4 ms·

> There are some varieties of apple that can make you fat if you overeat them. Is there any food that won't make you fat if you overeat them? Generally "overea

> There are some varieties of apple that can make you fat if you overeat them. Is there any food that won't make you fat if you overeat them? Generally "overeating" is what makes you fat.

rootusrootus 2y ago
Sure, that is technically correct, which as they say is the best kind of correct. But as a practical matter, getting enough calories from granny smith apples to get fat is not feasible. On the other hand, you might have a shot if you developed a hankering for honeycrisps. More sugar, less fiber, way less protein.
- Modified3019 2y ago
  Incidentally green apples are the only ones I still enjoy either raw or cooked, because they aren’t sickeningly sweet, and they store decently so they are on hand when I want one.
  - PittleyDunkin 2y ago
    > Incidentally green apples are the only ones I still enjoy either raw or cooked, because they aren’t sickeningly sweet, and they store decently so they are on hand when I want one. Color has little bearing on nutrition, but I assume you mean "granny smiths" here which renders your comment understandable.
    - positr0n 2y ago
      At least in the USA Granny Smith and green apple are synonymous. I don't think I've ever seen another type of green apple at a normal grocery store.
- PittleyDunkin 2y ago
  > But as a practical matter, getting enough calories from granny smith apples to get fat is not feasible. Sure, that's exactly what Big Apple wants you to believe. > On the other hand, you might have a shot if you developed a hankering for honeycrisps. More sugar, less fiber, way less protein. This seems equally ridiculous to me—who wants to eat more than two honeycrisps in a sitting? And that's seriously pushing it, especially compared to basically any other sugary food (including, say, juice and rice). At least use "apple pie" to make this believable.

4 ms·

> There are some varieties of apple that can make you fat if you overeat them. Is there any food that won't make you fat if you overeat them? Generally "overea

by PittleyDunkin 2y ago

> There are some varieties of apple that can make you fat if you overeat them. Is there any food that won't make you fat if you overeat them? Generally "overeating" is what makes you fat.

rootusrootus 2y ago
Sure, that is technically correct, which as they say is the best kind of correct. But as a practical matter, getting enough calories from granny smith apples to get fat is not feasible. On the other hand, you might have a shot if you developed a hankering for honeycrisps. More sugar, less fiber, way less protein.
- Modified3019 2y ago
  Incidentally green apples are the only ones I still enjoy either raw or cooked, because they aren’t sickeningly sweet, and they store decently so they are on hand when I want one.
  - PittleyDunkin 2y ago
    > Incidentally green apples are the only ones I still enjoy either raw or cooked, because they aren’t sickeningly sweet, and they store decently so they are on hand when I want one. Color has little bearing on nutrition, but I assume you mean "granny smiths" here which renders your comment understandable.
    - positr0n 2y ago
      At least in the USA Granny Smith and green apple are synonymous. I don't think I've ever seen another type of green apple at a normal grocery store.
- PittleyDunkin 2y ago
  > But as a practical matter, getting enough calories from granny smith apples to get fat is not feasible. Sure, that's exactly what Big Apple wants you to believe. > On the other hand, you might have a shot if you developed a hankering for honeycrisps. More sugar, less fiber, way less protein. This seems equally ridiculous to me—who wants to eat more than two honeycrisps in a sitting? And that's seriously pushing it, especially compared to basically any other sugary food (including, say, juice and rice). At least use "apple pie" to make this believable.