18 ms·
>> Russia is so corrupt, only a full scale revolution will have a chance at fixing the country Thank communism, because corruption was the only way for busines
by raverbashing 14y ago
>> Russia is so corrupt, only a full scale revolution will have a chance at fixing the country
Thank communism, because corruption was the only way for business to do any kind of transaction
- valisystem 14y agoWhile I agree that it probably did not help, you don't need communism to have such large scale problems, all you need is just a badly run country.
- pyre 14y agoCommunism as we know it? Yes. Communism as Marx envisioned it? No. It's all just semantics really: 1) In the US, 'socialism' is a dirty word, but don't you dare mess with Social Security or Medicaid. 2) China's 'communist' regime is called the "People's Republic of China." 3) Burma is now called "Republic of the Union of Myanmar" after a military coup. 4) China and the former USSR are both referred to as "Communist," but the governmental structures seem vastly different. 5) The Khmer Rouge were known as the 'Communist Party of Kampuchea,' but referred to their country as 'Democratic Kampuchea' even though they implemented forced relocation and confiscation of private property.
- danenania 14y agoI think all these semantic contradictions reveal a much more important truth: what -ism your government operates under or claims to operate under is about 1/1000th as significant as whether it aims to serve the people and respect the law. A corrupt communist state has much more in common with a corrupt capitalist state than with a respectable and well-run communist system, and vice versa. We should really focus a lot less on ideology in our politics and a lot more on basic ethics and accountability. Once we start getting those figured out, we can worry about the -isms.
- ajuc 14y agoAgreed, execution matters. But it's hard to miss the pattern - we have yet to see well run communist (not socialist) state. Every country that tried communism failed, and either are poor backwater countries (Kuba, North Korea), reverted to capitalism (Central and Eastern Europe), or kept communism on banners only, changing most of economy to capitalism under the hood (China). We even have a few case studies, where one country is divided into 2 parts, and one half is made communist. Both in East/West Germany, and North/South Korea the differences are quite obvious. Maybe it has sth to do with the system itself, after all?
- Aqwis 14y agoThe most well run communist state was probably Yugoslavia. I can see a few things which made it more successful than other communist states: it did not cut itself off from the world as a whole or associate itself with a much bigger and more powerful communist state and it allowed its citizens more personal freedoms than any other communist state. Of course it eventually collapsed due to internal and external pressure, but communism was not ousted due to a mass civil uprising (the wars were largely due to the policy of forcing a pan-Yugoslavian identity independent of pre-existing ethnic differences). In Slovenia, which only participated in the wars for a few days, the transition between communism and capitalism happened gradually and to my knowledge non-violently over 10 or so years.
- nathan_long 14y agoThis is anecdotal, but even within the same village, switching to capitalism has been known to radically increase production. I'd recommend this fascinating story from NPR's Planet Money: http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2012/01/20/145360447/the-secret-document-that-transformed-china http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2012/01/20/145360447/the-secr... Background: a group of farmers in a small Chinese village secretly agreed to start keeping their surplus crops for themselves. ============= Before the contract, the farmers would drag themselves out into the field only when the village whistle blew, marking the start of the work day. After the contract, the families went out before dawn. "We all secretly competed," says Yen Jingchang. "Everyone wanted to produce more than the next person." It was the same land, the same tools and the same people. Yet just by changing the economic rules — by saying, you get to keep some of what you grow — everything changed. At the end of the season, they had an enormous harvest: more, Yen Hongchang says, than in the previous five years combined.
- eru 14y ago> Communism as Marx envisioned it? No. Marx explicitly advocated a dictatorship. Dictatorship is what they got in the real world, too.
- molmalo 14y agoYou can find corruption all around the world, in places that were never under a communist regime. Corruption is a consequence of our human condition, not our economic system.