4 ms·
>I can’t help but think those people don’t understand that $100k is very much the new $45k of the 2000s, and has much less purchasing power than the latter did
by gruez 2y ago
>I can’t help but think those people don’t understand that $100k is very much the new $45k of the 2000s, and has much less purchasing power than the latter did at the time.
False. $45k in 2005 is only $73k today, when adjusted for inflation[1]. Even if you use the most generous interpretation of "2000s" to mean 2000, that's only $82k.
[1] https://www.usinflationcalculator.com/ https://www.usinflationcalculator.com/
- dpkirchner 2y agoDoes that account for increased housing prices? It probably doesn't, because housing prices (cash price, per the fed) more than doubled since 2005: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/NYSTHPI https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/NYSTHPI
- gruez 2y ago>It probably doesn't, If you did a 30 second search, you'd see it's factored into the CPI, with "Shelter" (which further breaks down into rent and owners' equivalent rent) making up 36% of the CPI basket. https://www.bls.gov/news.release/cpi.t02.htm https://www.bls.gov/news.release/cpi.t02.htm
- dpkirchner 2y agoUnfortunately, your source is offline, so I couldn't see where it got its data.
- gruez 2y agoIt's very much up for me. In any case here's an archived version: https://web.archive.org/web/20241009171432/https://www.bls.gov/news.release/cpi.t02.htm https://web.archive.org/web/20241009171432/https://www.bls.g...
- dpkirchner 2y agoI meant the original source, the inflation calculator site. Anyway, thanks for the figures. House prices more than doubled but I guess other things must have become cheaper to compensate.
- gruez 2y agoHouse prices aren't part of the CPI, but housing (ie. rent and owners' equivalent rent) is. The former is an investment but the latter is the thing you actually consume.
- joncrocks 2y agoOne possible issue is that the largest component (27% out of 26%) is `OER`, which can be detached from reality. Unless owners are completely in the loop in terms of the rental market (which they likely are not, they don't rent), they may not come up with good estimates for what an equivalent rent would be.
- kayo_20211030 2y agoYes, it's in there. But also, IMO, oer is a dreadful metric. It's very laggy, and more opinionated that it ought to be. Rent is rent, but oer seems neither fish nor fowl. It's a wild survey guess that's off by 6 months.
- vundercind 2y agoAll of my bills say “bull shit”. I’m sure getting it that low means ignoring housing, and making everything in the “basket of goods” worse.
- gruez 2y ago>I’m sure getting it that low means ignoring housing No. https://www.bls.gov/cpi/factsheets/owners-equivalent-rent-and-rent.htm https://www.bls.gov/cpi/factsheets/owners-equivalent-rent-an... >and making everything in the “basket of goods” worse. Given that food, energy, and shelter makes up the bulk of the CPI, I'm not sure how this can be done. The most plausible thing I can think of is "food is less nutritious than before", but I doubt that's an actual factor. "Food is getting less nutritious so I'm forced to shop at whole foods" isn't exactly a popular sentiment.
- lotsofpulp 2y agoHow about medical appointments with nurses instead of doctors? I wonder if there is a similar measure for time kids spend in school. My kid comes home early every Wednesday, and there’s are ~15 other early dismissal days during the school year too. I would bet almost everything that relies heavily on labor has been increasing in price faster than official figures for the basket of all goods and services.
- apwell23 2y ago"Food" listed in there is not food at all. Thats some cheap filler that isn't really affected by inflation that much because of its just cheap garbage subsided by govt. Look at the junk in this section for exampe > Cereals and bakery products And ofcourse all the items in fruits and vegetables had the highest inflation.
- gruez 2y ago>Look at the junk in this section for exampe >> Cereals and bakery products >And ofcourse all the items in fruits and vegetables had the highest inflation. A simple check shows this is false. The "Cereals and bakery products" category went up by 28.6% since January 2020, compared to 17.9% for "Fruits and Vegetables". You get similar conclusions if you use compare against January 2005. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CUSR0000SAF111 https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CUSR0000SAF111 https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CUSR0000SAF113 https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CUSR0000SAF113
- lordgrenville 2y agoAnd median wage in NYC is $74k (according to Google). Sure, Manhattan is different, tech salaries are different, etc. I'm not claiming that these specific workers should/shouldn't be paid more, just that it's really tone-deaf to claim that you can't live on <$100k, when more than half of New Yorkers do.
- ziddoap 2y ago>when more than half of New Yorkers do I'm curious about what portion of those that are living on $74k or less are doing so solo, and how many are only able to do so by racking up debt / getting support from family / etc. I live in an area less expensive than NYC and, at least anecdotally in my circles, if you don't have a partner (or other assistance like roommates, parents, or something along those lines) it seems pretty damn rough to get by on ~70k.
- ebiester 2y agoYou have roommates. Or you live in less than 400 sq feet. Or you're in an older rent control.
- sashank_1509 2y agoI have a good job in the Bay Area, and I spend 4K a month. Of course if I were a family, there is no way I could support a wife in 4K a month but that is rare anyway. If she were working too, I could surely support a child in 6k a month. At this cost my life includes: 1. A Tesla Model 3, on which I spend 1k a month with insurance 2. 1.5k rent for a studio in a good safe location with utilities 3. Rest on groceries, eating out movies etc. If I decided to get a cheap car, I could easily have 600$ or more to spend on housing etc. So it would be tight but as a single 20s male, I would make it with 50k a year after taxes. Everything else just goes into savings. I think people have lavish tastes, or no control over their spending if they can’t make do with 70k a year after taxes.
- piltdownman 2y ago// 2. 1.5k rent for a studio in a good safe location with utilities I actually can't think of an EU Capital where that's achievable anymore, bar possibly the socialist outlier of Vienna. In Dublin a good studio is at least 2k, and you'll pay 52% tax on earnings over €70k as well...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- kayo_20211030 2y agoThere's more in play here than math. An interesting idea is the concept of a "Vibecession", coined by Kyla Scanlon. It's more a focus on how people "feel" about their situation than it is math. It's resonant to me. https://kyla.substack.com/p/the-vibecession-the-self-fulfilling https://kyla.substack.com/p/the-vibecession-the-self-fulfill...
- sodality2 2y agoDo you think people should be compensated more because they feel poorer, regardless of the actual costs of living...? As an avid Scanlon reader I personally think you're misrepresenting her position
- kayo_20211030 2y agoNope, I don't have a particular view on what would be adequate compensation, although I'm reflexively with labor. But it might get to the heart of why people do what they do. Why go on strike when the math says you're being payed above average on a nationwide basis? People are funny that way. Very few are calculators, they're just people.
- sodality2 2y agoI reckon people want to be paid as much as they can bargain for, regardless of their relative income level. Besides, it's not just about pay, it's often about working conditions.
- kayo_20211030 2y agoYes, and double yes. How these people view (feel about) their working conditions is more important to them than any explanation of why they ought to, or ought not to, feel that way based on some measure of comparative economics or conditions. If they want, for whatever reason (either allergy or solidarity), a scent-free cleaning product and they're willing to strike for it; well, why not? It's a political negotiation, a bargaining. That's sensible to me. Everything is people and politics. It might be justified by math, but it's not driven by it.
- consteval 2y agoThis doesn't account for the fact that cost of living doesn't rise at the same rate everywhere. You can't just use national statistics for this. It's entirely possible that in NYC the cost of living went up more than 2x since the 2000s.
- marinmania 2y agofwiw the housing price index in New York has actually seen lower increase since 2000 than the rest of the country https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/NYXRSA https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/NYXRSA https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CSUSHPINSA https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CSUSHPINSA The same is also true if you use 2005 or 2009 as your start date. I agree there is variance in theory, but in practice it has been about the same as the national.
- whywhywhywhy 2y agoIt's remote work though, why would they live in NYC.
- cbhl 2y agoThe more I stare at this the more I think that using official inflation numbers / using the official CPI is wrong -- these baskets combine recreation and technology being nearly -50% (TVs can be had today for $300, whereas they used to cost $500 in 1995 dollars), assume you only buy new cars (only up ~25% since 2000, but used cars are now almost as expensive as new whereas they used to be available for half the price or less), and underweight housing (basically doubled since 2000, worse if you need to move to a HCOL major urban center for employment). If you are a healthy person living frugally then I think the inflation in your personal basket of goods is actually higher than the fed numbers would dictate (esp for rent and housing).
- smachiz 2y agothat's a pretty localized in time issue re: used cars. There's still covid supply issues being felt in the downstream used market as a result of underproduction for 2+ years. https://comptroller.nyc.gov/reports/spotlight-new-york-citys-rental-housing-market/ https://comptroller.nyc.gov/reports/spotlight-new-york-citys...
- gruez 2y ago>these baskets combine recreation and technology being nearly -50% (TVs can be had today for $300, whereas they used to cost $500 in 1995 dollars), The entire "Recreation commodities" category (which includes other stuff like "Sporting goods" and "Pets and pet products") is only weighed at 2%, compared to 13% for food and 37% for shelter. Even if it's down 50% the impact on the overall CPI is negligible. >assume you only buy new cars (only up ~25% since 2000, but used cars are now almost as expensive as new whereas they used to be available for half the price or less), ??? There's clearly a "Used cars and trucks" category. >and underweight housing (basically doubled since 2000, worse if you need to move to a HCOL major urban center for employment). The index is called "Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers", not "Consumer Price Index for Young Urban Professionals". Not everyone is a recent graduate who recently moved into a high COL city and paying for a market rate apartment. For every person fitting that criteria, there's probably also a retiree who owns their house and/or lives in a rent controlled apartment.
- 2y ago
- baron816 2y agoThe thing you always need to keep in mind about CPI is that it’s a weighted average for the ENTIRE COUNTRY. Like, retirees in Florida who own their own homes have a very different relationship with prices than young renters in NYC. It really only makes sense to use CPI and other inflation figures when you’re talking about the whole country.
- game_the0ry 2y agoThat's assuming that headline inflation numbers from the government are an accurate representation of reality. But they're not.
- macinjosh 2y agoNo one cares that they can buy a 4k TV for $400. We want healthy food that we can regularly afford. That costs $400 a week for a family. These government indexes are incredibly warped.
- Kerrick 2y agoIf you assume a family of four with both children aged 9-11 and the parents a male and a female aged 19-50, the USDA says [0] it costs only $250.10 with a low-cost plan, $314.90 with a moderate-cost plan and $380 with a liberal plan. All three of these plans each support "a healthy diet through nutritious meals and snacks at home" [1] and would cover everything -- no restaurant budget required. [0]: https://www.fns.usda.gov/cnpp/usda-food-plans-cost-food-monthly-reports https://www.fns.usda.gov/cnpp/usda-food-plans-cost-food-mont... [1]: https://www.fns.usda.gov/cnpp/low-moderate-liberal-food-plans-2007 https://www.fns.usda.gov/cnpp/low-moderate-liberal-food-plan...
- JohnMakin 2y agomeasures of core inflation that sites like this use leave out many things that massively impact purchasing power - namely food, fuel, and interest rates. When factoring these in, the gp comment is quite reasonable, as those costs have soared in the last 20 years for the typical household.
- gruez 2y ago>measures of core inflation that sites like this use leave out many things that massively impact purchasing power - namely food, fuel, Those are literally part of the CPI. >interest rates The "C" in "CPI" stands for consumer. Unless you're taking out loans to buy your groceries, interest rates shouldn't be a factor on your expenditures.
- carlosjobim 2y ago"Official" inflation numbers are fraudulent and have always been. Real life situations is what matters, because we're dealing with real people. The Soviet Union "officially" had the highest production of food per capita in the world, yet they had to import food. Because you cannot eat government statistics.
- stego-tech 2y agoI had a feeling someone would dredge up a basic calculator and make this argument. The problem with your retort is it ignores the very context I outlined above. The present rate of inflation appears more manageable, but because most of it is driven by absurd inflation in shelter and transport costs (homes and cars), those two areas are starkly higher than inflation overall - as much as 50% or more, in some metros. So while your napkin math makes for a good soundbite, the reality is that it just hides the complex truth of inflation. So yes, while $45k might be inflation-equivalent to $73k today, that purchasing power is significantly different. $43k in the 2000s could buy you a starter home in most states, albeit not in most metros; nowadays, $73k can’t even cover basic necessities in many states and all metros, not without significant sacrifices. So my point still stands.