6 ms·
Someone needs to develop an algorithm or mechanism that allows someone to record their own voice without recording anyone else's speech. Most video recording do
by stcredzero 14y ago
Someone needs to develop an algorithm or mechanism that allows someone to record their own voice without recording anyone else's speech. Most video recording doesn't run afoul of the law, unless there is a soundtrack. However, recording yourself is okay in most jurisdictions.
- michaelfeathers 14y agoThat is an important point. The law varies across states. Some states are two-party consent states for audio, and some are single party. Courts seem to be allowing exceptions for recording where there is no anticipation of privacy but, if I remember correctly, stealth recording can tip back towards illegality in some places.
- darkarmani 14y agoConsent is usually for phone calls and amounts to notification (hang up if you don't consent). In public states like MA recording in public is mostly about awareness and not consent. If you have a giant camera recording things they won't succeed in prosecuting you for secretly taping audio.
- einhverfr 14y agoAttention officer: If you do not consent to be recorded, please don't stop me. Thank you and have a nice day ;-)
- darkarmani 14y agoWhich is why people are allowed to tape auto of officers with large video cameras -- the press for example.
- einhverfr 14y agoAgain, my suggestion of a bumper sticker. Given the realities of traffic stops, I think it is entirely to be expected that police will read bumper stickers when running plates etc. It gives fair notice. Every officer will read it. And one can verify at the beginning of the conversation.
- stcredzero 14y agoIf it doesn't already, the ACLU app should use GPS data to disable the soundtrack by jurisdiction.
- bigiain 14y agoMaybe just selectively encrypt the audio? Perhaps, if it'd work better legally, some system that encrypts the audio on the fly, with a public half of a keypair where the private key is held by an organisation who never gets the encrypted file, and who will only turn the key over to a lawyer or court? (It'd be nice to think you could set this up so the only way law enforcement can get it without the consent of the uploader would be to have the decryption key made public, so if the cops want it, _everybody_ gets to hear it) Where I am (Sydney, Australia), recording a police interaction is legal, but showing/playing it to other people may not be. You can't tender your recording as evidence in court without the consent of all the people in the recording, but you _can_ use the recording in court if it contradicts sworn evidence given by someone you've recorded.
- stcredzero 14y ago> Maybe just selectively encrypt the audio? The problem with that, is that you've still effectively recorded other people. That's okay in Australia, but not everywhere. Deliberately not recording has a strong legal basis just about everywhere, though. Think of the example of an active microphone hooked up to an analog tape recorder on "pause." In that case, the signal exists in hardware, and is in fact being amplified. There would be no violation of the law, however. Now think of the same setup with a digital recorder that is on pause. There may be a DSP chip that is processing the input signal, but there is effectively no "recording" going on.
- Alex3917 14y agoEither way, the penalties for illegally recording someone are a lot less than the penalties you'd get for the cops planting a kilo of heroin on you.
- SwellJoe 14y agoSeveral courts have found that recording police, including audio, is legal because a public employee doing their job in a public location has no reasonable expectation of privacy. The privacy argument has been used in several jurisdictions and they've consistently lost the cases. I don't know if that will apply everywhere, but the ACLU is of the opinion that recording police when they are making arrests is always legal and always ethical, and they've put their money where their mouth is by becoming involved in several of those cases. I'm not knowledgeable enough to know if it's always true, but I know where I stand on the ethics of the thing: it's always right to record a police officer making an arrest, and it's always wrong for a police officer to harass, assault, arrest, or threaten someone who is merely recording an arrest. Hopefully the law agrees with that, because any police officer doing his job ethically should have no fear of the public seeing him doing that job.
- ddt 14y agoYou're spot on. It all comes down to a reasonable expectation of privacy. If you're in public, interacting with other people in the public, you waive your right to not have pictures taken of you. I don't know a place in the US that this doesn't hold.
- stcredzero 14y agoIt's not the pictures part that's tricky. When you include audio, a whole other set of laws comes into play.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- einhverfr 14y agoThe interesting questions will come up regarding people who claim to have much more power, like TSA agents.