9 ms·
"The present discounted value of the promises embedded in the Social Security law greatly exceeds the present discounted value of the expected proceeds from the
by tokenadult 18y ago
"The present discounted value of the promises embedded in the Social Security law greatly exceeds the present discounted value of the expected proceeds from the payroll tax. The difference is an unfunded liability variously estimated at from $4 trillion to $11 trillion--or from slightly larger than the funded federal debt that is in the hands of the public to three times as large."
The mismatch between the promised benefits that many voters think they have "earned" by "saving" money in their personal "Social Security accounts" and the actual funding capacity of the Social Security system is why it looks like Mr. Ponzi was the designer of the system. The overall societal effect of Social Security as it is currently funded is a massive wealth transfer from the working young to the nonworking old, which is excellent politics but rather poor economics.
- mattmaroon 18y agoEven if it wasn't for the anomalous population boom that is causing the problem, you would essentially be being forced by the government to put a portion of your salary into an investment with a 0% interest rate. Which granted, would look good to a lot of people right now, but is bad financial planning on the whole. On the other hand, I reject his cries of paternalism for the simple reason that other people's poverty has a negative effect on my life, liberty, and pursuit of happiness. Poor people have incredibly high rates of criminal activity, drug use, etc. Granted, I don't see a lot of retirees selling crack or robbing banks, but the effect it could have on their families, who sometimes they support or sometimes support them, could create a serious ripple down through generations. Which doesn't necessarily mean I'm for Social Security or forced savings of any kind, but the issue is not nearly so simple as paternalism.
- Retric 18y agoIn defense of social security: It pays significant disability and survives benefits which has little to do with investing and everything to do with insurance. So consider SS as insurance in case of a long life. Some people will live well over 100 so finding the "correct" amount of money to save is overkill for most people who die far younger than that. If you invested a portion of your savings each year and pooled you money with 10,000 other people your age then paid dividends from that to the survivors you could save less money and still not worry about running out. Granted if to many people lived until retirement age you might need to reduce benefits. Granted you would not be able to give people money at the time of your death but if your single what's the point? Now the implementation of social security is broken in several ways but minor changes in retirement age will fix the "benefit gap" long before it runs out of money. The basic problem is people are living longer so they need to increase average retirement age. The surplus was also invested in government bonds with terrible long term returns etc, but when you consider how much more important the first 20k/year is over the next you might consider guaranteed benefits even at high cost are worth a lot more than the simple math would suggest. PS: There are a lot of things I hate about SS, but it's not really a Ponzi scheme.
- tptacek 18y agoThis was one of the intellectual flaws of the Bush privatization scheme; they calibrated returns from individual private accounts to the average lifespan, without noting that a pretty large contingent of social security beneficiaries would outlive the average. Current estimates are that many of us will be long retired before there even is a "gap" between Social Security funding and Social Security benefits. The trust fund, for instance, doesn't run out until the 2040's.
- mmmurf 18y agoThe privatization plan would give the beneficiary ownership over the investment, so there is not a problem, it just means that the investment has longer to grow. Ideally someone doesn't just build up a pile of money and intend to die with $0, he/she intends to leave some to the next generation or to charity.
- Retric 18y agoI am single why should I give my money to charity, my will is going to say take it out into the forest and burn it. Only slightly kidding. A close friend of mine had a trust fund worth a little over 6 million and was looking to inherent a lot more when his grandmother died. He is dead now and imo money really messed up his life.
- mattmcknight 18y agoThe trust fund doesn't exist. It's a line on the books, but it's been borrowed fund to pay for other expenses.
- tptacek 18y agoSo, when do you think the government is going to default on its own bonds? 2010? 2018?
- mattmaroon 18y agoThe life insurance aspect of SS is always overlooked in discussions on its impending collapse. I would guess that it's just not a significant factor. The yearly Social Security/Medicare payments for the average American is something like $7,500. Term Life would be what, $600? I'm not sure what you meant after that. Actuarial tables take life spans into account. And people are not living longer, see my original comment. That's a myth, and not the problem at all.
- alecco 18y agoThe current group on the receiving end did pay. Noam Chomsky wrote a great essay on this non-issue: http://www.chomsky.info/articles/20050601.htm http://www.chomsky.info/articles/20050601.htm (Hey, the guy's from MIT, don't down-vote me that much, please! ;)
- nihilocrat 18y agoChomsky is a pretty hardline radical liberal, so it's fairly likely that an HN reader or two thinks what he writes is pure and utter garbage.
- tptacek 18y agoHow do you at one point in a thread discuss how "liberal" is an ad hominem, and in another part of the thread dismiss someone as a "hardline radical liberal"?
- nihilocrat 18y agoBecause I'm not using "liberal" as an insult. I can't tell where you see an ad hominem, I'm "dismissing" Chomsky because he has a long track record plus popular image of being a radical liberal, which was the focus of my reply. I think you are assigning too much tone to a text-based discussion. The use of "liberal" in the other thread was referring to "classical liberal". I was mainly trying to point out how the definitions that are popularly used these days should be preferred over definitions of "liberal" that might have been accurate two hundred years ago when the original "classical liberals" were contemporary.
- alecco 18y agoThat's OK. But why do you down-vote what you don't agree with?
- nihilocrat 18y agoHow do you know I down-voted anything? I actually haven't down-voted anything attached to this story. I will downvote something I don't agree with if I think it's not well-reasoned, or too knee-jerky, or otherwise just dilutes the discussion.