4 ms·
It's not really a Ponzi scheme. A Ponzi scheme pays interest to attract investors so it needs significantly more customers with each iteration. Madoff's infamou
by mattmaroon 18y ago
It's not really a Ponzi scheme. A Ponzi scheme pays interest to attract investors so it needs significantly more customers with each iteration. Madoff's infamous one paid out 12% annually, so it needed to grow by 12% each year just to achieve stasis (or it would have if cash outs equaled profits anyway, some years it was probably more or less).
Social Security isn't a Ponzi scheme because it would work perfectly well if the population remained stable over time, or shrank. And it would even be alright if it grew slowly and linearly.
What really throws a wrench in the cogs is when the generation retiring is much larger than the ones still working, especially the one or two before it. This is why the Baby Boomers leaving the work force is so problematic.
The good news (in a sick sort of way) is that our diet and health care are so bad that we save a little due to lifespans actually shrinking. People mistakenly attribute the problem to longer lifespans, but the expectancy of a working-age adult (the only group that matters for the purposes of entitlements) has barely budged since before Social Security was invented, and is now quite possibly shrinking. Lifespan from birth (as it is typically expressed) has risen almost entirely due to lower infant mortality.
- chaostheory 18y agothe main problem with Social Security isn't really changes in population size (though it still is a problem). The core problem of Social Security is this: "Taxes paid by today’s workers are used to pay today’s retirees. If money is left over, it finances other government spending—though, to maintain the insurance fiction, paper entries are created in a “trust fund” that is simultaneously an asset and a liability of the government. When the benefits that are due exceed the proceeds from payroll taxes, as they will in the not very distant future, the difference will have to be financed by raising taxes, borrowing, creating money, or reducing other government spending." Basically politicians (of both parties) raid the Social Security fund and just leave IOU notes behind to fund their pork projects. If the money was untouchable and only used for Social Security, the problems we'd see with just population changes wouldn't be nearly as bad... hence (I could be wrong but I feel) this is one of the core arguments that Social Security is a Ponzi scheme.
- mattmaroon 18y agoNo, that is entirely incorrect. The government borrowing from SS is no different than them borrowing from the Chinese, either way it has to be repaid. At least this way the interest is going to Americans. Government borrowing itself may be a problem, but it's an entirely separate one. The kicker is the first sentence. Today's workers pay today's retirees. The payments are designed to ensure a consistent, inflation adjusted standard of living for retirees. If the ratio of retirees to workers stayed the same, the payments would. But when there fewer retirees per worker, workers pay less, and when there are more, they pay more. It's the system's fatal flaw. The problem now is that baby boomers paid much lower Social Security taxes than us, but they still need to receive the same standard of living that we will. You can see the historical rates here: http://www.taxpolicycenter.org/taxfacts/Content/PDF/ssrate_historical.pdf http://www.taxpolicycenter.org/taxfacts/Content/PDF/ssrate_h... They paid a lower % with a much lower cap, even adjusted for inflation. They did so because the retiree to worker ratio was lower. If they paid the same percentage and cap that we do now, Social Security would be sitting on enough money to cover the shortfall in the future. In 20 years, that ratio will be much higher than today, meaning the workers of 2018 would have to pay far higher taxes still for the system to fund itself. This would, of course, be unbearable (it's already close) so the government will have to seek other solutions, such as borrowing money or printing.
- byrneseyeview 18y agoThe government borrowing from SS is no different than them borrowing from the Chinese, either way it has to be repaid. I'd like to offer you an annuity. Here's how it works: you give me about 15% of your paycheck every year, and I spend the money on whatever I feel like. I replace it with a piece of paper that says "Dear Byrneseyeview: Please tender to the bearer -- Byrneseyeview -- an amount equal to the sum borrowed)." See how this 100% foolproof scheme might break down?
- mattmaroon 18y agoHere's 2 scenarios. a) Government borrows $4 trillion from the Chinese at 2% annually. b) Government borrows $4 trillion from Americans, by way of Social Security, at 2% annually. What's the difference in what the government owes after 10 years? Either way the government has to raise $4 trillion (plus interest) in taxes, borrow it, or print it to pay it off. Either way everyone is in the exact same boat, except in boat b, Americans get the interest. In boat a the Chinese do. (Unless you count borrowing from the Chinese, leaving the Social Security money in a CD, and defaulting to on the borrowed money while paying out SS an option, which it isn't.) I wasn't suggesting that government borrowing is not a problem. It is. They probably should just not borrow the $4 trillion from anywhere. But that's just a different issue that has nothing to do with Social Security, as many economists have pointed out.
- euccastro 18y ago[Social Security] would work perfectly well if the population remained stable over time, or shrank. And it would even be alright if it grew slowly and linearly. You got it right but say it backwards. The problem is population shrinking. The generation retiring is much larger than the ones still working when population has shrunk at some point. Baby Boom wouldn't be a problem in this respect, had it been followed by Baby Big Bang.
- mattmaroon 18y agoYou're right, I meant the ratio of retirees to workers, not the overall population. Thanks.
- sethg 18y agoBut long-term population shrinkage can be accommodated by raising the Social Security tax (an fund-raising option that was not available to Ponzi or Madoff). As long as the generation-to-generation increase in worker productivity is greater than the generation-to-generation increase in the tax, it won't harm the general welfare. And if that doesn't do the trick then the US can always let in more working-age immigrants.
- mattchew 18y agoSocial Security isn't a Ponzi scheme because it would work perfectly well if the population remained stable over time, or shrank. And it would even be alright if it grew slowly and linearly. Only if benefits match contributions. If benefits exceed contributions, you do have a Ponzi scheme, and you have to find ways to funnel increasing amounts of money into the system. Social Security taxes, as a percentage of income, have risen continuously since the program was started, well before the baby boomers started retiring: http://www.ssa.gov/history/pdf/t2a3.pdf http://www.ssa.gov/history/pdf/t2a3.pdf
- tptacek 18y agoAgain: that's not what the words "ponzi scheme" means. You could be arguing that "if benefits exceed contributions, you have a budget deficit", but that wouldn't be as emotionally manipulative, and it would also be boring. Social Security taxes as a percentage of income were raised sharply in the '80s precisely because the baby boomers hadn't retired.
- mmmurf 18y agoWell, you forgot about the way that benefits are systematically reduced and the retirement age is systematically increased. What about someone who worked hard in his 20s, 30s, 40s, 50s in hopes of retiring at 65 only to see the SS age be increased to 70? Is that security? No, that's a 5 year ripoff. Now, the SS retirement age is GREATER THAN the average lifespan of African American citizens! You may consider that another "good in a sick sort of way" aspect of the program, but I don't.
- pg 18y agobut the expectancy of a working-age adult ... has barely budged since before Social Security was invented. Lifespan from birth ... has risen almost entirely due to lower infant mortality. This is not true. While it's true that infant mortality rates in industrialized countries have decreased a lot since the 1930s, so have mortality rates at every age.