6 ms·
Several comments in this thread relate to Pistorius' prosthetics and whether they give him an unfair advantage. The Court of Arbitration for Sport have ruled t
by jdietrich 14y ago
Several comments in this thread relate to Pistorius' prosthetics and whether they give him an unfair advantage.
The Court of Arbitration for Sport have ruled that there is no evidence that his prosthetics constitute an unfair advantage over his preferred 400m distance. The initial IAAF testing showed that he used less energy at full speed, but this is not relevant to sprinting performance, which demands maximum power output. All below-knee amputees are at a significant disadvantage during the start and initial acceleration of the race, which is vital in sprinting.
Personally, I think the most obvious evidence that these prosthetics do not constitute an advantage is the times of other athletes using identical limbs. Pistorius is whole seconds faster than his nearest rivals. If the limbs constitute a meaningful advantage, then why is Pistorius so uniquely quick?
- luser001 14y agodavidjohnson below posted this excellent link which talks about the shenanigans^Wcheating that happened during arbitration. http://www.sportsscientists.com/2011/12/science-of-sport-awards-controversy-of.html http://www.sportsscientists.com/2011/12/science-of-sport-awa... And see the top comment for a good explanation (imho) for why you are wrong about the initial acceleration phase being important for 400m.
- MSM 14y ago> I think the most obvious evidence that these prosthetics do not constitute an advantage is the times of other athletes using identical limbs. Pistorius is whole seconds faster than his nearest rivals. If the limbs constitute a meaningful advantage, then why is Pistorius so uniquely quick? You're mixing apples and oranges here. In the highest most competitive horse races, it's not uncommon to still see horses that win by large margins. Having a horse win without advantage against other horses is not a good reason to start having humans race against horses.
- gaius 14y agoOr isn't it? http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/wales/mid/3801177.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/wales/mid/3801177.stm
- yuliyp 14y agoThe size of the population from which the top race horses are drawn is orders of magnitude smaller than the size of the set of human track athletes. Thus in the Olympics, you're looking at specimens a few standard deviations above the mean, instead of only 1 or 2 in horse races, which means the very top ones are going to be significantly better than the rest of the competition.
- MSM 14y agoVery true, but that actually validates my point- how many amputees actively strive to participate in the paralympics? I would estimate that pool is smaller than all the horses being raced, meaning his accomplishment of beating other racers is even less significant.
- eggbrain 14y agoWhile his current prosthetic might not give him a great competitive advantage, doesn't it seem like a slippery slope? 12 years from now, lets say there is a breakthrough in prosthetic technology, one that gets rid of all the disadvantages, and improves the advantages -- do we let those in, or do we say "No, you can only use prosthetics from x years ago?"
- brodney 14y agoDidn't they ban the swim suits from the last olympics because of the advantages they conferred? I think they can evaluate the advances in technologies on a case by case basis and decide. His current setup offers no apparent one for his race, thus he should be allowed to compete.
- ahelwer 14y agoExactly. Same goes with banned substances. Caffeine, for instance, is not banned despite giving a very minor advantage (or so the nutritionist told us when I used to speed skate competitively). A group of people educated on the subject decide where to draw the line.
- eggbrain 14y agoI think it would be much harder to determine whether a prosthetic was "fair" though. With the swimsuits, you could test two different swimsuits on the same swimmer and see if one offered a direct advantage. Not to mention, when people that have not broken world records before start breaking world records, all of them using the same suit, it becomes pretty obvious. With prosthetics, however, how do you compare how they run with prosthetics to how they might have ran if they had legs? If they don't break world records, but they place 2nd when they might have placed 5th with legs, how will we be able to know that?
- brodney 14y agoI imagine they can use the same process from the wiki article where they studied the mechanical efficiency of Pistorius's running form and compared to other runners. They'd need to broaden the study to include turns and starts, and possibly more. That should show whether prosthetic runners have a net advantage.
- gaius 14y agoI've seen guys like him when I run half-marathons. Damn, they're fast. It really challenges the notion of disabled; they're effectively actually superhuman. The less energy at cruising speed is obviously a bigger advantage over longer distances.
- jbooth 14y agoRunning a 400m is much more about anaerobic endurance than it is about raw speed, even at the olympic level. 40-100m are speed, 400-800m are anaerobic, then the mile and up are aerobic endurance. There's some gray in there but go run a 400 if you don't believe me that the race is dominated by endurance.
- ivoflipse 14y agoHow convenient for Oscar then that his both calf muscles are made out of carbon and don't fatigue. On top of that his low leg is significantly lighter than non-amputees, though whether this is a curse or a blessing is arguable. Oscars main 'advantage' over fellow amputees that he grew up wearing prosthetics and had the funds to get ones that are good enough to train on. I can't imagine a Jamaican bilateral amputee being in the same situation. The problem is that at the moment he's a one of a kind, which makes comparisons pretty much useless. Regardless of it all, his achievements are impressive and he's an example for a lot amputees. Edit: Here's a link to a literature review I wrote about him 4 years ago. Note that it may be a draft version! https://docs.google.com/open?id=0B1W3cjBV_DpNajQyUWVJdEtwYkk https://docs.google.com/open?id=0B1W3cjBV_DpNajQyUWVJdEtwYkk
- mayneack 14y agoCitation?