4 ms·
"Any simple major enhancement to human intelligence is a net evolutionary disadvantage." An individual who is more intelligent might be less likely to pass on
by Alex3917 14y ago
"Any simple major enhancement to human intelligence is a net evolutionary disadvantage."
An individual who is more intelligent might be less likely to pass on their own genes, but may well make the species as a whole more resilient. Looking at evolution from the perspective of the individual is a mistake.
- pjscott 14y agoHow would helping "the species as a whole" increase the frequency of that person's genetic traits in the population? It sounds very pretty and virtuous -- get ahead by helping others, hooray -- but the math just doesn't work.
- karamazov 14y agoThis could work through group selection - on average, groups containing more intelligent individuals would outcompete groups not containing them. However, this requires a scenario with group competition, and probably also requires substantially more time than individual selection for the dynamic to play out.
- Alex3917 14y ago"How would helping 'the species as a whole' increase the frequency of that person's genetic traits in the population?" I mean that's pretty much just standard evolutionary theory. C.f. sickle cell anemia.
- pjscott 14y agoHow so? Having the sickle cell trait (i.e. being heterozygous for the gene which, in homozygous individuals, causes sickle cell anemia) gives an advantage to individual evolutionary fitness in areas where malaria is a big problem. There's no need for group selection arguments to explain the prevalence of that trait.
- monkeypizza 14y agoWow, people really hate group selection! Last thing I saw on it was a blogging heads video [0], which convinced me it's not as dead as I thought it was. [0] http://bloggingheads.tv/videos/2361 http://bloggingheads.tv/videos/2361
- rcthompson 14y agoWould you care to support your assertion that "looking at evolution from the perspective of the individual is a mistake"? The individual is the fundamental "biological unit" through which human genes are propogated (same for non-genetic vectors of heritable traits, such as epigenetic signatures and memes), and the individual is also the level at which selection acts. Since evolution is all about selection of and propogation of genes, in what sense is it a mistake to look at evolution at the level where both of these phenomena act? Note that being "less likely to pass on their own genes" means exactly the same thing here as having a "net evolutionary disadvantage", so your comment is actually agreeing with the sentence that you quoted, despite what appears to be your intent. Regardless, there is a valid discussion to be had about evolution at levels other than the individual, but it's just not as simple as replacing individuals with species as the biological unit of evolution.
- Cushman 14y agoAn individual does not evolve, it either reproduces or not. Individuals have never been the "biological unit" of evolution; evolution is a process of populations by definition. Edit: To make it a little more clear what this means, treating the organism as the unit of evolution is like treating the cell as the unit of walking. Yes, walking is the action of individual cells, but nothing interesting or relevant to the process is happening at a cellular level.
- rcthompson 14y agoCorrect, an individual does not evolve, but the process of evolution is the result of selection on and reproduction of individuals. You can't just change it to be about selection on and reproduction of populations and then treat the individual-level stuff as an implementation detail that you can ignore.
- Cushman 14y agoEvolution is the result of the reproduction of populations of individuals. A single organism reproducing once is a non-event, evolutionarily speaking. This implies effects in the population that are counterintuitive from the perspective of the individual, which is why it's important to make the distinction.