very handy, so she has me do things around the house. I don't charge for labor, because she's family and because her hatred for the HOA is only surpassed by her hatred for the geese so it's hilarious. Also I'm sneaky as all get out. I'm not sure she has figured it out yet.
- gruez 2y ago>HOAs often enacts rules that would be illegal for a city council to enact. (between the US constitution, US federal laws, State constitution, State laws, and county laws there are often strict limits to what can be done that HOAs are not effected by). Courts have reigned in some of that, but there is still a lot that a HOA can do. Can you give some examples that are applicable today? >HOAs also tend to be too small - it is hard to find someone qualified who wants to be in charge and so they are often forced to accept some busybody nobody really likes because at least that person wants the job. As you get larger you get a choice of qualified people for the job (but of course also large enough for corruption to take effect). This might vary on a state by state basis, but there are some pretty "cities" in some states. In Florida, there are plenty with population in the hundreds. In some cases it's due to it being rural, but there's plenty of cases where the city is simply small. For instance: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Briny_Breezes,_Florida https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Briny_Breezes,_Florida more: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_municipalities_in_Florida https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_municipalities_in_Flor...
- dghlsakjg 2y ago> Can you give some examples that are applicable today? HOAs are pretty famously restrictive of free speech (house color restrictions, yard sign restrictions, political activism restrictions), and free association (visitor restrictions). Their are some speech restrictions that governments apply to historic structures, but you would have a hard time as a government trying to register the name of every visitor to a residence, or restricting hours that visitors can come, or how long they can stay, but those are all things that HOAs try to control.
- gruez 2y ago>house color restrictions And have courts ruled that cities (or other governments) can't impose color restrictions? >yard sign restrictions, political activism restrictions Not sure what's meant by "political activism restrictions", but cities most definitely have restrictions on signs. You can't put a brightly flashing LED sign next to a busy intersection, or plant a billboard to make some money on the side. >and free association (visitor restrictions). ??? I've literally never encountered this, unless you count having to register to use the visitor parking.
- otterley 2y ago> between the US constitution, US federal laws, State constitution, State laws, and county laws there are often strict limits to what can be done that HOAs are not effected (sic) by HOAs cannot enforce rules that conflict with State or Federal law or the Constitution.
- sokoloff 2y agoAre you sure [in the context of GP's claim]? The Federal government could not pass a law prohibiting me from painting my front door purple (that would be an infringement on my 1A rights). As I understand it, an HOA can enforce such a prohibition as a private entity (and use the courts to back them, ultimately).
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> Federal government could not pass a law prohibiting me from painting my front door purple (that would be an infringement on my 1A rights) Uh, D.C. has plenty of aesthetic restrictions.
- ttyprintk 2y agoBackground: Washington, D.C. is not a state and in theory the US Congress performs state legislative practices for it. In practice, Congress has devolved civil policy to a mayor and devolved state court functions to a superior court. Purple door disputes wouldn’t be a Federal issue, but one of the D.C. superior court. The Feds have only intervened four times, and it was over much bigger features than HOAs. And the Supreme Court has actively closed loopholes where local issues relevant to any other state could become Federally interesting.
- dmd 2y agoBut they do, every day, because fighting is far more expensive than acceding.
- ttyprintk 2y ago
- colechristensen 2y agoHOAs go well beyond what any government is allowed to impose on you. They don’t have to follow the same rules a government does.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoformation or joining of HOAs are entirely voluntary. On the other hand, cities can unilaterally claim jurisdiction. If you were to draw a comparison, HOAs are far more consensual.
- psunavy03 2y agoThey're not really "voluntary" when the majority (if not all) of new construction uses them.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoit's still more voluntary than the city. An HOA can't claim a non HOA house. If you think avoiding an HOA is hard, do you really think it's easier to avoid a city government?
- DrillShopper 2y agoThe basis of HOAs is a history of racial covenants. While facially racial covenants are illegal, the enforcement of HOA restrictions is based in racism so the entire concept is rotten to the core.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoNonsense. Theological concepts of original sin don't apply to contract law. Just because there were racist HOAs in the 1950s or whatever doesn't mean a new HOA is tainted. You're not even trying to make a logical argument