5 ms·
Ironically I see this the day after I've decided to quit Stack Overflow due to interacting with moderators. For the last few months I've been in the habit of s
by btilly 14y ago
Ironically I see this the day after I've decided to quit Stack Overflow due to interacting with moderators.
For the last few months I've been in the habit of searching for algorithm questions, and answering them for fun. And then http://stackoverflow.com/questions/11314077/algorithm-for-exclusion-of-numbers/11317787 http://stackoverflow.com/questions/11314077/algorithm-for-ex... came along. It was the most fun algorithm question that I had seen in the last week. I put a fair amount of effort into rewriting a response I learned a nice trick from into a response that programmers with no theoretical background should be able to understand. But 4 moderators decided that it should be closed despite multiple votes, stars, and so on.
I then asked at http://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/138678/can-we-please-reopen-this-programming-question http://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/138678/can-we-please... and the immediate response was that I got downvoted into oblivion, the question got deleted by clearly senior members of the community (it since has become undeleted, but there is no question what the "wise elders" think should have happened), and I got a lesson in what they really do and do not want to see on their site.
I understand what they are aiming for, and clearly what I find fun is simply not a fit for what they want on their site. The site that they'd like me to go to instead is http://http://cs.stackexchange.com/ http://http://cs.stackexchange.com/. I looked. It is practically dead in comparison. What little does appear there seems strongly geared towards computer science students. Given that I'm self-taught in CS, I doubt I'll stay there.
So, goodbye Stack Overflow. I wonder how many other people you don't see there any more.
- codinghorror 14y agoLooks like the community decided to re-open it. I agree it's on-topic, actually, since it is about algorithms and got good answers.
- btilly 14y agoWhat community reopened it? It did not get reopened until after I posted here, and people came from here to reopen it. The discussion on meta, and comments here from people who are clearly actively involved in site moderation on stack overflow, shows overwhelming agreement that it does not belong there. I would be willing to bet money that your opinion that it is on topic would come as a surprise to them. I would also be willing to bet money that if the question and answers came back to the attention of the majority of people on meta, it would immediately be closed and deleted again. If you think that this is a problem, perhaps you should say something publicly. Because it doesn't seem to be an isolated or even particularly unusual occurrence, and it is costing you contributers.
- runn1ng 14y agoI don't see your problem. They are trying to put specific questions to specific stackexchange subsites. So, there is http://programmers.stackexchange.com http://programmers.stackexchange.com for conceptual questions , http://cs.stackexchange.com/ http://cs.stackexchange.com/ for "easy" computer science and http://cstheory.stackexchange.com/ http://cstheory.stackexchange.com/ for "hard" computer science. I don't see the problem in trying to split the horde of questions into more subsites.
- nopassrecover 14y agoBut why not achieve that filtering in app? After all I'm not interested in Android development or Cocoa questions but they still appear in the feed - I simply learn to ignore them or add filters. Could this not support these questions as well? Clearly the question and answer was useful to someone, code related, interesting to others (upvotes), so excluding it only serves to discourage great contributors, with the proposed solution being division of the audience.
- btilly 14y agoThe problem is that people who are actually going to ask questions that I find interesting don't know or care how the powers that be have decided to organize things - they just head to the site that is most popular. Which would be stack overflow. So I'm left with a choice. I can not see those questions. I can answer those questions on a site where I know that is not wanted. I can become one of the people trying to moderate the site into the structure they want despite knowing how frustrating that can be for the people affected. None of those options is palatable to me, so I'll find other ways to amuse myself. Look through my answers at http://stackoverflow.com/users/585411/btilly?tab=answers http://stackoverflow.com/users/585411/btilly?tab=answers and tell me whether the loss of contributers like me is good or bad to the whole stack exchange enterprise. If you think it is neutral to good, then our value systems are so different that there is no real point in continuing the conversation.
- ufo 14y agoIt's not the first time I have seen this SO deletionism discussion come up but this is the first time I recognized the guy that is giving up. Puts the whole thing in a new light. :(
- mhp 14y agoIt sounds like you are upset that you put a lot of effort into solving the problem, and also that the question got closed. I can understand how that could be frustrating, but your answer is still there and can still be voted on (only new answers aren't allowed). And to be honest, the question is definitely without a doubt, not on topic to SO. I'm sorry you came away with a bad experience, but just because a questions is closed doesn't mean SO is saying something mean to you personally.
- btilly 14y agoThe problem is there at the moment. But for several hours yesterday it was deleted. It is clear that for people who are senior in the stack overflow community, like Oded, think that deletion is what should have happened. What was intended is one thing. What resulted is that I got the message that effort put out by me, that I thought was appreciated due to upvotes, is not what is actually desired there. So why bother?
- mhp 14y agoI don't think you should let an isolated incident speak for the community as a whole. But your point still stands and it's been repeated often... You felt personally insulted by a moderation action by the community due to the way it was handled. I think most people have been in that situation (I am still upset that the 'programming on a boat' question is gone). My only consolation is that we recognize this is a problem and it is one that almost all online communities face, and we're working on ways to alleviate it. I hope you'll stick around and help us figure out how to do that.
- nathan_long 14y ago>> it is one that almost all online communities face I'd strike "almost" and "online" from this sentence. Being part of community always means compromise. Only hermits win all their arguments. But most of us have decided that the benefits of community outweigh the cost.
- btilly 14y ago
- AGorilla 14y agoThe real irony is that the Meta question was deleted instead of being answered. It just seems like there are so many people with vote-to-close permissions that it's statistically likely that some 4 of them will have a nit to pick with any question you ask.
- cooldeal 14y agoThis is a problem in community sites that want to keep their focus. For example, politics stories are not welcome on HN, even if people here want to discuss it. Why? Because, in any place that people congregate, they like to talk about unrelated. Unfortunately, if you don't do the tree trimming, the site will degenrate into something else. For example, see how Reddit is almost a completely different site from five years ago(and not in a good way to me) and there is almost no way to fix it after the fact. So while you have my sympathies that you were collateral damage, I can definitely understand why the moderators did what they did.