14 ms·
StackOverflow Man Remakes Net One Answer at a TIme
- cadab 14y agoCurrently -" 2 million registered users and averages 5,000 new questions per day and 10,000 new answers per day" 2008 - "By the end of 2008 users were posting 100,000 answers per day" I find that hard to believe? Surely it'd be more like the other way round? Or has it really dropped off 4 years on?
- Zikes 14y agoThat may be due to duplicate questions, which are typically shut down before anyone has a chance to answer.
- yen223 14y agoCould simply be that most questions have already be answered.
- klint 14y agoSorry, this is an error. It should have been 100,000 per month by the end of 2008 and 10,000 per day currently (so around 300,000 a month).
- balakk 14y agoWhat a lousy headline. And the article is almost content-free.
- nakkiel 14y agoClearly a paid-for article. Jeff is onto something these days and needs some press. Regarding the down-votes: it's the second time in a week that Jeff publishes something free of any interesting content and makes it big enough to reach a large audience while mentioning each time that he's onto something but can't say anything about it. If that's not a PR exercise, please tell me what it is.
- mhp 14y agoI can confirm that SE Inc. definitely did not pay for this article (or blog post). They called us for some facts, but that was the extent of our involvement as far as I know. I also agree that it seems about two years late and not filled with any new information.
- nathan_long 14y agoPR exercise, maybe. "paid-for" is an accusation you can't back up and shouldn't make.
- nakkiel 14y agoYou're right, it's just my opinion based on the tone of the article and what I perceive of Wired. I'd change the wording to reflect that if I could edit the post. Also, this was not really meant as an accusation in the sense that I make no value judgement on Jeff based on what he did or did not pay for the article (but I hear I'm strangely wired (yeah, hum) when it comes to translating my opinions into judgements; YMMV so, you've got another point there because I should be more cautious).
- klint 14y agoI can also confirm that neither StackExchange nor Jeff Atwood paid for this post. I met Jeff Atwood while I was in San Francisco last month and thought he had a good story that hadn't gotten much mainstream press (for example, StackExchange was covered by the New York Times, [http://www.nytimes.com/2011/02/07/technology/07question.html?pagewanted=all http://www.nytimes.com/2011/02/07/technology/07question.html...] but that story didn't go into the origins of the company or Atwood's "secret agenda" of tricking developers into being better communicators). The story wasn't assigned, I pitched it to Wired because I had the opportunity to interview Atwood. I think of Atwood were to pay for press (which I very much doubt he would do) I assume he'd do so when he actually had something to announce.
- zitterbewegung 14y agoThe mere idea of creating the site was revolutionary. The platform and the concept of creating a site where you house questions and FOCUS on the quality of questions is pure genius. Making it an addicting game is great too. People love the social proof. I use stack overflow and its sister sites nearly every day. On theoretical computer science stack exchange its allowed me to ask better questions. It has increased my research maturity by one hundred times. I know more about topology and I am sincerely in debt to the quality of this concept and platform. Cheers to Jeff. This is his magnum opus. I can't wait what he thinks of next.
- codinghorror 14y agoIt is wonderful to read this. Self-improvement is the sort-of-hidden thing that all Stack Exchange sites are about. The best way to improve, in my opinion, is to teach your peers while learning from your peers.
- TazeTSchnitzel 14y agoStack Overflow is basically what Yahoo! Answers could be, but isn't. A brilliant resource with great questions, great answers, and a great community.
- Goladus 14y agoIt's certainly better than the alternatives that preceded it. I can't tell you how many times I've searched for <topic>, found my question in a forum about <topic>, and instead of answers or straightforward discussion I find a bunch of attitude from high-postcount forum jockeys saying "use the search function", "RTFM," changing the subject, and otherwise contributing lots of useless static noise (often they won't even bother to actually link a FAQ).
- gearoidoc 14y agoIs it just me or has the quality and quantity of answers dropped in the past year or so? I find SO perfect for the simple problems you have when you're new to a language/framework/whatever but when you get into the real nitty gritty problems its like nobodys home.
- willvarfar 14y agoMe too http://williamedwardscoder.tumblr.com/post/25426541504/stackoverflow-unwinding http://williamedwardscoder.tumblr.com/post/25426541504/stack...
- johnchristopher 14y agoedit: curse firefox and my "reply before reading every relevant tabs" habit, you are the poster I had in mind :) Hasn't the subject been touched recently on HN ? I think I remember a commenter stating that SO degraded because its popularity attracted a flock of "police of the forum mentality kind" posters who would close or move subject based on wording or overzealous sorting of questions in order to get gaming points and that made old and experienced posters go away in reaction.
- willvarfar 14y agoProbably, although the question got flagged down just as quickly as it got voted up sadly: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4131462 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4131462 As the mods say, nothing to see here, move along ;)
- yen223 14y agoCould simply be the case that all 'simple' questions have already been answered. Nitty-gritty problems tend to be the edge-cases that don't attract a lot of attention, hence fewer user participation. That said, StackOverflow is without a doubt the single best programmer resource out there.
- lightweb 14y agoThis is the basic problem with the current path most startups take, and indeed a real problem with business in America today. Venture Capital kills companies. The money changes it all. This applies to just about any business venture that involves investment by outside parties. There are obviously exceptions but usually when money gets involved, compromises start being made to make more money. This has disillusioned me for my entire 16yr career... I have never found a company that wasn't internally corrupted by money.
- willvarfar 14y ago> “I have some things in the hopper,” he says. “Communities are still the holy grail. What if you could make every site on the internet as good as it can be?" Speculation on what that might be? A curated disqus competitor, or?
- tubbo 14y agoDon't learn to code. Otherwise, you'll end up looking like this man: http://www.wired.com/wiredenterprise/?attachment_id=24755 http://www.wired.com/wiredenterprise/?attachment_id=24755
- josephscott 14y agoUnless the Internet involves using PHP, in which case he'd rather kill it :-)
- praptak 14y ago"The site zoomed past in Experts Exchange in terms of traffic in summer 2009, according to Alexa data Atwood posted to the StackOverflow blog." It looks even better nowadays. Experts-exchange now looks like statistical noise compared to stackoverflow: http://www.alexa.com/siteinfo/stackoverflow.com+experts-exchange.com#trafficstats http://www.alexa.com/siteinfo/stackoverflow.com+experts-exch... Serves them well for hiding community-provided information behind a paywall.
- acslater00 14y ago"But the biggest reason for the site’s success is the use of game mechanics." No. No no. No. It isn't. The biggest reason for the site's success is that it provides a really broad range of useful and detailed content in a useable (and search-indexable) format and doesn't charge for it. It helps that there is a community of thousands (millions?) of developers who need this information on a daily basis and keep going back to the site out of necessity. If the lesson you take from Stack Overflow is "Wow, I should really add game mechanics to my site. That'll do the trick!" you are simply beyond help.
- nopassrecover 14y agoThe thing is, listening to the early SO podcasts it was clear Jeff gave a lot of credit to the mechanics of the site. Clearly (and I'm pretty sure Joel gathered this) it was the combined critical mass from their blogs and the viral effect which led to a significant portion of the community allowing the site to become a "standard".
- mtrn 14y agoIt might not be the biggest reason, but game mechanics in a broad sense helps this site to rank answers - and that's a big part of what makes it stand out.
- afterburner 14y agoYou can credit the search and price, but for the content and community, the question is why did those come there in the first place? And perhaps search and price are the answer, but perhaps also word of mouth leading a critical mass of users also helped. And then the question is why did word get around in the first place. Marketing? Nice site design? Back to search and price? I can't tell because I started using it after it got big (or at least it feels that way). The upvote system, as always, also contributed a little I'm sure, as an encouragement to produce quality content. That kind of system seems a prerquisite at the very least, if not the reason for a site's success.
- nathan_long 14y agoWell, you're right, but: "provides a really broad range of useful and detailed content" ...which it gets from users. Who are motivated to contribute using game mechanics. No, you can't just slap a points mechanism at any site and magically make it great. But "get credit for your work" is a motivation that is basic to human nature. I say this as a longtime user with more than 10k points. I like helping others, but I must admit that having points to show for it is also a motivation.
- btilly 14y agoIronically I see this the day after I've decided to quit Stack Overflow due to interacting with moderators. For the last few months I've been in the habit of searching for algorithm questions, and answering them for fun. And then http://stackoverflow.com/questions/11314077/algorithm-for-exclusion-of-numbers/11317787 http://stackoverflow.com/questions/11314077/algorithm-for-ex... came along. It was the most fun algorithm question that I had seen in the last week. I put a fair amount of effort into rewriting a response I learned a nice trick from into a response that programmers with no theoretical background should be able to understand. But 4 moderators decided that it should be closed despite multiple votes, stars, and so on. I then asked at http://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/138678/can-we-please-reopen-this-programming-question http://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/138678/can-we-please... and the immediate response was that I got downvoted into oblivion, the question got deleted by clearly senior members of the community (it since has become undeleted, but there is no question what the "wise elders" think should have happened), and I got a lesson in what they really do and do not want to see on their site. I understand what they are aiming for, and clearly what I find fun is simply not a fit for what they want on their site. The site that they'd like me to go to instead is http://http://cs.stackexchange.com/ http://http://cs.stackexchange.com/. I looked. It is practically dead in comparison. What little does appear there seems strongly geared towards computer science students. Given that I'm self-taught in CS, I doubt I'll stay there. So, goodbye Stack Overflow. I wonder how many other people you don't see there any more.
- codinghorror 14y agoLooks like the community decided to re-open it. I agree it's on-topic, actually, since it is about algorithms and got good answers.
- btilly 14y agoWhat community reopened it? It did not get reopened until after I posted here, and people came from here to reopen it. The discussion on meta, and comments here from people who are clearly actively involved in site moderation on stack overflow, shows overwhelming agreement that it does not belong there. I would be willing to bet money that your opinion that it is on topic would come as a surprise to them. I would also be willing to bet money that if the question and answers came back to the attention of the majority of people on meta, it would immediately be closed and deleted again. If you think that this is a problem, perhaps you should say something publicly. Because it doesn't seem to be an isolated or even particularly unusual occurrence, and it is costing you contributers.