2 ms·
> In the meanwhile the most important people in tech including Nvidia CEO, Sam, Hinton, Musk So, two people with a major vested interest, someone who has a pas
by rsynnott 2y ago
> In the meanwhile the most important people in tech including Nvidia CEO, Sam, Hinton, Musk
So, two people with a major vested interest, someone who has a past record of making ludicrously over-optimistic claims about this stuff (yes, Geoffrey, we still need radiologists), and, well, do I really need to address Musk?
I mean, if you’re going to do an argument to authority, you can probably do better than this.
People have been claiming that we won’t need programmers anymore any day now for, at this point, about 65 years (entertainingly, this started with COBOL, the theory being that managers could just use COBOL to tell the computer what to do).
- arisAlexis 2y ago[flagged]
- rsynnott 2y agoI mean, it's evidently disturbing _you_, but really I'm not sure why. Today's LLM-based programming tools are obviously not going to replace human programmers. So really all you've got is forward-looking claims from some people who largely have a history of making incorrect forward-looking claims, and/or are making claims about something far outside their area of expertise.
- arisAlexis 2y agoI mean I really don't understand how: you can think that today's llms are going to be the same tomorrow as scaling is exponential, it's non sensical thinking to me and 2) how there is expert consensus on it but still not get it. That's why I made the thread. It doesn't bother me at all, I'm not in the field anymore I made the thread to see how far detached is the tech crowd from what is happening.
- rsynnott 2y ago> you can think that today's llms are going to be the same tomorrow as scaling is exponential Irrelevant (even if true, which is far from established); they're still not going to suddenly become capable of reasoning. They will still 'hallucinate' (terrible euphemism, that, but we are where we are). > how there is expert consensus on it but still not get it. Only one of the people you mentioned could be considered an expert (Hinton). And he's an expert his a history of very wrong predictions about this sort of thing. There is _by no means_ expert consensus on this.